Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   General Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/)
-   -   Does honesty matter? (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/70769-does-honesty-matter.html)

RL Clown 07-18-2013 01:33 PM

Does honesty matter?
 
Seriously, do musicians have to be honest?

I'll give you an example...

A rapper makes songs about drugs, prostitution, and gang violence. But the truth is this rapper actually grew up in a nice neighborhood. This rapper had a good education (He graduated from University). The last time he got into a fight with someone was back in elementary school.

^
Would you be a fan of this rapper?

Do you think that musicians have to be honest? Do you think that their lyrics have to reflect their true lifestyles?

Urban Hat€monger ? 07-18-2013 01:35 PM

Ridiculous question

If people only wrote songs about things they'd experienced themselves you'd have virtually no songs about anything.

Powerstars 07-18-2013 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hat€monger ? (Post 1346567)
Ridiculous question

If people only wrote songs about things they'd experienced themselves you'd have virtually no songs about anything.

Well, except maybe a song by The Who about Keith Moon. That would be pretty awesome. More on-topic, a lot of the music I like has lyrics that do not reflect personal experiences (Beatles, Queen), but a lot of it also does (Beatles again, Bon Jovi), so to me, it doesn't really matter

TheBig3 07-18-2013 01:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powerstars (Post 1346575)
Well, except maybe a song by The Who about Keith Moon. That would be pretty awesome. More on-topic, a lot of the music I like has lyrics that do not reflect personal experiences (Beatles, Queen), but a lot of it also does (Beatles again, Bon Jovi), so to me, it doesn't really matter

Hey, do you like music from the 1960's?!?!?!?

OT: No, it doesn't have to be honest. Convey a message.

Scarlett O'Hara 07-18-2013 02:28 PM

This is about as bad as your clown avatar. I thought song writing was supposed to be imaginative. Since when does honesty matter?

Paedantic Basterd 07-18-2013 02:34 PM

If it's a well-crafted story like those that Joanna Newsom or Colin Meloy tell, then I think that the sky's the limit, but if you're an average lyricist and you don't even have anything personal to share, I think that speaks to the quality of your writing. Does it affect the music? Not an ounce. Does it stand as a mark against the quality of your poetry/prose if you can't tell a decent story and have no artistry with your language? I do think so.

Necromancer 07-18-2013 02:52 PM

I would think its just as important as the music is on a 50-50 basis, but not as important by itself.

No different than a fact or fiction novel/story.

butthead aka 216 07-18-2013 06:32 PM

no it doent have to be honest. with the rap that you gave as an example i think the publics racial stereotypes play into that kind of success because a lot of times i think things need to be believable. image and look is important in that.

its also very different if you know the musician which most of us dont considering this is a music forum and we are tlakin about very famous artists. maybe having a shred of believability is all that is needed

Rjinn 07-18-2013 09:30 PM

I don't think the question is that silly. If artists are talking about themselves and making up their own experiences or owning something they don't, then their music wouldn't be very credible. I wouldn't really take it seriously in that regard. Otherwise it's just something they're trying to convey and like others have mentioned, sending a message.

Janszoon 07-18-2013 10:39 PM

I don't view fiction writing as dishonest so I'm not sure I even fully understand the question being asked in the OP.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:27 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.