I'm arguing that his post defeats itself. If everything is just about survival, why are we even having this conversation? I understand that you're both trying to "defeat" me and might get some sort of residual biological satisfaction out of this, but ultimately there is something more going on here. Language isn't just about communicating survival tips, it goes deeper, it's about trying to find out who we are, to find ourselves through the other. It's about meaning, which is a state where two different consciousnesses can converge on a single understanding. If meaning didn't contain some bliss apart from its application, language would never have gone beyond the point of describing buffalos and weather conditions. We never would have developed philosophy, or religion, or poetry, or that music we're all so mysteriously obsessed with. If you disagree, follow the scientific attitude all the way into its nihilism. Everything is for the sake of its own survival, so why should it be? Even pleasure is just there for the sake of survival, but what's so great about survival in itself, if it's just a pointless, circular journey between pleasure and pain? Everything is pointless but only because we want it to have a point...
|