Music Banter - View Single Post - Covers vs Original
View Single Post
Old 09-11-2009, 02:09 AM   #15 (permalink)
Liljagare
Music Addict
 
Liljagare's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: Sweden
Posts: 182
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Janszoon View Post
I have to say I've never understood why so many people like the Cash version better. I like Johnny Cash a lot and he has a lot of great covers in his back catalogue but "Hurt" isn't one of them. He and Rick Rubin basically removed everything that was interesting and good about the original and turned it into an incredibly bland folk song. Give me the Reznor version any day of the week.
I think that Johnny Cash's version of Hurt is alot more personal then the NIN version. One has to think that he made it right before he died (his last single) and his wife had just died..so it seemed to me to have alot more feeling than the NIN original. The original is very good but Cash's remake seemed to just have a bit more to it than just the melancholy. Cash had lived a long life and it seems to me that that particualar song just encompasses all the regret, sadness, longing he might have felt at that time. But that is just me. Nothing wrong with liking the original more. And I too have never heard anyone saying that the Cash version was the original...

There have been so many remakes it is almost imposssible to count. I never really minded remakes as long as they were done well and perhaps had a new spin on the original (example: "Mad World" - Tears for Fears original, Gary Jules/Micheal Andrews cover). I don't really enjoy when they remake a tune, put it into a complete new genre, and then market it as a dance version of the original (example: Ultravox "Hymn" and Music Instructors version). Dance versions seem to usually destroy what probably was a perfectly good song to begin with. Also, I wished they would admit that it was a remake once in a while rather than just market it as a completly new song (although they do on the cds, but it isn't marketed that way). But that is just me.
Liljagare is offline   Reply With Quote