Another couple of good reviews
In the Land of Grey and Pink is a brilliantly charming little record, I think. I probably have more love for Golf Girl than you do. I even love it's use of the trumpet. The real stars for me are the title track and Nine Feet Underground. Brilliant tunes!
Waterloo Lily is alright too, I think! It's not an imposing album. It doesn't make me sit up, sorta, but songs you mention like the title track, Aristocracy and The World is Yours are good and comfortable listens if not mind blowing (blowing minds isn't a very Caravanish thing to do anyways). I even like Songs and signs! I think Miller leaving again was probably a good thing for the band, though, considering my love for the next in line.