| Rexx Shredd |
11-28-2014 04:19 AM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninetales
(Post 1514489)
well I mean black and death metal are completely different, so theres that.
|
"Completely different"? Ha! :D Country and Classical are "completely different". Go one further: Symphonic Metal and Pop Metal are different..... I can make your argument and say Black Metal and Death Metal are different (mainly due to the vocal styles and the sometimes satanic overtones associated with one) and enough to earn their own categories - but are they (as you say) "completely different"? I don't think so :D.
......Which brings me back to the point: Do we really need a Grind Metal sub category? Is "Grind Metal" SO different that it earns its own unique label?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninetales
(Post 1514489)
Math-rock/metal does have a distinct sound too.
|
Math Rock is just an extreme - sometimes heavier - form of Progressive Rock, isn't it? Why not just call it "Extreme Prog" - wouldn't that make more sense? :D
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ninetales
(Post 1514489)
And I mean some genres just have dumb names, but it doesn't mean they aren't separate from others in some way. wtf does "shoegaze" mean, but its a pretty recognizable genre.
|
You are making my point: its recognizable to people familiar with it. What about a listener out there ready to try something different on the sonic pallette? how does calling something "Math Rock" or "Shoegaze" help them to understand what it is and give it a go?
Well, Im not going to argue with you: Opinions are opinions and Im not going to debate whether or not chocolate ice cream tastes better than vanilla ice cream, but - to me - your examples are making my point.
You are debating differences under a microscope to earn genre and sub-genre titles which, I not only disagree with, but it pigeon-holes artists. Pigeon-holing an artist is a disservice to them, because when they try to add some variety to what they do - and step outside their boxes - it is often met with contempt
Like I said above, this is the difference between bands from the 60s and 70s til now. I think there is a dire need for bands like The Beatles or Queen who just wrote what they feel/ explored a wide variety of musical territory, and whose body of work can fall under many many of today's category labels without the pressure of remaining in a box.
"I don't like Anal Gravy's new song! They are supposed to be a Math Rock band but the new song is too Shoegaze for me!" :rolleyes:
|