The Batlord |
06-02-2014 11:04 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by WhateverDude
(Post 1455795)
Batlord and GB, you guys are still responding to my posts and going off on a tangent about religion. I made it explicitly clear in my first post that I don't believe in any of that, just that it's possible their may be a 'creator'.
I'll go on to say that maybe not even a 'God', just fulfilling a similar role as far as our existing goes. S/he/it might not even be supernatual, just not described or imagined by humans.
|
I did address your point. You say that there "may be a 'creator'". I pointed out that any number of things "may" be true (i.e. zombies, Harry Potter, etc). Why do you take the idea of a creator seriously and not any number of other absurd beliefs? I'm putting forth the idea that there may be a cultural influence that is influencing you into considering something (be it a god or a "creator") that you may not otherwise treat seriously.
My point isn't that we can rule out a god (or a creator), and I imagine any atheist with two logics to rub together wouldn't either. If you think that's what atheists think then you're probably misinterpreting what they've been saying. My point is that if there isn't any evidence for an idea, no legitimate reason to consider it for longer than it takes to go, "Hey, maybe...", then why would we give it any real consideration until evidence was brought forth?
Quote:
Originally Posted by WhateverDude
(Post 1456044)
But really though, I don't see why it seems so far fetched to people. Like I said, if we can recreate the circumstances under which life on Earth (supposedly) began and evolved to what we know today, what's so preposterous about the idea of ourselves having been created?
|
If life can be created by glorified monkeys then why do you need anything that could be described as a deity to create us? Why not just scrub the idea of God and start talking about aliens? Whether or not I treat the idea seriously I still find it far more believable than a deity just by virtue of the fact that we know intelligent life exists.
And if we're talking about aliens, then you've just taken the argument out of the Atheist vs Religion sphere and this now becomes an off-topic discussion that has nothing to do with the preconceptions of atheists.
|