Quote:
|
You can't simply say that you are enjoying the music, not the words and be taken seriously. It's like saying a black and white minstrel show would be acceptable because you like the vaudeville , not the offensive racial stereotypes. You couldn't possible say its fine to like SS marching band music because its quite stirring but don't support anti Semitic genocide. In those cases the whole form of the art is tainted by its context and purpose.
|
Yes, you can say that and be taken seriously. Not only
can you do so, if you want to be taken seriously in a discussion of art you
need to do so.
Let's use film as an example. It's widely accepted in critical film circles that "Birth of a Nation" is, if not the greatest film ever made, one of the best. This despite the fact that it raises all sorts of hairs on the back of your typically PC film critic; as not only were the filmmakers openly racist, but the whole point of the film was to incite racism. Or let's go in the opposite political direction; "The Battleship Potemkin" was a propaganda piece by one of the bloodiest dicatorships in human history, a regime which spread misery and genocide throughout several continents. Yet, it too is rightly regarded as a masterpiece.
To shrug off these and other artworks because they don't meet the requirements of some absurd politically correct litmus test is
retarded. It's retarded because it denies the humanity of artists and offers a crass distortion of reality. Further, doing so does not lead to the growth of art but to it's retardation.
Quote:
|
So you think a minority male born in an inner city (in the United States) with a broken education system, surrounded by the life styles they are surrounded by have the same access to higher education and prosperity as a white male from a suburban area (like myself) has?
|
Why do you imply that the race of the individuals in these situations is somehow as important as the economic situations they were born into? Poverty is available to all races, as is the ability to escape it. Take a look at what the Jewish people managed to accomplish; they were the victims of systemic discrimination for millenia, suffered innumerable pogroms which culminated in the single greatest race-specific attrocity in human history (the holocaust).... and they not only went on to create a thriving nation in a desert, but created such prosperity while defenind their nation from endless foreign aggression.
If the success of Israel shows us anything, it's that any people can overcome adversity and achieve greatness.