Quote:
Originally Posted by right-track
[I]Elbow's Mercury Prize-winning album The Seldom Seen Kid is UK music critics' album of the year, a survey says.
The "poll of polls", conducted by retail chain HMV, took into account votes from media critics as well as the firm's staff and online customers.
|
So, the poll took into account votes from the firm's staff and online customers. So much for it being the 'UK
music critics' album of the year. Lolz.
The claim, as far as goes media critics, is without any shadow of a doubt untrue: Elbow's record is very scarcely regarded as the album of the year in any critical circles. Hell, even Q magazine couldn't fit it in their top 5.
Quote:
Originally Posted by lucifer_sam
They're all indie albums. What an amazing coincidence.
|
It is true that the UK music journalist community is heavily indie-oriented (as is the generality of the more widely read American music media community, as evidenced by looking at data on compendium sites like Metacritic), but I think there is a single very good reason why this year there was nothing from outside of indie at all in this list: whatever one might think about the quality of the indie music that came out this year, it would be hard to argue that there were many particularly worthy releases from other sectors of the popular music spectrum. It was not really a great year for any one genre of music. What indie has on its side is a vast quantity of widely accessible albums to choose from, so it's bound to hit with about 15 or so well-circulated records a year. It has no competition from mainstream pop, for which the albums almost invariably consist of about 2 or 3 hits and the rest filler. It has no competition from metal, which is far too niche these days. It also has little competition from non-mainstream hiphop, which has seen a massive decrease in the amount of widely accessible albums in circulation over the past 3 years. Other broad genres (and their sub-genres), similarly, are much too niche to really hit these lists - e.g. minimal techno.
In summary, these lists
have to be indie oriented, because there's not an awful lot else in terms of album music that's widely listened to in the readership community.