Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)
-   -   This I Believe There is / is not a God (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/33149-i-believe-there-not-god.html)

Janszoon 02-14-2011 09:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maccabbe (Post 1004647)
Up until now I have made less then 10 to 15 posts about religion in this site.

You have made 20 posts in this thread. That's, what, 60% of your post count? When you figure in the fact that all your other posts have virtually no content I would say about 99% of all the writing you've done on MB has been about religion.

Dirty 02-14-2011 09:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Introvox (Post 1004639)
Yes, my friend, that would be totally correct.

It is I.....Muzoid, at your service. *takes a bow*

I was kindly re-welcomed by a mod here, and invited to take part in the community.

Isn't that wonderful? :)


Yeah I hope so. My initial impression of you was immature douchebag, but hopefully I was wrong. :pimp:

Maccabbe, can I ask you why you keep bringing up porn? What is so wrong about it and why do you hate it?

Howard the Duck 02-14-2011 09:46 PM

^^to the best of my experience, it reduces rape

PinkCigarette 02-14-2011 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Maccabbe (Post 1004647)
Up until now I have made less then 10 to 15 posts about religion in this site.
I have not called anyone any bad name, or used any dirty language, or insulted anyone on a personal manner, please check out all my comments on this thread, and see if I speak the truth or not.

What in the world are you talking about?

In your site, you have sat on the sidelines while people were mobbing around me and calling me Kike and other Anti Semitic diatribes, and you have done nothing to stop them, nothing.

Yet you got the nerve to blame me for everything?

Do you got no shame?

You didn’t have one outspoken religious and creationist person in your website, and when I came, you let the mob shred me to pieces. Even one true creationist was too much for you to bare.

So much for fairness and equal opportunity to all…

As to the discussion , you said :"Religion has nothing to do with anything you talk about. It's PEOPLE who make these decisions".


You don’t mean to suggest that religion supports the awful and devastating way of life of porn and drugs and all these negative things, or to suggest that religion is the cause of all of these things?

What set the ground for all these horrible things to come to reality?

The casting down the Yoke of Heaven to the ground, nothing else.

If people followed the will of God as God wanted, all of these horrible things wouldn’t come to reality.

When a person believes that there is no reward or punishment and that he comes from the apes, why should he care if he becomes a porn star or not? or become a thief or not, or a murderer or not?

Secular Humanism?

We all know what subjective humanism can do, it can support those who they seem are worthy and neglect those who they don’t care for.

Morality needs to be heavenly sanctioned, for objectivity to take place.


If you are going to re-tell something that happened, please be honest about it. A number of people were banned from the thread, BY ME, including YOU, because you complained that they insulted what you believed in yet YOU DID THE SAME TO THEM. The proof of my stance on religion is in my posts. I openly admit to being atheist but I have stood up for religious beliefs because I have been surrounded by religious people my entire life so I have some education on why people believe certain things. Infact, as we speak, I am DEFENDING the argument that because God has power and 'knows all', why doesn't he jump in and stop things from happening, so don't tell lies. I do NOT tolerate people being douchebags. If people were being morons in the thread and were not told about it, excuse me for having a life and not being online 24/7 to babysit everyone. The staff has told people many times to use the report button. We try to sift through as much as we can but if you don't help us by reporting it, it is very easy to miss, especially in a fast moving thread about religion. I figured a 34 year old man would be able to refrain from insulting 16 and 17 year olds.

Enough with the MF garbage, we are here at MB. If you want to complain about the ban you earned yourself, feel free to PM me to discuss it. Otherwise, you did it to yourself, move on. You were not the only person punished, get over it.

Again, a person's religion has nothing to do with the things you are talking about. If you seriously think a religious person does not participate in the things you are mentioning, you're just being ignorant.

Introvox 02-14-2011 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirty (Post 1004651)
Yeah I hope so. My initial impression of you was immature douchebag, but hopefully I was wrong. :pimp:

Maccabbe, can I ask you why you keep bring up porn? What is so wrong about it and why do you hate it?

Awww, how lovely.

But you will soon see the real me...one hellova nice/fun guy, with loads of musical knowledge.

But, of course, I will leave that judgement up to you. ;)


...did someone say Porn?

Dirty 02-14-2011 10:19 PM

Hey mods, why was Maccabbe banned?

Janszoon 02-14-2011 10:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dirty (Post 1004679)
Hey mods, why was Maccabbe banned?

Self-promotion, post-slutting and, in the end, failure to cooperate with mod requests regarding his rule violations.

