Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Classical (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/)
-   -   The Most Underrated Composer (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/25763-most-underrated-composer.html)

ADELE 07-20-2008 04:59 PM

Has anyone mentioned Sergio Leone?
Spagetti Westerns genre.

jackhammer 07-21-2008 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ADELE (Post 499223)
Has anyone mentioned Sergio Leone?
Spagetti Westerns genre.

Sergio Leone was the director of many of these not the composer. For that you want Ennio Morricone who is a brilliant composer but certainly not underated.

ADELE 07-21-2008 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 499523)
Sergio Leone was the director of many of these not the composer. For that you want Ennio Morricone who is a brilliant composer but certainly not underated.

Yeah that's the guy.
I remember now as I have the album of the theme music.

Would he be put amoung the greats though?
Or is that just a matter of time.

jackhammer 07-21-2008 03:47 PM

Definitely great:

Ennio Morricone discography - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

nevadajames 08-22-2008 10:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Exodizer (Post 410700)
What do you guys think. I think personally is Josquin Des Prez. He was a Renaissance Composer and wrote varations on Gegorian Chants and also Masses. He mastered polyphonic harmony using mostly imiatation. It's really good music if you like Choral stuff. His music is hard to find also, but it's worth it if you do. So who do you guys think is the most underrated?

Have to agree, Josquin was considered the greatest composer of his day by his contemporaries. The motet De profundis clamavi is definitely worth a listen.

MoxieMan 08-23-2008 07:20 PM

Modest Petrovitch Mussorgsky.

Too often remembered as "That fat Russian dude who wrote piano stuff for people..."

X-One 09-03-2008 09:53 PM

I'd have to say Alexander Scriabin.. his pieces are genius, especially Etude Op.8 No.12 ..

classylady 09-18-2008 11:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by X-One (Post 514167)
I'd have to say Alexander Scriabin.. his pieces are genius, especially Etude Op.8 No.12 ..

I 100% agree, but I'm more into the Prelude Op. 74 No. 2...Yeah I know it's more popular, but it really shows how deranged his mind worked and how it transposed into his music.

Ludicati 09-24-2008 06:41 PM

LOL, the topic is about "underrated" composer and you're talking about Bach Chopin and Beethoven... I think the human respiratory system is underrated lmao

and I'll agree with X-One, Scriabin would be my choice too, less accessible but incredible if you bother listening carefully. etude op 8 no 12 is one of my favorite (Evgeny Kissin has the best recording of it on youtube)

MusicNerd92 10-12-2008 01:19 AM

Honestly? I would say all composers that are underrated are the ones that people that do not play or know much about classical music do not know.
If you mention Beethoven, Mozart, or Bach, they'll know.
But if you mention Debussy, Schumann, or Prokofiev, they'll have no idea..
My theory may be incorrect, but that's what I think.

FireInCairo 10-12-2008 03:00 AM

Vangelis...just to be different

Zarko 10-14-2008 12:00 AM

Probably not so much underrated by peers or classical aficionado's, but probably less well known than deserves to be so would be Cesar Franck. Fairly unsuccessful in his time though.

RoemerMW 10-14-2008 12:04 AM

Philip Glass, Frank Zappa and Steve Reich are pretty underrated in my opinion.

Zarko 10-14-2008 12:08 AM

I agree, but with Zappa I think it has more to do with not being known or recognized of his classical work, but rather with his rock and jazz-rock work.

RoemerMW 10-14-2008 08:25 AM

Yeah. I meant Zappa's classical work, his rock and jazz albums aren't really underrated.

4ZZZ 10-14-2008 08:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by UberFilmBuff (Post 530678)
Philip Glass, Frank Zappa and Steve Reich are pretty underrated in my opinion.

I am a massive fan of Reich. I am of the opinion that he is the most influential Classical musician in terms of crossover appeal over the last 50 years. His 60's tape loop work is astonishing. It's Gonna Rain and Come Out where ahead of their time and IMO the likes of Pink Floyd through to Eno through to just about every electronic artist owes Reich a debt of gratitude. Eno in fact mentions him on the cover notes for My Life From The Bush Of Ghosts for Come Out alone. An incredible piece of tape loop minimalism. I find it spellbinding though I do realise that it may not be to everyone's taste.

I could rave about his work for ages. Drumming, Music For 18 Musicians and Different Trains for example. Wonderful stuff.


