Music Banter - View Single Post - The Official Captain Beefheart Thread
View Single Post
Old 12-13-2009, 06:56 PM   #11 (permalink)
lucifer_sam
Unrepentant Ass-Mod
 
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Pennsylvania
Posts: 3,921
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Schizotypic View Post
I watched a documentary on Beefheart last night and am not entirely convinced the man's a genius. I mean what is the appeal, if I'm going to spend who knows how much time spinning one of these, I need to know the appeal. Is it just to be Beefheart fan?

Ry Cooder, Frank Zappa, Muddy Waters, easily, I could understand. What's so great about Beefheart? I heard one guy in the documentary say he had the core blue's sounds of of Howlin' Wolf with time signatures of Ornette Coleman, is it true? Is it good? What do you guys like about it? I mean the guy seems kinda spaced out to me and the only person who produced his music really was Zappa... and if I had guess that was only because they were friends and to stop any future suicide attempts after the Monera Pop Festival. I think Beefheart with all his anxiety attacks, odd ideas, anti-social and often erratic and dangerous behavior must've either been a genius like so many say... or he was just plain out psychotic.

What do you guys like about him again?
i'm not quite sure what you're trying to say here, but allow me to explain something...

Frank Zappa's production was the WORST thing to happen to the Magic Band. his financial constrictions prevented the instrumentals on Trout Mask Replica from sounding anywhere near their intended quality, to ill effect. in fact, the time constraints he placed upon the band (they recorded the instrumentals within four hours) prevented second-takes in most situations and offered an air of novice and ineptitude to the whole band, which could not have been further from what they were trying to accomplish. the two songs on the album which sound truly impressive (Moonlight on Vermont, Veteran's Day Poppy) are coincidentally the two that were recorded at a different session with an entirely different set of engineers.

had Beefheart chosen a suitable replacement for producer they might have elicited a much stronger sound and consequently better album. the problem was Frank Zappa's label was unwilling to provide the necessary funds and technicians to promote anything greater than what they had accomplished.
__________________
first.am
lucifer_sam is offline   Reply With Quote