Howard the Duck 02-15-2011 03:36 AM

^^ what a shame, he was a source of endless hilarity

s_k 02-15-2011 04:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1004426)
So, if you're not posting to add to the discussion, but only to join the mob in ridiculing a religious poster, then I think you should reconsider before clicking the submit button. This is a discussion thread and if you think arguments truly are idiotic, then it should be easy for you to counter them with reason.

Altough you are actually completely right and I'm sorry for getting carried away, end of the story is that Maccabe was really going nowhere...
But yeah, you're right. I should stay out of this topic alltogether because I just cannot, as much as I want to, have respect or understanding for people who are seriously religious and want to project that onto others.

Edit: Just notice there's been three pages of... stuff... between Tore's posting and this one. My reply may be a bit too late. If it's considered bad form, feel free to delete it mods :).

PurpleWolf 02-15-2011 05:01 AM

1 Attachment(s)
I was once a hardcore christian, not a fundie but dedicated.
Up until I got into a conversation about religion with an older man.
And, despite all religions faults and problems, it gives people a sense of purpose and a set of morals and ethics to follow. It gives people friends, an external family, and a goal on how to live their lives. I would not be surprised if religious people died more content than non-religious people simply due to the fact that they feel they have accomplished something, whether that something is fake or real.

Besides religion has pretty much got me through my childhood, in which I was constantly moving countries or cities, constantly alone and dealing with **** that my father dealt out to me.
When I gave up religion, one of the few things I realized was that life is pointless; you get born, live a short life (which consists of a childhood were you are controlled by your parents then 12 years of schooling, maybe higher learning followed by 40-50 years of working for our two bitches, money and society before finally becoming too old to be of any use to anyone, except verbally) and then die. Another thing I realized is that religion makes peoples lives easier and safer. The Western world is built on christianity and is a fairly accepting and safe society, imagine if instead it was built on the Aztec religion or Islam?

Religion plays its part in the world and the majority of believers do make the world a better place for us all (not saying non-believers don't either).
But in the end, once you know religion is a facade then you might as well move on and create a life worth living for yourself.
That is my goal in life, to live a life were I can die content, knowing that I did what I wanted to do in life and through my actions, I changed the world. (I believe that everyone is connected somehow. I am speculating that there is a sort of collective 'will' or 'desire' that binds the universe together, every person is somehow connected through this 'will'. Perhaps it is a desire to exist on a higher level that holds the universe together, and perhaps the next level for us is a spiritual level. My opinion, feel free to add your 5 cents.)
I also believe in the Chaos Theory or Butterfly Effect, were a tiny action can cause a chain of reactions that results in the entire world being effected. If I had not bothered to post this then perhaps you would never of heard about it and lived an alternate life, thus changing all your actions and eventually changing the people around you.
Food for thought =]

Peace,
PurpleWolf

The Batlord 02-15-2011 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PurpleWolf (Post 1004859)
I was once a hardcore christian, not a fundie but dedicated.
Up until I got into a conversation about religion with an older man.
And, despite all religions faults and problems, it gives people a sense of purpose and a set of morals and ethics to follow. It gives people friends, an external family, and a goal on how to live their lives. I would not be surprised if religious people died more content than non-religious people simply due to the fact that they feel they have accomplished something, whether that something is fake or real.

It also gives easy answers even though those answers may be wrong and even harmful (about homosexuality, the role of women, slavery).

Quote:

When I gave up religion, one of the few things I realized was that life is pointless; you get born, live a short life (which consists of a childhood were you are controlled by your parents then 12 years of schooling, maybe higher learning followed by 40-50 years of working for our two bitches, money and society before finally becoming too old to be of any use to anyone, except verbally) and then die.
That's just life.

Quote:

Another thing I realized is that religion makes peoples lives easier and safer.
Tell that to anyone who's ever been stoned to death for adultery, burned as a witch, or tortured to death for heresy.

Quote:

The Western world is built on christianity and is a fairly accepting and safe society, imagine if instead it was built on the Aztec religion or Islam?
The western world was built on Christianity, (leading to witch burnings, the Inquisition, the repression of science, the oppression of women, etc) but now it is built on taking those things that we still agree with (thou shallt not kill, love thy neighbor, etc) and ignoring all those things that are inconvenient. Like it or not, Christianity's hold on the western world is dying.


I don't mean to misrepresent your post by ignoring the last part, but the first half of your post was what I wanted to discuss.

crash_override 02-15-2011 11:47 AM

I may or may not have posted this before, but, god is not real.

