The reason I rated it higher than 9 is because it's not a complete compromise in their sound. It's an album of subtleties as opposed to surprises (Wowee Zowee), hooks (Crooked Rain) or energy (Slanted). Pavement without Brighten The Corners just wouldn't feel as well rounded a band, not as diverse, as they do with it. Somewhere along the 8 scale would have been more fitting in retrospect, but I think it deserves a 9.2. I think people should consider it more seriously.
After Terror Twilight, I'll adjust the scores when comparing each album with the other. You'll see the scores change drastically.
|