Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   General Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/)
-   -   Sopa (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/60036-sopa.html)

Janszoon 01-20-2012 06:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1144407)
I'm just the translator/messenger, although if The White House can veto against SOPA, it seems they are able to control the law to at least some extent.

The president is certainly part of the process, but I think a lot of people have an inflated perception that somehow it's all about him. Like I implied earlier, Obama did not author this bill and is not voting on this bill. The real politicians people should be complaining about here are SOPA's authors and supporters in the House of Representatives.

Guybrush 01-20-2012 06:44 AM

^I agree ..

Your post also makes me realize how little I know about the US political system. Here, the prime minister and his possè of ministers are generally the ones who come up with new laws. Then they present their suggested law to the parliament which will vote on whether or not to pass the government's suggestion. The parliament is made up of representatives from different political parties. The more votes a party has, the more representatives it has in the parliament.

So, SOPA in Norway would likely have come from the top (prime minister) to be voted for or against in parliament.

I feel a bit ignorant asking this, but how are laws thought up and passed in the US?

Janszoon 01-20-2012 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tore (Post 1144412)
^I agree ..

Your post also makes me realize how little I know about the US political system. Here, the prime minister and his possè of ministers are generally the ones who come up with new laws. Then they present their suggested law to the parliament which will vote on whether or not to pass the government's suggestion. The parliament is made up of representatives from different political parties. The more votes a party has, the more representatives it has in the parliament.

So, SOPA in Norway would likely have come from the top (prime minister) to be voted for or against in parliament.

I feel a bit ignorant asking this, but how are laws thought up and passed in the US?

Basically the way it works here is a bill would be proposed by members of one of the two houses of Congress (The House of Representatives and The Senate). Each house has a somewhat different way of doing things but basically the bill is introduced and voted on, and if it passes, it goes to the other house for voting. If it passes in that house, it goes through a little review process and then is sent to the president, who has ten days to either sign it or veto it. If he signs it, it becomes law. If he vetoes it, it goes back to Congress, who then have the option to rework the bill or vote to override the president's veto.

Dr_Rez 01-20-2012 11:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 1144416)
Basically the way it works here is a bill would be proposed by members of one of the two houses of Congress (The House of Representatives and The Senate). Each house has a somewhat different way of doing things but basically the bill is introduced and voted on, and if it passes, it goes to the other house for voting. If it passes in that house, it goes through a little review process and then is sent to the president, who has ten days to either sign it or veto it. If he signs it, it becomes law. If he vetoes it, it goes back to Congress, who then have the option to rework the bill or vote to override the president's veto.

A vetoed bill/law by the prez almost always means the congress will at least revise the document rather than just overriding him. Often the prez vetoes not because he dissagrees but would like something in the fine print o be changed.

Mykonos 01-21-2012 05:22 AM

So the President has the power to stop bad decisions but nothing absolute? I actually like that system. Most of the political analyses I've seen of the US wrre clearly biased against them so I never actually did know how the system worked. The Brits had a similar one in the past, although the House Of Lords were an unelected esrablishment so we rightfully took away their power to veto long ago. Also, even though she never uses it the Queen has the power to stop pretty much any Parliamentary decision, which I don't like.

Sorry, tangent. Some are urging the internet community to stop buying a single product or service linked to the companies supporting SOPA until April, putting a dent in their March profit margins. Sadly that means no new music until April.

Janszoon 01-21-2012 07:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RezZ (Post 1144690)
A vetoed bill/law by the prez almost always means the congress will at least revise the document rather than just overriding him. Often the prez vetoes not because he dissagrees but would like something in the fine print o be changed.

Right. It's actually pretty funny when you look at the list of vetoes. Obama has had 2. FDR had 635.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mykonos (Post 1144727)
So the President has the power to stop bad decisions but nothing absolute?

Yep, the president has a lot less power in this country than people often think he does.

Dr_Rez 01-21-2012 03:18 PM

Wow FDR was a stubborn stubborn man.

Guybrush 01-21-2012 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 1144416)
Basically the way it works here is a bill would be proposed by members of one of the two houses of Congress (The House of Representatives and The Senate). Each house has a somewhat different way of doing things but basically the bill is introduced and voted on, and if it passes, it goes to the other house for voting. If it passes in that house, it goes through a little review process and then is sent to the president, who has ten days to either sign it or veto it. If he signs it, it becomes law. If he vetoes it, it goes back to Congress, who then have the option to rework the bill or vote to override the president's veto.

Thanks for the explanation :)

blastingas10 01-23-2012 04:13 PM

We've been so focused on SOPA that they slipped ACTA past us.

Mrd00d 01-23-2012 05:02 PM

We (USA) signed it in October for cryin out loud. We're just waiting for it to ratify I believe. And/or waiting for other countries to sign on... And yes it sucks. People are getting protest fatigue from all this stuff. But as we all have heard, eternal vigilance is the cost of freedom.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:02 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.