Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   General Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/)
-   -   Top-50 All-time (Rough Draft) (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/23921-top-50-all-time-rough-draft.html)

CAPTAIN CAVEMAN 07-20-2007 01:19 AM

lol those bands suck

adidasss 07-20-2007 01:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Frances (Post 381638)
The ones I've bolded, in my opinion, shouldn't be anywhere near that list. The others are debatable, but the bold ones should go.

Can you elaborate on why you think RATM isn't worthy to be on some all time list? Other than the fact that you don't dig their music...?:-/

Son of JayJamJah 07-20-2007 01:39 AM

Last list of the night, the 100 Bands\Individuals I will consider for my top 50 list

Please inform me of any I have neglected you feel worthy of consideration

In no specific order beyond 50:

1. Led Zeppelin
2. The Beatles
3. The Rolling Stones
4. Jimi Hendrix
5. The Who
6. Bob Dylan
7. Eric Clapton
8. Stevie Wonder
9. Van Morrison
10. Queen
11. Rage Against the Machine
12. Nirvana
13. Pearl Jam
14. Pink Floyd
15. Green Day
16. Incubus
17. Metallica
18. Creedence Clearwater Revival
19. The Grateful Dead
20. The Beach Boys
21. The Allman Brothers Band
22. Bob Marley
23. Chuck Berry
24. Johnny Cash
25. Janis Joplin
26. Elvis Presley
27. The Doors
28. CSNY
29. The Police
30. System of a Down
31. Elvis Costello
32. Aretha Franklin
33. 311
34. David Bowie
35. Black Sabbath
36. Roy Orbison
37. Rakim
38. The Clash
39. Boston
40. Live
41. Lynyrd Skynyrd
42. Genesis
43. The Eagles
44. Bad Company
45. Marvin ***e
46. Ray Charles
47. Sublime
48. Tupac
49. Garth Brooks
50. Velvet Underground
51. Ben Harper
52. Red Hot Chili Peppers
53. Aerosmith
54. Jack Johnson
55. Weezer
56. KRS-ONE
57. Biggie Smalls
58. Elton John
59. Hank Williams Sr.
60. Van Halen
61. U2
62. Bruce Springsteen
63. Tim McGraw
64. Rush
65. Stone Temple Pilots
66. Yes
67. Prince
68. Earth Wind and Fire
69. The Bee Gees
70. James Brown
71. Soundgarden
72. The Guess Who
73. Steely Dan
74. Guns n’ Roses
75. Otis Redding
76. The Ramones
77. Journey
78. Robert Johnson
79. Alice in Chains
80. Sex Pistols
81. R.E.M
82. Michael Jackson
83. Randy Travis
84. Kenny Rogers
85. Tool
86. George Jones
87. Mos Def
88. Jay-Z
89. Miles Davis
90. Glenn Miller Band
91. The Band
92. Cream
93. Al Green
94. AC\DC
95. Radiohead
96. The Yardbirds
97. Buddy Holly
98. James Taylor
99. Etta James
100. Sam Cooke

i get high sometimes 07-20-2007 01:43 AM

It looks like you need to get over the 70s. All the musicians you added post 1979 just seem forced.

Son of JayJamJah 07-20-2007 01:44 AM

Two additions:

Ben Folds & Elvis Costello

Son of JayJamJah 07-20-2007 01:46 AM

get high:

The stuff I like from today is represented like Weezer and Jack Johnson, Ben Harper, Mos Def, System, Incubus Tool etc. How are those forced they are by no means staples of these type of lists.

i get high sometimes 07-20-2007 01:47 AM

are you making a personal favorites list, or an all around best list?

Son of JayJamJah 07-20-2007 01:58 AM

all-around

Major Criteria include (still a work in progress)

personal preference
popular opinion
technical ability
cultural significance\groundbreaking
relative success

boo boo 07-20-2007 10:01 AM

Quote:

15. Green Day
16. Incubus
17. Metallica

18. Creedence Clearwater Revival
19. The Grateful Dead
20. The Beach Boys
21. The Allman Brothers Band
22. Bob Marley
23. Chuck Berry
24. Johnny Cash
25. Janis Joplin
26. Elvis Presley
27. The Doors
28. CSNY
29. The Police
Quote:

30. System of a Down

31. Elvis Costello
32. Aretha Franklin
Quote:

33. 311

34. David Bowie
35. Black Sabbath
36. Roy Orbison
38. The Clash
Quote:

39. Boston
40. Live

41. Lynyrd Skynyrd
42. Genesis
43. The Eagles
Quote:

44. Bad Company

45. Marvin ***e
46. Ray Charles
Quote:

47. Sublime
48. Tupac
49. Garth Brooks

50. Velvet Underground
Quote:

51. Ben Harper
54. Jack Johnson
55. Weezer

58. Elton John
59. Hank Williams Sr.
60. Van Halen
61. U2
62. Bruce Springsteen
Quote:

63. Tim McGraw
64. Rush
65. Stone Temple Pilots

66. Yes
67. Prince
68. Earth Wind and Fire
69. The Bee Gees
70. James Brown
Quote:

72. The Guess Who

74. Guns n’ Roses
75. Otis Redding
76. The Ramones
Quote:

77. Journey

78. Robert Johnson
Quote:

79. Alice in Chains

80. Sex Pistols
81. R.E.M
82. Michael Jackson
Quote:

83. Randy Travis
84. Kenny Rogers

91. The Band
92. Cream
93. Al Green
94. AC\DC
95. Radiohead
96. The Yardbirds
97. Buddy Holly
98. James Taylor
99. Etta James
100. Sam Cooke


I take it this is a preference thing.

But whatever, nice to meet another Incubus fan for once.

Quote:

personal preference
I wouldn't put that criteria in a greatest list, if this was just preference it would make more since.

Quote:

popular opinion
Well for one, popular opinion can be pretty damn screwy. For example, Blink 182 are more popular than The Minutemen, Foreigner are more popular than Gentle Giant, Nickelback are more popular than Pavement, Kenny G is more popular than Ornette Coleman, Hanz Zimmer is more popular than Claude Debussy, Justin Timberlake is more popular than Elliot Smith.

And no ones opinions are really better than anothers as far as good music goes. Besides, popular opinion contradicts itself quite often.

Quote:

technical ability
By that criteria, Green Day shouldn't even be in the top 1000.

Quote:

cultural significance\groundbreaking
I love Incubus. But I don't see how in the hell they are culturally significant or groundbreaking.

Quote:

relative success
311 haven't had a hit in what. 10 years?

boo boo 07-20-2007 10:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by i get high sometimes (Post 381616)
any band that writes about lord of the rings is not worthy of a number one position on an all time best list.

Only 1 song about LOTR and 3 songs that briefy reference it.

Paul McCartney however wrote a song about HIS F*CKING DOG.

Yeah, a tribute to one of the greatest works in western literature, that is so much more pathetic than writing a music hall love ballad to an english sheepdog.

What in the hell is wrong with you people?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:57 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.