Your Favorite Weapon is actually my favorite album from Brand New. The first songs I ever heard from Brand New were Mix Tape and Failure by Design and I'd have to agree the Jude Law and a Semester Abroad is the best track.
I think it's just as deep as The Devil and God are Raging inside me, just in a different context. The bluntness and honesty in their lyricism is the most prevalent in this album.
Good review mate.