Music Banter - Flat Earth Uprising?

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)

- Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)

- - Flat Earth Uprising? (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/86596-flat-earth-uprising.html)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland (Post 1766189)

That actually looks flat as ****.

That's because it's a picture you dingus.

Quote:

Originally Posted by P A N (Post 1766036)

ships going over the horizon is a broad topic. a whole thread could be devoted to it. but pertaining to what you're talking about it, your argument falls apart when you pull a telescope out after the ship has disappeared to your naked eye, and it magically comes back into view. this is a replicable experiment. the reason it appears to shrink as it moves away is because we see things in perspective. all things shrink as they move away from the observer. hold your finger an inch from your eye and then move it to arm's length.

What you describe is not what happens when viewing ships. The ship disappears from the bottom up - with a large ship and calm sea you can see this with the naked eye. Use binoculars and you will see the ship as if it were closer, but the same amount of the bottom of the ship will be out of view. I strongly encourage you to try this yourself if you live close enough to a port - this is science from first principles, and all science is ultimately based on common sense and first principles.

The issue of atmosphere shouldn't be hard to understand - even if you don't like the term gravity you will notice that you don't float off into space, and neither does your car, nor the air that surrounds us. These things have mass. We can see that things with mass don't float off into space, and we call that gravity, but if you don't like that term you can call it Fred.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 1766219)

It's what I meant though. I assumed you were making that comment at least in part toward me. If not, my bad.

I might have been but I didn't understand what you meant. I thought that you meant seeing a visible curve rather than seeing a ship disappear over the curve.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chula Vista (Post 1766185)

P A N = Troll.

Let's stop feeding him and maybe he'll go away.

Next he'll claim that the International Space Station is a hoax too.

http://www.boeing.com/resources/boei...02_960x600.jpg

Is that a UFO in the top part of the picture?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aloysius (Post 1766245)

What you describe is not what happens when viewing ships. The ship disappears from the bottom up - with a large ship and calm sea you can see this with the naked eye. Use binoculars and you will see the ship as if it were closer, but the same amount of the bottom of the ship will be out of view. I strongly encourage you to try this yourself if you live close enough to a port - this is science from first principles, and all science is ultimately based on common sense and first principles.

The issue of atmosphere shouldn't be hard to understand - even if you don't like the term gravity you will notice that you don't float off into space, and neither does your car, nor the air that surrounds us. These things have mass. We can see that things with mass don't float off into space, and we call that gravity, but if you don't like that term you can call it Fred.

ships don't actually disappear from the ground up. it kinda looks like they do, but what's actually happening is as the ships goes further away, a mirage of the top of the ship appears at the bottom of the ship. in a lot of cases, when they get really far out, they look like just floating masts.

it looks like some people have basically said what i wanted to get out though, which is that a gaseous system within a vacuous expanse does not exist other than in the case of earth.

that's good.

next question:

why can't a plane fly into the rotation of the earth to shorten its flight times?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 1766176)

Sure you can. People have observed ships disappearing over the horizon for centuries. The horizon line we see is created by the fact that the surface of the Earth is curving away from the observer.

that would be detecting the curvature. much different than seeing it.

and just to test your logic about horizons a bit, would the horizon not still exist if the earth were flat? to me the horizon is just where the sky meets the earth.

Quote:

Originally Posted by P A N (Post 1766287)

:laughing:

Pure genius.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frownland (Post 1766290)

:laughing:

Pure genius.

you may not want to accept this, but i'm not gonna laugh at you for it.