Music Banter - View Single Post - Mogwai
Thread: Mogwai
View Single Post
Old 06-24-2009, 08:25 PM   #182 (permalink)
Engine
air quote
 
Engine's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: pollen & mold
Posts: 3,112
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Veridical Fiction View Post
Ok, I think I've given myself enough time to make a personal judgment about Mogwai.
I got all the albums and listened for a week or so, and personally, nothing they do is very interesting to me.
In fact, I find their music rather boring.
I guess it would be OK to use as mood music very low in the background, but nothing of theirs really jumps out at me in an inspirational way.
In fact, I find myself a bit depressed after listening to their stuff.

It's not that everything I listen to is extreme in any way, but I like to be engaged in music, and Mogwai doesn't provide that.

So I guess I'll just let the torrent seed 100 percent and delete it after that. No sense in taking up space on my drives. Sorry Mogwai.
That made me a little sad for some reason.
I think it's because I can see myself having the exact same reaction if that was my experience. For me it was like: a friend recommends Young Team and I was lukewarm to it for a while but came to love it - and all their previous stuff. Then Come On Die Young came out and I remember that day well because I had a friend drop me off at a record store after work so that I could buy the CD. I had brought my discman and I walked the 2 or so miles home listening to it. At first I was terribly disappointed. I wanted those big sounds that I heard in Young Team and 10 Rapid. They didn't come. Instead it was all mellowed-out post rock bliss that I eventually also came to love (I still count it as one of my favorite albums).
Anyway, they proceeded to make a lot more music that was hit or miss and I can see writing them off as boring. But for me a lot of their music is as engaging as it gets.
Engine is offline   Reply With Quote