Music Banters Top 10 Pink Floyd Tracks
 

Nominations are in so it's poll time to determine the Floyd top 10.

Comfortably Numb is the shizy off the hizzy.

I voted for Time. Second choice would be Wish You Were Here.

Dogs for me. No surprise there.

I never would've expected Bike to make it while Shine On didn't make it.

My vote would have gone towards SOYCD if it were here, but I ended up voting for Dogs.

I still can't pick between Dogs and Echoes.

Time, Echoes was a close second.

Bike one of the top 10 best Pink Floyd songs?

Try top 10 worst Pink Floyd songs.

Astronomy Domine would have been a much better choice out of the Barrett songs.

Anyway. My favorite Pink Floyd song is Shine On, but out of these I gotta go with Echoes. But much love for Us & Them and Great Gig in the Sky also.

Not good enough. Sort it :D

I ended up voting for Echoes.

Voted for See Emily Play.

Dogs

I vote Wish you were here.

I would say that it's not their best work, but I really love it...

If I had to vote for their best song I would vote Echoes.

No...just no.


See Emily Play FTW

I don't think that something like that is even possible...do they have 10 bad songs?

I write in Pigs.

There will be no write-ins.

You do make the rules, you follow them.

Must I again threaten to ban you?

We could do that on The Beatles one. :shycouch:

See Emily Play

Woo, go see emily play.

Not to brag but I totally was the first one to pick See Emily Play for this poll. Jackhammer I demand you give me some points for this.

Being the first one to be wrong about something entitles you to nothing.

Still good to have you back though,

Ill take the 17 minute epic.

Animals truly is brilliant.

edit; wtf, The Great Gig in The Sky is one of the worst Floyd tracks.

:s

I'll go with Wish You Were Here for this.

It's one of my favorites. I think it's incredibly moving. What's not to like?

Run Like Hell and When the Tigers Broke Free should be on the list for sure. That's my two cents :-)

You should have voted for them when they were in the nominations thread, then.

Dogs.

Any colour you like... a close second...
but yeah, Dogs.

They haven't been here that long, cut him/her some slack and stop acting like a jackass.

Seriously? Ethan, you're reprimanding me about cutting newbies slack?

People in general need to stop injecting suggestions for new songs into this thread -- if they didn't vote in the nominations thread, that's their problem. Otherwise it just becomes a redundant thread.

I voted for Time, just as I did in the nominations thread. For a second there I didn't see it was an option and thought I was going to have to pick between Wish You Were Here and Great Gig in the Sky... that would have been a tough choice.

Agreed. And I can play it on piano. :p: