^I'd have to go with the Coheed out of those
All That Remains - Empty Inside
Rush - Limelight
Killswitch Engage - The Arms of Sorrow
The Arcade Fire - Black Mirror
Metallica - The Call of Ktulu
City and Colour - Sleeping Sickness
David Nevue - It Is Well With My Soul
Scary Kids Scaring Kids - A Breath of Sunshine
Alexisonfire - Side Walk When She Walks
Boston - To Be a Man
Out of those ten choices I'd have to go with City and Colour, but All That Remains is a very close (and very different) second. And that's probably my least favorite Boston song.