I'll assume you meant to say you
wouldn't rate any GnR album as your favorite rock/metal of all time.
I loved those albums when they came out. I even pre-ordered them, the first time I pre-ordered music evar! "You Could be Mine" was the shiz! That said, one of the few times I had the radio on in the past few years I heard it...and it sounded like total sh
it. The vocals were so whiny and terrible. Bleh!! I couldn't believe I used to go gagga for that song. I couldn't even tell you whether I liked I or II better, don't remember.
Favorite rock/metal album of all time? Ha! There are way too many rock albums I love to choose one. Specific to metal and not rock as a whole, that might be easier. But still not easy.