After reading all the posts in this thread, I've come to the shocking conclusion that I know almost nothing about Pink Floyd, even though they are one of my favorite bands. Regardless I like PF without Waters more than I like Waters without PF. David Gilmour's solo albums I also enjoy more than Water's solo material, Roger just seems to be so depressing most of the time, I think one of the major reasons the band fragmented was they were tired of his Domineering Presence doing all the writing and not giving them a chance to contribute more of their own songs. So I'll have to say I think Gilmour is the more talented of the two main powers behind the post-Barrett PF.
|