Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Classical (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/)
-   -   Differentiating between Baroque and Romantic Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/classical/70304-differentiating-between-baroque-romantic-music.html)

AntonioVitali 06-21-2013 08:33 PM

Differentiating between Baroque and Romantic Music
 
It is difficult to explain the difference between romantic and baroque music to non musicians, but I am trying to. I have chosen a video of me playing some baroque music and romantic music to identify different characteristics. So you think this is the best way, or how would you explain this difference?

Freebase Dali 06-21-2013 09:57 PM

I think the best way is to study the difference in how the music was composed.

And that's probably the only thing I ever learned in Music Appreciation during college.

drh1589 06-26-2013 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AntonioVitali (Post 1334941)
It is difficult to explain the difference between romantic and baroque music to non musicians, but I am trying to. I have chosen a video of me playing some baroque music and romantic music to identify different characteristics. So you think this is the best way, or how would you explain this difference?

Well for starters, listen for the harpsichord :D


Seriously, though...

The differences between baroque and other styles of music are hard to explain, but there are some clear differences. Maybe some of this will help:

The baroque period is known for a motoric rhythm. Typically, you'll hear a constant 8th or quarter-note rhythm in at least one part. That isn't always the case. The baroque period also made the art of fugal writing more famous.

Baroque music can typically be homophonic (one melody accompanied by another part or parts that are not the focus) or polyphonic (the goal of which is for every part to sound as its own independent melody, and beautiful in harmony, together).

Romantic music marks a shift towards more adventurous harmony. Whereas previously, music would be more diatonic (in one key or another), Romantic harmony began to stretch the limits of what was acceptable. Harmony became much more chromatic and ultimately this allows for further expression through more sudden changes, emphasis, etc.

Much more explanation might be too complicated but I'd be happy to explain more if you're still looking for more. I'm also unsure if you're looking for a "for dummies" version of this for listeners.

gunnels 06-27-2013 12:10 AM

I remember that before I really got into 'classical' music, I couldn't really tell the difference between the major eras. Now, I can't fathom not being able to tell the difference between Bach and Chopin, and I can usually identify the the composer of a piece I've never heard before, or at least get close to the mark.

I've never realized it until I read this thread...but yeah, it is kind of hard to explain it in layman's terms. I guess a good indicator would be the degree of (I know this is really subjective) "drama" within the piece. Baroque and previous-era music tends to be kind of reserved dynamic-wise, whereas Romantic music has the tendency to be a tad bit bombastic (especially the later composers). This same principle could also be applied to emotional expression, since the now popular philosophy that music's primary purpose was to express one's self didn't really catch on until Beethoven came around. Again, that's incredibly subjective and not really helpful, but that's all I have for you at the moment. =\

Astronomer 07-02-2013 05:11 AM

Well, from a classical pianists point of view, baroque keyboard music is pre-pianoforte, so was originally written for organ, harpsichord, or spinet... However today it's easy to mistake it for "classical" as it'd probably be performed on piano.

I find that in Baroque music, time signatures are quite strict and stately, and everything is in harmony. Romantic pieces have much more rubato, as in, not as strict and stately in time and rhythm.

Topazchicken 07-12-2013 10:45 AM

I agree that stated as simply as possible (with exceptions of course): baroque is more structured, steady, and "stately" (to use Lateralus' word) with everything in a standard sort of harmony harmony and with consistent recurring rhythms (and harpsichord!). Think a king marching steadily and happily down a great hall.

Meanwhile Romantic is more loose, fluid, and elegant, with more diversity in the arrangements and arguably more experimentation (it was a couple steps into the future from baroque). Think the gentle swooping strings of a love scene!

Farewell 07-13-2013 04:39 AM

I'm new to all things classical, but have been doing some light research when the mood strikes. Google is my friend! :p

I'm curious what particular pieces/artists would fall into each of these particular categories?

