Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)
-   -   GMOs (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/80077-gmos.html)

Pet_Sounds 05-04-2017 04:02 PM

Regardless, if the vast majority of people think they should be labelled, shouldn't we listen to the will of the people?

Poll: Skepticism of Genetically Modified Foods - ABC News

93% of respondents said "the federal government should require labels on food saying whether it's been genetically modified, or 'bio-engineered' (this poll used both phrases)."

Frownland 05-04-2017 04:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pet_Sounds (Post 1831808)
Regardless, if the vast majority of people think they should be labelled, shouldn't we listen to the will of the people?

If the will of the people is based on an unscientific premise (in this case, the idea that GMOs are unhealthy/dangerous), then no. Much in the same way that we shouldn't (I would say don't but that's not realistic) allow the public's opinions on climate change affect public policy. Because as a rule of thumb, the public is dumb as ****. That's why the gubment exists in the first place.

Pet_Sounds 05-04-2017 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland (Post 1831811)
If the will of the people is based on an unscientific premise (in this case, the idea that GMOs are unhealthy/dangerous), then no. Much in the same way that we shouldn't (I would say don't but that's not realistic) allow the public's opinions on climate change affect public policy. Because as a rule of thumb, the public is dumb as ****. That's why the gubment exists in the first place.

"Moral questions are outside the scientific realm." —Richard Feynman

The role of scientists is to serve as advisors, not to dictate policy. And the public's opinions on climate change currently ARE affecting public policy, albeit indirectly (through their choice of leader).

Additionally, I question whether or not there is a scientific consensus on GMOs. Both the EU and Japan have regulations regarding the labelling of products that contain GMOs. Those nations are certainly not anti-science. Also, here's a pretty important geneticist who's worried about GMOs.

duga 05-04-2017 04:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 1831807)
I was hoping for a science publication maybe but you give me a source from a pro buiz magazine

We are talking about the economic impact, though....what does science have to do with that? You need me to convince you GMOs are safe?

The one line responses are not really motivating me to give you more.

duga 05-04-2017 04:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pet_Sounds (Post 1831817)
"Moral questions are outside the scientific realm." —Richard Feynman

The role of scientists is to serve as advisors, not to dictate policy. And the public's opinions on climate change currently ARE affecting public policy, albeit indirectly (through their choice of leader).

Additionally, I question whether or not there is a scientific consensus on GMOs. Both the EU and Japan have regulations regarding the labelling of products that contain GMOs. Those nations are certainly not anti-science. Also, here's a pretty important geneticist who's worried about GMOs.

Certainly we need to mitigate risk - the biggest concern is killing genetic diversity. Which basically every scientist agrees we need to address - even pro-GMO scientists.

I used to research GMO's and my master's thesis was on using genetic modification to suss out genetic pathways and gene families to better control biomass production. Knowing a bit more on the topic than the average bear, I can say confidently there is no proof GMOs are harmful to humans.

duga 05-04-2017 04:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 1831824)
Theres 38 countries that have banned GMO's i just think a label would be nice

Sure, it would be nice. But it would be too prohibitive and a waste of money. This isn't just a sticker slapped on a piece of fruit that says "GMO"...people want details. Details they don't understand and will scare them from buying affordable, safe, and a lot of times healthier than organic products. There's just so much more nuance to this than people seem to understand.

Janszoon 05-04-2017 04:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duga (Post 1831825)
Sure, it would be nice. But it would be too prohibitive and a waste of money. This isn't just a sticker slapped on a piece of fruit that says "GMO"...people want details. Details they don't understand and will scare them from buying affordable, safe, and a lot of times healthier than organic products. There's just so much more nuance to this than people seem to understand.

It's nice read comments from someone who actually knows what they're talking about!

Pet_Sounds 05-04-2017 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duga (Post 1831825)
Sure, it would be nice. But it would be too prohibitive and a waste of money. This isn't just a sticker slapped on a piece of fruit that says "GMO"...people want details. Details they don't understand and will scare them from buying affordable, safe, and a lot of times healthier than organic products. There's just so much more nuance to this than people seem to understand.

Sure, people want details, but it seems the vast majority of them also want a label. Doesn't holding out make GMOs seem scary? Ultimately, I think people should have the choice to avoid them if they want to, whether their reasons for doing so are sound or not.

(For the record, I agree with you on the safety of GMOs and I'm personally indifferent on whether or not they're labelled. I just have to write a paper on this.)

Frownland 05-04-2017 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pet_Sounds (Post 1831817)
"Moral questions are outside the scientific realm." —Richard Feynman

I don't consider it a moral issue to be honest. I agree with the quote, but I would also add that morals can (and should be) directly be influenced and strengthened when it's backed up by solid science.

Quote:

The role of scientists is to serve as advisors, not to dictate policy.
Yes, but many of those who dictate policy do not always get their scientific advice from scientists or valid studies.

Quote:

And the public's opinions on climate change currently ARE affecting public policy, albeit indirectly (through their choice of leader).
This is why I said shouldn't instead of don't.

Quote:

Additionally, I question whether or not there is a scientific consensus on GMOs. Both the EU and Japan have regulations regarding the labelling of products that contain GMOs. Those nations are certainly not anti-science.
Your teacher will mark you down for combining a bandwagon fallacy with an appeal to authority. What did evidence they use to support this particular decision? Everything should be inspected case by case instead of assuming that these are good decisions because they have a history of it.

Quote:

Also, here's a pretty important geneticist who's worried about GMOs.
That link used a lot of the common arguments that have been addressed several times that I don't want to get into, but I'll say that it's largely an argument from ignorance, since there hasn't been any valid evidence of GMOs being harmful. I don't think that that kind of mindset should dictate policy. Also, many of the arguments against GMOs in the backlink to his other blog post blame GMOs for bad farming practice when that's really on the farmer.

The best thing to do is to look at the meta-analysis. Here are a couple that I didn't read entirely.

A Meta-Analysis of the Impacts of Genetically Modified Crops
http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/...eedAccess=true


Also do you know who else wanted to put labels on something based on its genetics? HITLER!

The Batlord 05-04-2017 04:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 1831831)
This was the same argument againt nutritional facts and calories on menu

Consumers have a right to know don't treat them like children

Do you seriously think the common people aren't idiots though?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:32 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.