Music Banter - View Single Post - Covers
Thread: Covers
View Single Post
Old 06-18-2010, 05:23 PM   #385 (permalink)
dankrsta
...
 
dankrsta's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Posts: 1,776
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by clutnuckle View Post
TMC were disrespectful by their attempt at blatant mimicry. The Residents were trying to go about it that way, where as TMC just failed at being parrots. It sounds dated, down-tuned for commercialism, everything that Tim Buckley's version doesn't sound like. It's not a 'totally different' take. It's an attempt to cash in on EXACTLY what Tim did. It ranks among the worst covers of all-time. I don't have anything against covers when they aren't so drenched in selfishness.
I've never felt this cover was an attempt at blatant mimicry. For me it is a different take. It doesn't have to be The Residents type of approach, when you almost can't recognize the song, to be considered a different take.

And I've never understood this criticism that something sounds dated. What does that even mean exactly? That the song is a product of its time? Since when is that a bad thing?

I don't care what motivation This Mortal Coil had when they did this cover - be it cashing in and commercialism or a genuine artistic inspiration. All I know is that I love this song, it has a certain magnetic power to me. When I hear it, I can't stop listening to it. Maybe it's because I first heard it in "Lost Highway", one of my favorite films. I don't know.

By the way, this discussion is pretty pointless. You hate this cover with a passion and I like it very much. We're obviously not going to change our minds.
__________________
dankrsta is offline   Reply With Quote