Bacholyte 07-16-2013 09:23 AM

Between the baroque era (1600-1750) and the romantic era (1830-World War I) stands the classical period proper (Haydn, Mozart, Beethoven, although Beethoven definitely headed towards the romantic). There are reasons for the dates: the invention of opera, the death of Bach, etc., but in practice the developments were gradual. Opera started almost exactly in 1600, but it wasn't as if every composer in Europe got the news flash and said, "aha, we're now in the Baroque!" Bach, a baroque stalwart, was considered an old fogey by the time of his death and all but forgotten for two generations: classical-style trends were already underway. (In his Prelude in E-flat for organ, perhaps Bach wanted to show that he was perfectly able to compose in this new style, thank you, and it is a masterpiece, yet his heart wasn't in the style.) The baroque era itself was rather romantic in spirit. Look at the architecture, for instance.

One impetus for the Romantic period in all the arts was the industrial revolution and at least a vague horror of its effects on people's lives. The reaction involved elements of nostalgia and love of countryside, nature, simpler ways, folk heritage, and national identities growing out of common blood lines. (Some of this, of course, would eventually be horribly exploited by the Nazis. No wonder they idolized the ultra-romanticist Wagner).

Lord Larehip 07-16-2013 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AntonioVitali (Post 1334941)
It is difficult to explain the difference between romantic and baroque music to non musicians, but I am trying to. I have chosen a video of me playing some baroque music and romantic music to identify different characteristics. So you think this is the best way, or how would you explain this difference?

Hearing is believing. You can explain that baroque relied on fugues and ground bass and all that. That it was fractal in nature--small riffs that made up larger riffs which made up even larger riffs.

Romantic, as the name implies, is much more emotional music. Baroque had a more cold intelligence to it. You're also skipping a period between baroque and romantic.

But all the explaining in the world doesn't mean squat if they can't hear it.

jekluc 08-11-2013 04:20 PM

Personally I think good baroque is more romantic than Romantic music. The emotion in baroque music, especially someone like Bach, is there, but bottled up. This actually makes it more powerful; think of a pressure cooker.

CoolBec 08-11-2013 05:50 PM

The only thing I could add to what's pretty much been covered is the popularity of different compositional forms. Forms like the Fugue were popular during the Baroque era as opposed to Symphonies which became more popular during the Classical and Romantic period.

Also, the Romantic era tended to be much more secular.

Zack 08-14-2013 10:22 PM

I think that the easiest way to explain it, to someone with NO formal musical background is in the overall feel. Tell them that Romantic music sounds somewhat like a film soundtrack (sort of), and that Baroque sounds more like a dance in a medieval castle, (not really, but...)

It's the vibe, that the average person who isn't familiar with theory or classical musics is going to respond to. Tell them that Romantic music is flowy and dramatic, Baroque music is rhythmic and hypnotic. Tell them that Romantic music is the Nutcracker, and Baroque music is what Tenacious D starts out with, singing about Bach and Rock.

Of course, the easiest way would be to just play them some music from the corresponding periods...

-Zack

Michael Adam Serrano 08-17-2013 11:59 AM

A Pretty Subjective Topic-

There are vast similarities and differences between Baroque and Romantic music. So the discussion can get hairy. I'm not sure we can sum it up in a sentence or two, which is why there are eons of scholars like Christoph Wolf at Harvard writing bibles on the matter.

- I think the biggest difference, would be the influence of the more "balanced and symmetrical" classical music period, whether appreciated or not. Note that I used quotes, and also note that baroque composers were not yet influenced by the classical era. Power-house composers like Brahms had a great appreciation for the symmetrical quality of the classical era and you can see it throughout almost all of his work in comparison to other romantic composers.

* Also, many argue that romantic music is more smoothly interconnected, especially as ideas like "legato" are more emphasized than before (particularly, between movements of the same work), which could also be an influence from classical music and variation.

* Flourishing or embellishment is prevalent in both eras, in their own ways, especially since a lot of research points to the use of vibrato in Romantic music. The Baroque era is the very example of embellishment which we stereotype in any early music.

* It's really a level of evolution, as the Baroque era was also very passionate, but music evolves as society changes.

* I don't think my answer encompasses everything, as what previous people mention about more romantic music being secular, or the rhythmic baroque qualities, the different instrumentation, and tuning systems also show clear differences.

I hope this helps! Cheers!

Ghora 09-22-2013 06:57 PM

Beethoven has the perfect balance IMO


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:20 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.