Introvox 02-15-2011 11:50 AM

I'm Frisbetyrian

"we believe that when we die, we become frisbees and end up on the roof of a local grocery store"

PurpleWolf 02-15-2011 05:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1005062)
It also gives easy answers even though those answers may be wrong and even harmful (about homosexuality, the role of women, slavery).

Yes thats very true. The Abrahamic religions are very much about putting power into the hands of men. Feminine men and gays are a disgrace to men, women must be submissive and quiet, and treating another human being as worse than an animal is A-OK!!

Quote:

That's just life.
Yeeaapp, its a pointless and otherwise boring life.


Quote:

Tell that to anyone who's ever been stoned to death for adultery, burned as a witch, or tortured to death for heresy.
Don't forget the Crusades....

Quote:

The western world was built on Christianity, (leading to witch burnings, the Inquisition, the repression of science, the oppression of women, etc) but now it is built on taking those things that we still agree with (thou shallt not kill, love thy neighbor, etc) and ignoring all those things that are inconvenient. Like it or not, Christianity's hold on the western world is dying.
I should stop posting after 3am, my brain died and stupid comments appear.
You are quite right there, thank you for pointing that out.

Quote:

I don't mean to misrepresent your post by ignoring the last part, but the first half of your post was what I wanted to discuss.
Not a problem! :thumb:

Phantom Limb 02-15-2011 06:41 PM

Why the Christian God Does Not Exist:
1) God is all knowing
2) God is good
3) God is all powerful

If god is all knowing then he knows everything that will happen, and if he knows everything that will happen, he will use his infinite power to stop any evil before it happens (because he is all good). Therefore, since there's a **** ton of evil in the world, we can conclude that there is no god. Either that or god isn't good.

Janszoon 02-15-2011 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abearmauledme (Post 1005352)
Why the Christian God Does Not Exist:
1) God is all knowing
2) God is good
3) God is all powerful

If god is all knowing then he knows everything that will happen, and if he knows everything that will happen, he will use his infinite power to stop any evil before it happens (because he is all good). Therefore, since there's a **** ton of evil in the world, we can conclude that there is no god. Either that or god isn't good.

Yep, that even has a name: The Problem of Evil.

RVCA 02-15-2011 09:14 PM

What I find funniest about the christian god is that he "created the universe in 6 days" and then "stopped to rest".

...yes, because divine beings who create universes need to rest too!

Phantom Limb 02-17-2011 06:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RVCA (Post 1005466)
What I find funniest about the christian god is that he "created the universe in 6 days" and then "stopped to rest".

...yes, because divine beings who create universes need to rest too!

I'm pretty sure that's intended to be a metaphor for the creation of the world. Who knows, maybe the world is so ****ed up because god is still resting.

The Batlord 02-18-2011 11:49 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Abearmauledme (Post 1006708)
I'm pretty sure that's intended to be a metaphor for the creation of the world. Who knows, maybe the world is so ****ed up because god is still resting.

I'm pretty sure it was written by ignorant shephards who didn't have the slightest idea what they were talking about. And if it was a metaphor, it was incredibly irresponsible of them/him/it to give us something so open to interpretation.

ProggyMan 02-18-2011 11:57 AM

Lol, considering the incredibly poetic nature of much of the bible it certainly wasn't written by 'ignorant shepherds'.

The Batlord 02-18-2011 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007031)
Lol, considering the incredibly poetic nature of much of the bible

If you say so. Besides, what do you know of an ignorant shepherd's peotic knowledge? It is a modern concept that poetry is an intellectual pursuit.

Quote:

it certainly wasn't written by 'ignorant shepherds'.
I was speaking of the story of Genesis, which is in the Torah. It may also be in The Bible, but obviously they did not have the same writers.

Ska Lagos Jew Sun Ra 02-18-2011 01:58 PM

Torah = old testament. Obviously since the Jews don't consider the new testament holy they don't call their own book the 'old testament'.

ProggyMan 02-18-2011 08:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1007055)
If you say so. Besides, what do you know of an ignorant shepherd's peotic knowledge? It is a modern concept that poetry is an intellectual pursuit.

Lol, 'ignorant shepherds' wouldn't have been literate. There's really no basis for your statement about the authors knowledge of metaphor and considering the countless examples of metaphor and other literary devices in the Tanakh it becomes ridiculous.


Quote:

I was speaking of the story of Genesis, which is in the Torah. It may also be in The Bible, but obviously they did not have the same writers.
Bible and Torah are interchangeable terms, generally speaking. It's not really relevant though.

