Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   General Music (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/)
-   -   Nirvana vs The Smashing Pumpkins (https://www.musicbanter.com/general-music/77675-nirvana-vs-smashing-pumpkins.html)

skeetz 06-21-2014 11:31 PM

Nirvana vs The Smashing Pumpkins
 
Smashing Pumpkins are better.

Janszoon 06-21-2014 11:40 PM

Jesus. Stop.

The Ascension 06-21-2014 11:42 PM

Gonna get #flamed but I agree

Always thought Nirvana was overrated

On the grand scale of things Nirvana is more important, but I prefer the Smashing Pumpkins musically by a decent amount

Necromancer 06-22-2014 12:04 AM

Cobain is better than Corgan.

The Ascension 06-22-2014 12:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Necromancer (Post 1462636)
Cobain is better than Corgan.

The knock on the Pumpkins, for me, are their lyrics. Which I will definitely admit are below average at best. But, from a pure music perspective, I prefer Corgan's voice and the music/atmosphere that the Pumpkins produce compared to Nirvana. They delve into a lot of different sub genres.

skeetz 06-22-2014 12:12 AM

I like both bands. I think nirvana is better live. Smashing pumpkins however in my opinion have better quality songs. Kurt cobain is a better rock star than corgan but what can I say I enjoy listening more to the smashing pumpkins.

Btw I here that most people like Siamese dream more than Mellon collie. I actually like both albums. However I got hooked on Mellon collie quicker than Siamese dream. I believe that the song zero alone which is on the Mellon collie album is better than any other song on the Siamese dream album.

Necromancer 06-22-2014 12:32 AM

The Pumpkins don't have a lot of material I actually like other than 3 or 4 songs. Crogans voice is weak in comparison to the strength and projection of Cobain. I don't really see the SPs being more versatile than Nirvana, but I can see their softer approach musically being more desirable to listeners.

The Ascension 06-22-2014 12:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Necromancer (Post 1462653)
The Pumpkins don't have a lot of material I actually like other than 3 or 4 songs. Crogans voice is weak in comparison to the strength and projection of Cobain. I don't really see the SPs being more versatile than Nirvana, but I can see their softer approach musically being more desirable to listeners.

I actually think each of Cobain and Corgan's voices fit the genres they are playing almost to a tee.

I'm definitely not against rough music, but the Smashing Pumpkins are more up my own alley in terms of musical preferences.

I mean, I'm not gonna act like the Pumpkins are a WAY better band than Nirvana or anything - I could even say myself, objectively, that Nirvana is and should be considered "better". I just prefer the Pumpkins myself, though.

Necromancer 06-22-2014 12:53 AM

Of course, individual taste is all that matters after all is said and done.

skeetz 06-22-2014 12:54 AM

The first thing about the pumpkins that caught my attention was Billy Corgan's voice. It was whiny and unorthodox. I thought to myself that it was pretty unique and it was something I've never actually heard before. So anyway that sparked my first interest in the band. I later discovered how great Corgan put together instruments to enhance the band musically. Nirvana had the attitude. The pumpkins had the aesthetics more so.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:51 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.