Jane's Addiction FTW. To be fair, I probably picked a stronger Jane's song, but I figured it would be close because FNM has a lot of fans on here (and apparently their fair share of haters).
I NEED NOMS!
Now then, another pick of mine, Battle Chapel Hill:
'The First Part' by Superchunk - Foolish (1994)
vs.
'Web in Front' by Archers of Loaf - Icky Mettle (1994)