Dammit, you're always the critical one arent you? :laughing:

I love Pink Floyd , I fucking hate The Wall.

So I hate The Wall
I hate Bob Geldof

So it was never going to work for me really

I have every PF album, The Wall is actualy my second favorite album from them.

It`s kinda weird with Pink Floyd with me.

I seem to hate each album more the later they came out.

Apart from Atom Heart Mother , which I almost threw against the wall (ha) it was so bad

Atom Heart Mother was ok, the title track and Summer 68 were great, the other songs just sound more like musical concrete pieces rather than actual songs.

Other than that i disagree, i think their 70s stuff got a lot better than the post Syd stuff they did in the 60s, like More and Ummagumma...Meddle was the first truely great album they did after Piper At The Gates Of Dawn, and Dark Side Of The Moon was even better...I also rank Wish You Were Here and Animals among their best work...And even though their last 2 albums, Momentary Lapse Of Reason and The Division Bell are nothing great, i would certainly say they were better than The Final Cut, which is their worst in my opinion.

My theory end with the Wall , Quite honestly I can`t find myself to even attempt to listen to any 80s Floyd

Well, Final Cut is pretty lackluster, but Momentary Lapse Of Reason aint that bad.

well who doesn't do that?

i never seen him cut his nipple off in the movie.. i swear or at least i swear what i saw was him shaving the hair off of his face and chest and 'cut' his nipple but never cut it off per-say..he was just shaving his chest and cut it... you know its normal.. :laughing:

So do you like Piper at the gates of dawn....were you more a fan of Syd Barret?