Yeah, I suppose commercial would be a good word to describe a few of their tunes. I personally wouldn't use that word to describe them to someone, because it just makes it sounds bad I think. Even if some of their songs would reach out to a mainstream crowd...they're just done so well that it doesn't even bother me in the slightest, and I still enjoy them immensely.
I do think Countereit is "a grower" though, yeah. It's enjoyable the first few listens, but once you give it those extra spins and start learning the in's and out's of every song, you really start to appreciate the album as a whole so much more.
If you wanna check out the first two CDs just lemme know btw, pm or whatever.