And for those that may find that a bit daunting maybe Reich Remixed.

http://www.discogs.com/image/R-150-27570-001.jpg

P.S. I am a Glass fan as well. As to Zappa I don't know enough though Zarko tells me I should get into him a bit more and intend to take his advice.

badmusicisbad 10-24-2008 08:49 AM

Erik Satie and Oliver Messiaen

Son_of_Mr_Greengenes 10-31-2008 12:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 419681)
OK Frank Zappa. His classical pieces are phenomenal and disgustingly underated.

I thank you for mentioning Zappa. I encourage anyone to get the album, "Yellow Shark" as a representation of his orchestral composing prowess. I would also like to mention John Cage, as he is genius and I feel he has been hidden from me.

loldongs 11-03-2008 10:34 AM

something tells me i have to bring up salieri.

Fallout_at_The_Disco 11-03-2008 09:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 415685)
Chopin. his pieces are excersises in simple elegancy.

I agree that Chopin was amazing and wonderful, but I wouldn't call him underrated. He's been well credited and recognized for his brilliance.

Dr_Rez 11-03-2008 10:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by loldongs (Post 539447)
something tells me i have to bring up salieri.

He was so overshadowed by Mozart, so he never really got the attention he probably deserved.

Astronomer 11-05-2008 09:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by agoodw1 (Post 422664)
debussy

agreed.

And Chopin isn't underrated is he? Growing up I learnt tons of his stuff on piano. But maybe that's just because I was learning classical piano. But anyway he is certainly one of my favourites.

NoUserName 11-11-2008 08:51 PM

Not too underrated but I'll go with Carl Philipp Emanuel Bach. his work is great and I actually prefer it to J S Bach.

Anti-Christ 11-11-2008 11:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lateralus (Post 541101)
agreed.

And Chopin isn't underrated is he? Growing up I learnt tons of his stuff on piano. But maybe that's just because I was learning classical piano. But anyway he is certainly one of my favourites.

I wouldn't call Debussy underrated...

When someone says underrated, it means that people don't know about him/her or do not credit them. I feel like Debussy has been well recognized and has been credited by a great many of musicians after him.

Boris 01-01-2009 05:47 PM

Tomaso Albinoni

ValeBartoloz 01-02-2009 12:48 PM

from the critic side i'd say Puccini...

zappafan23 02-06-2009 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 419681)
OK Frank Zappa. His classical pieces are phenomenal and disgustingly underated.

I like the way this man talks...

How about one of the most inspirational composers of Frank's, Edgard Varese...

The Robot Hunter 02-07-2009 02:29 PM

Heitor Villa-Lobos is a very well-known composer in Latin America but I don't think many people know about him in The States/Europe. I've played a couple of guitar suites and his Bachianas brasileiras arranged for orchestra and they're all beautiful works.

barbarella 02-14-2009 06:19 PM

I think my choice would have to be Gian Piero Reverberi; the Italian guy who founded Rondo Veneziano. Pretty much unheard of here, they're incredibly popular in Europe, having made about 60 or so CDs. Although somewhat generic in style, Rondo Veneziano have brought Italian Baroque music to the masses by giving it a modern, pop-orientated style.

witmer 02-17-2009 10:14 PM

Chabrier and plenty of others
 
Oh god, this thread is kind of old. But I must say this. No one has mentioned one of my favorite composers, he's horribly underrated.

Emmanuel Chabrier. His music is on par with the greats, he is practically only known for his Espana, even though, Suite Pastorale and Gwendoline, and others are truly fabulous. Not a soul ever talks about him it seems. He came before Debussy and Satie, but he influenced them both, he is the source of that parisian avante garde movement, he is huge in the developement of "the six". If I had to pick one, it would be Chabrier!