Howard the Duck 02-18-2011 08:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007271)
Lol, 'ignorant shepherds' wouldn't have been literate. There's really no basis for your statement about the authors knowledge of metaphor and considering the countless examples of metaphor and other literary devices in the Tanakh it becomes ridiculous.

Bible and Torah are interchangeable terms, generally speaking. It's not really relevant though.

Revelations reads like John stumbled on an early form of LSD.

The Torah is only the first five books of the Old Testament.

ProggyMan 02-18-2011 08:59 PM

I was referring to the Old Testament only. It's habit, I'm Jewish.

Janszoon 02-18-2011 11:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007271)
Lol, 'ignorant shepherds' wouldn't have been literate.

They didn't have to be literate. The stories in the Bible were an oral tradition and were only written down years later.

ProggyMan 02-18-2011 11:20 PM

Perhaps, but even so the people who transcribed the traditions into the form of sacred texts were certainly educated.

TockTockTock 02-19-2011 08:35 AM

Well, maybe the original text itself wasn't poet, but the King James English translation was (or the Latin translation)? I do know that several monks started to translate the Bible into English so the people (even though most of them were illiterate) could read it and the (sometimes corrupt) priests wouldn't have to read it to them from the Latin translation. Because the priests were able to read Latin, they could manipulate the text's meaning to take advantage of the unknowing worshipers.

The Batlord 02-19-2011 09:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007271)
Lol, 'ignorant shepherds' wouldn't have been literate. There's really no basis for your statement about the authors knowledge of metaphor and considering the countless examples of metaphor and other literary devices in the Tanakh it becomes ridiculous.

Considering the fact that just about every society has had poetry, regardless of their level of education, I think my statement does have basis. Just off the top of my head, the vikings are famous for creating poetry even though there society was almost entirely illiterate and uneducated. It would seem that Wikipedia even has an opinion on the matter. So, just because the Bible may or may not be poetic (and I honestly don't know or care either way), is meaningless.


Quote:

Bible and Torah are interchangeable terms, generally speaking. It's not really relevant though.
No, they're not. Not only does the Bible contain extra books (obviously), but the Bible was also a translation of the Torah and contains many mistranslations.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007315)
Perhaps, but even so the people who transcribed the traditions into the form of sacred texts were certainly educated.

Really? Nomadic herders were educated? News to me.

ProggyMan 02-19-2011 12:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1007462)
Considering the fact that just about every society has had poetry, regardless of their level of education, I think my statement does have basis. Just off the top of my head, the vikings are famous for creating poetry even though there society was almost entirely illiterate and uneducated. It would seem that Wikipedia even has an opinion on the matter. So, just because the Bible may or may not be poetic (and I honestly don't know or care either way), is meaningless.

Ok, my mistake, the 'ignorant shepherds' were perfectly capable of understanding the concept of a metaphor, which just proves my point anyway.

Quote:

No, they're not. Not only does the Bible contain extra books (obviously), but the Bible was also a translation of the Torah and contains many mistranslations.
People use the word 'bible' all the time to refer to all sorts of things, you know what I meant, this discussion is irrelevant.

Quote:

Really? Nomadic herders were educated? News to me.
The nomadic herders obviously didn't transcribe the texts, Jewish civilization had evolved quite a bit by the time the Tanakh/Torah was written down.

Neapolitan 02-21-2011 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Batlord (Post 1007462)
Really? Nomadic herders were educated? News to me.

It's false to think only civilizations with a written language can be educated, did you overlooked passing information by word of mouth.

The Batlord 02-22-2011 03:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProggyMan (Post 1007547)
Ok, my mistake, the 'ignorant shepherds' were perfectly capable of understanding the concept of a metaphor, which just proves my point anyway.

Understanding a metaphor means that you are qualified to comment on the creation of the universe? It appears that I've been wasting my life. I could have been a astrophycisist years ago.

RVCA 05-28-2011 12:08 PM

"Azeusism, or not believing in Zeus, has been the cause of almost every single major atrocity of the past several thousand years."

I've recently come across this, and I think it's perhaps the greatest response to people who claim "atheists have killed just as many people as theists" or even "atheists are immoral".

Mr November 05-29-2011 11:32 PM

I don't believe in God because I don't know what it is. I've never seen a definition of God that I believed in, so I can call myself an atheist.

Also don't believe in any other deities/creators/miracles/souls/etc,etc,etc. Why? Because I have no reason to believe in them. Occam's Razor.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:20 PM.


© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.