Quote:
Originally Posted by Aswad Vogelenzang
This Charming Man wasn't originally on the album, it's only been tagged on for the re-issues (same as How Soon Is Now wasn't on Meat Is Murder).
|
I stand corrected. It was really a crass mistake to make, I could have easily found that information on Wikipedia.
Quote:
The Smiths debut has it's moments but they were a band who did the inverted V in terms of musical progression, starting off, getting better, peaking in roughly the middle of their career and then going down again.
I'd go as far as to say that many of these songs were done better before or after the release of the album.
The single version of 'Hand In Glove' is far superior to the album cut, tracks like 'You've Got Everything Now' and 'Reel Around The Fountain' were better in their BBC sessions form and I've always much preferred the live version of 'Still Ill' from 'Rank' where Morrissey really gets much more emotion in his voice.
|
While I admit I haven't listened to the single version of "Hand In Glove" (and I'd quite like to, heard wonders of the 7'' version) or the BBC sessions rendition of the aforementioned songs, I find these claims entirely subjective. Not only that, I find the Rank version of Still Ill dreadful, so I'm having trouble understanding your point.
I shall post the Troy Tate Sessions review shortly.