Music Banter - View Single Post - HMV Poll of Polls 2008
View Single Post
Old 12-30-2008, 03:11 PM   #8 (permalink)
Rainard Jalen
Music Addict
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 2,219
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by lucifer_sam View Post
lol

I wasn't making a statement about the releases this year, just expressing my distaste for the unilateral ****pile of music that critics divulge. The indie community is so ****ing insular -- I didn't really expect end-of-year lists to breach music beyond indie's repertoire. I know it wasn't a very good year, but there were plenty of releases which deserve recognition, especially hip-hop and metal albums.
The problem, as I see it, is that it is society that determines the nature of these lists. Cultural journalism is essentially a manifestation of widespread demand. These critics are not laws unto themselves - they answer to their readership. In order to succeed as journalists, they must put out material that a big enough audience actually want to read.

Fashion, in that case, is really the supreme arbiter of taste. Indie is widely fashionable, so the main tide of critical journalism must cater to indie. Metal and alternative hip-hop are more niche and far less in distribution. In a society where metal was the main type of alternative music listened to (and the most recorded), the end of year lists would have a massive metal bias.

I'd go as far as to argue that metal and hip-hop, in general, ought not to be recognized at all in these webzines because, plain and simply, those genres have little to do with these sites' readership. They don't belong. There are webzines that deal exclusively with other genres - people interested in those genres will go and read those sites. Aside from that, where do you stop? To be completely free of bias to one genre, a site would have to include compositions from the avant garde, obscure electronica recordings, and so forth. Nah. Critics should stick with their areas of specialty. Otherwise it gets embarrassing. I always laugh whenever Pitchfork throw in their token hip-hop album into an end of year list - especially since the album is usually one of the most banal, least interesting hip-hop releases of the year.
Rainard Jalen is offline   Reply With Quote