Out of all these posts so far id be more inclined to lean more towards what Jackhammer said when thinking about what my own response would be.
I listen to different kinds of music for different moods and for different reasons so i dont think i have an exclusive set of rules for what i think makes a good band. If anything the rules would change depending on what i was listening to. Lyrics are imporant to me for SOME bands, lyricists that make me want to sit and actually read the inlay whether im listening to the album at the time or not. Lyrics that i find inspiration in or personally relate to in some way. In other bands i would say creating an atmosphere and whatever that atmosphere is, it would be something i can complete get lost in and really feel that record from start to end. Sometimes im looking for something that isnt clever, is in no way experimental or even original but is plain balls to the wall energy.
However no matter what the rules are, what exactly im listening to or what im looking for from the band im listening to i guess i would say any band that knows exactly what they want to be and how they want to sound and don't allow themselves to stray from that would be the most important thing to me. If a band makes the music they want to make rather than making the music they think their largest potential audience would pay to listen to or conforming with any current trends to make money their top priority and therefore probably jumping on every bandwagon going over the course of their career then im likely to be able to give them props for that.
|