My take on how this should be done, for what's it's worth.
No criticism, just opinion.
Seeing as this is supposed to be a fun project;
Nominations: By nominations I mean plural, ie; more than one nomination in the category per nominator. Maybe 3 maximum? No less than 2.
Voting: After nominations are collected the top 3 members for each category are put up for voting.
Why? Because during the current nomination round a member may not have voted for any of the final top 3 and their second (unknown) choice may have progressed to the voting round giving them the opportunity to vote again.
Again this will be done publicly (not via pm) as with the nomination round.
Why? Because it's more fun.
|