Of course, there are others, Johann Strauss II has been mentioned, and I believe this to be true, I much prefer him to Richard. How about Gustav Holst, people know the Planets Suite, one of the greatest pieces of music out there, but hardly know his name. Erik Satie has been mentioned, quite a few refuse to take his gymnopedies and gnossienes seriously, sadly, and few recognize that he wrote Parade, and alot of cool "normal" piano pieces that sound Scott Joplin-esque and are often better to listen to and more clever than Debussy pieces. This brings me to the man himself, Scott Joplin. He founded a genre of music, Maple Leaf rag is a gem and this kind of stuff came out of nowhere. Its really easy to consider his music classical, but most want to put it off as ragtime, which I believe to be a hybrid subgenre of classical and jazz, it was composed in the tradition of classical, notated and such, and I believe it should be treated that way. When it came out, there was no Jazz. Bacharinni, that early classical dude, must've been good, everyone knows his minuet tune, but not his name, and this minuet is excellant, I don't know his other stuff. Aaron Copland, I mean, his music is hugely appreciated and so is he as a historic figure, but plenty of traditional classical snobs bill him as inferior, even if they don't really mean to. And he was really, really, really excellant, nothing else to it, just like Chabrier(except poor Chabrier didn't have America to support him). I think Zappa is a little bit pretentious, but he probably doesn't get as much credit as he deserves. Not a classical composer, but Joe Jackson, I love his music, wrote that "Symphony no. 1" and I find the second movement to be great, and it had a similar and why the hell not equal creative process to writing a symphony. Plus his new wave and jazz stuff is amazing. He was somewhat trained as a traditional composer but broke off into the pop scene. Ooh, a really good one, George Martin, he composed string music for the Beatles, he came up with so many good sound ideas for them. I think that John Phillip Sousa is pretty neat and original. So many people underrate many of Haydn's works and overrate others. The first movement of his Clock Symphony is incredible and not considered much. The Surprise Symphony has been elevated to a slightly pompus status. But the 2nd movement of the Clock Symphony is just right. As long as I've mentioned Haydn, I thought of someone much more deserving of being called underrated, Leopold Mozart.

I don't know much about this fellow, but I'll throw out Toru Takemitsu as well. He seems thoughtful about his notes, very original, and Copland thought highly of him, ;). Oh, and I forgot to mention Camille Saint Saens, he is widely respected, but many wrongfully call his music superficial in my opinion, I think it is marvelous and that he truly was the next Mozart, its like people can't appreciate his music because they are freaked out by the fact that he was such an insane child prodigy, he wasn't as respected as it seems he should have been with that, therefore, he must not have lived up to his potential. This is bull****! Oh, and Jaques Offenbach is also underrated in that he is better than Wagner, and not as highly thought of as he should be! There is plenty of lute music from Italy in the rennaisance period that is beautiful, and the composers are hardly known. These are the ones I can back up adequately and/or really, really want to put up, there are others. Remember Chabrier!

So,

EMMANUEL CHABRIER
Johann Strauss II
Gustav Holst
Erik Satie
Scott Joplin(ragtime=american classical piano)
Luigi Bacharinni
Aaron Copland(to a lesser degree by some significant circles)
Frank Zappa
Joe Jackson
George Martin
John Phillip Sousa
Joseph Haydn(to a lesser degree by some significant circles)
Leopold Mozart
Toru Takemitsu
Lute composers from Rennaisance Italy.
-and to a lesser degree by some significant circles:
Camille Saint-Saens
Jacques Offenbach
And and I forgot to mention that:
One day, i'll show up alot on lists like this, ;).

On the flip side, I appreciate their music and they are great and all, but...
Richard Wagner(its annoying that people say he is better than Offenbach, let alone Tchaikovky!)
Richard Strauss
can't think of any others right now, I'm not sure how I feel about saying any composer is overrated, you know I like R. Strauss and Wagner, its just when they overshadow others that I like better.

witmer 02-17-2009 10:15 PM

For a succinct message. Emmanuel Chabrier, in case you are intimidated by long ones. I cannot stress this enough.

penguin315 02-25-2009 01:41 PM

Wagner

jdm11b 02-25-2009 02:03 PM

I say Samuel Barber. His "Adagio for Strings" is well known, but his symphonies and concertos are mind blowing.

There's a CD of piano works that show a wide variety of styles, and his technical ability is amazing.

Stirling 03-01-2009 10:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Åke Sjöström (Post 423849)
Mahler pffft. I think he's overrated.
Kalevi Aho-severely underrated. Simon Proctor too. Come on, Serpents and Contrabassoons and Tubas need love too-we're the black sheep of the orchestra. :(

PS. i take that back-Schoenberg is SEVERELY underrated-he's a goddamn genius-so is Toru Takemitsu-I know way too many classical composers lol

You think that Mahler is overrated! Have you heard his Symphony No. 8, it's perpetuous, brilliant, incredibly beautiful all the way throughout it's two movements. Just as well, his first symphony "Titan" - it has a purely grand piece throughout. Both of these symphonies carry Mahler's passion of the world; his desire to explain its meaning through music. As he said in a conversation with Sibelius: "... the symphony should be like the world: it must embrace everything." I think that that's the essence of his brilliance.

Having said that, he wrote a piece called "Das Lied von der Erde" (The song of the Earth) of some oriental lyrics. This piece is one which, I think expresses those same values of worldly description.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:53 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.