Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
What I'd like to know about these forums you frequented is what the site did to push itself to a new level of discussion. Music, like sports, never seems to end. The idea that they couldn't keep talking about sports concerns me. So was it guys showing up wanting to talk about the 62 world series or were they popping in to tell you how nasty the Yankees were?
|
Yeah, with more information on the specific topic coming in constantly it seems like a board is a going concern. But, the amount of things to talk about dwindles over time. This is kind of dumb and obvious, but it's what popped into my head:
Let's say there are 100 musical events from the past to talk about, 100 bands in existence to talk about, and 5 new things each day to talk about. Over time - a span of maybe 5 years in an online forum - the 100 events are thoroughly discussed, each of the 100 bands has its own thread that has been discusses to death, and the 5 new things continue to pop up each day. With all of the past and all of the bands covered, all that's left to talk about is day-to-day events, which is why "LOUNGE" forums tend to become more and more popular to post in (more so than music, in this case). Once you've made a thread chronicling the top 100 guitarists in history, there is no need for a new discussion on the exact same thing 2 years later... It's there in stone, and done.
With sports- you've chronicled the most clutch performances, the 1945 World Series, the greatest hockey player of all time, whether there should be instant replay, whether or not college players should be paid, whether or not LT is the greatest RB of all time, the 2007 footy season.... This is interchangeable with any forum topic: music, sports, POG collecting... And you run out.
My thoughts on keeping everything fresh:
-Solid mod crew.
-More debates (where ^ is important).
-Build off of music recommendations and swapping: One of the coolest thread ideas I saw was one where each month a user picks a random album for another one to listen to.
-Concert revues/photo sharing. I was pretty surprised when I came here that there isn't much in terms of sharing concert experiences. I know there's the member journals and picture thread, but people don't use those for that too often it seems.
-Out of the box creativity with music posts: not just "Top 100 Drummers", "Favorite Album".
-If possible, lower the lounge activity: Merge subforums? Posting incentives (since you don't get credit for posting in the lounge)? Something.
2ยข