[QUOTE=The Ice Plant;846661][FONT="Palatino Linotype"](I can't post links yet, so no album cover)
[
[SIZE="3"]One of the things that makes the Beatles the best is that each album they released represents a progression from the previous one. Please Please Me is generally not very good, but With the Beatles, despite maintaining the same basic sound, represents a huge step forward, paving the way for A Hard Day's Night, their first creative breakthrough. Beatles For Sale is to A Hard Day's Night what With the Beatles is to Please Please Me, a transitional album, and while the next three albums the Beatles released (Rubber Soul, Revolver, Sgt. Pepper…) receive more attention historically, Help! could be considered the band's second creative breakthrough. It often is overlooked because the next five (!!) albums the band released (the three mentioned in the previous sentence, The White Album, Abbey Road) all could make a serious case to be considered the best album of all time.
I've got to take issue with some of that.
a-imo they didn't make any real progression for the first 5 U.K albums. I think any song that could have appeared on Help! could have been written for PPM. Musically, outside of the fact that all the songs were different, i don't think they moved forward musically and not very much lyrically.
b-The breakthroughs started with Norwegian wood (the first song recorded for RS) and came thick and fast, often from song to song rather than album to album from then on
c-I love the white album and Abbey rd. but they are both, imo, over-rated. They both great albums but i don't think any of them have the consistency of quality to put them in the greatest album ever made catagory.
|