Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Current Events, Philosophy, & Religion (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/)
-   -   Universal Basic Income or Class Warfare (https://www.musicbanter.com/current-events-philosophy-religion/90667-universal-basic-income-class-warfare.html)

SGR 10-30-2020 10:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141885)
well it can and can't

essentially what it means to be right or left comes down to your stance on Authority vs. Democracy

in theory

in practice some people will call themselves left and be quite authoritarian

Eh, I don't know if I buy it, even in theory. If someone subscribes to every single prescription of Marx/Engels, but wants the state to do it, they're a right-winger?

I think the spectrum of political leanings is more nuanced than that and is better explained by the traditional political compass, that I'm sure you're familiar with.

https://i0.wp.com/thesidelineobserve...35%2C310&ssl=1

OccultHawk 10-30-2020 10:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SoundgardenRocks (Post 2141882)
Right - all I'm saying is that, though it may not be that in its utopian form as envisioned by Marx/Engels, authoritarianism can't be conveniently disassociated from the left by idealistic leftists.

'Communist' revolutions get stuck in the 'Dictatorship of the Proletariat' stage and never reach communism.

Honestly I think the absolute brutality it would take to really redistribute the wealth isn’t something the left as it pretends to be in this day in age isn’t really willing to look at. People don’t give up their **** without a fight. A lot of people would have to die to get it done. That’s why I won’t **** talk Mao and Stalin. With the income disparity we have now it would take a lot more than that. It’s not going to be like just Chomsky giving lectures and ****. Call it fascism or whatever but like Steve Miller says on Jetliner you got to go though hell before you get to heaven.

SGR 10-30-2020 10:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OccultHawk (Post 2141888)
Honestly I think the absolute brutality it would take to really redistribute the wealth isn’t something the left as it pretends to be in this day in age isn’t really willing to look at. People don’t give up their **** without a fight. A lot of people would have to die to get it done.

And that's the rub, isn't it?

The ideas of Marx/Engels might work great for a small willing commune, but in practice across a large country, you need a lot of political will and a lot of guns to get it done.

You can slowly boil people by raising their taxes, but it usually gets to a point where folks will eventually balk. You'll never get communism this way, the best you can hope for is Socialism.

OccultHawk 10-30-2020 10:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141897)
yeah I think that that graph is bunk

theres not 4 quadrants it's just a line

most sociologists believe Marx/Engels prescription

whether you want the state to "do it" or some kind of anarchic vision is the difference between Trotsky and Stalin

Left and Right

Even though I don’t agree I respect your lack of nuance!

SGR 10-30-2020 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141897)
yeah I think that that graph is bunk

theres not 4 quadrants it's just a line

most sociologists believe Marx/Engels prescription

whether you want the state to "do it" or some kind of anarchic vision is the difference between Trotsky and Stalin

Left and Right

So Stalin was a right-winger in your eyes? And Stalinism is a right-wing ideology?

SGR 10-30-2020 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141903)
Some misunderstanding of Marx here

Marx/Engels didn't write instruction manuals for a better world or even invent the idea of socialism

the Communist Manifesto is their political document but it's less important compared to their broader contribution to sociology I think

I realize it wasn't an instruction manual - if it was, there wouldn't have been so many revolutionaries who ****ed it up. It presented a vision and served as a call to action. There are ideas in the document that can be implemented.

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141904)
holy **** yes

the reason we today associate Russia under Stalin with communism is because the 2 major powers of the Cold War were both invested in having their populations believe it

it's the greatest propaganda campaign the world has ever known

All the right-wing people I talk to tell me that Hitler was a left-winger and that the effort to paint him as a right-winger is part of a broad propaganda campaign. I don't know who to believe.

SGR 10-30-2020 11:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141906)
they call for a "dictatorship of the proletariat" but that's really as specific as it gets

and dictatorship did not mean then what it does now

I'm guessing you haven't read the Communist Manifesto, at least not in full. e.g.

Quote:

The Communists turn their attention chiefly to Germany, because that country is on the eve of a bourgeois revolution that is bound to be carried out under more advanced conditions of European civilisation and with a much more developed proletariat than that of England was in the seventeenth, and France in the eighteenth century, and because the bourgeois revolution in Germany will be but the prelude to an immediately following proletarian revolution.
....
The Communists disdain to conceal their views and aims. They openly declare that their ends can be attained only by the forcible overthrow of all existing social conditions. Let the ruling classes tremble at a Communistic revolution. The proletarians have nothing to lose but their chains. They have a world to win.

jwb 10-30-2020 11:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141906)
they call for a "dictatorship of the proletariat" but that's really as specific as it gets

and dictatorship did not mean then what it does now

You're right the German word used didn't have the same connotations as dictatorship does in English, and you're right that Marx's strict political and tactical vision is less fleshed out than his descriptions of economics, but he did spend time agitating politically and there are some basic inferences that can be made about his views on the state and it's role in the coming revolution.

I think Lenin's interpretations of Marx in State and Revolution were fairly coherent and defensible. Ultimately his rule didn't pan out the way we would like but generally speaking his intention was to try to create communism by any means necessary. I don't see how that's not a left wing ambition.

Stalin was more pragmatic and ruthless and power hungry and less concerned with ideology. He wasn't specifically right wing in any serious ideological sense he was just willing to embrace elements of the right when it suited them. He was also willing to persecute and purge right wing and moderate forces when it served him.

Lucem Ferre 10-30-2020 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gutmensch (Post 2141846)
I had to look for the word "illiterate" after your answer. :)

Holy **** that's good.

SGR 10-30-2020 11:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elphenor (Post 2141910)
I have it in print right here

quoted passage is a description of why Marx assumed Germany to be where the revolution would originally occur (obviously he was wrong about this)

there is not a detailing of what is to follow in Germany other than "dictatorship of the proletariat"

Marxists believe revolution is inevitably the result of capitalism (seem like he was right about this)

Perhaps I misunderstood you, I thought you were saying that their only "call to action" was that of calling for a "Dictatorship of the Proletariat". If you're suggesting that their only actionable idea was a 'Dictatorship of a Proletariat', I also disagree with that.

Quote:

The distinguishing feature of Communism is not the abolition of property generally, but the abolition of bourgeois property. But modern bourgeois private property is the final and most complete expression of the system of producing and appropriating products, that is based on class antagonisms, on the exploitation of the many by the few.

In this sense, the theory of the Communists may be summed up in the single sentence: Abolition of private property.
If you're suggesting that Marx didn't get down to the minutiae of policy proposal details, then yes, I agree. Not that it really matters for our broader discussion.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:18 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.