Have U2 dated more or less than these 80s bands?
I've been discussing various bands of the 80s with my parents, and most particularly had a different opinion to my dad over whether U2 or The Icicle Works sounded older. He (who hates U2) claimed U2, but I thought that the Icicle Works sounded older. Below is a song example by both (first is the Icicle Works, the latter U2's Sunday Bloody Sunday video, which is similar to on the album):
m.youtube.com/watch?v=85mvq5XxjKk m.youtube.com/watch?v=EM4vblG6BVQ I argue that U2 sound quite like an early version of Coldplay or (90s) Radiohead, but my dad says that they have dated more than a lot of other rock. Of the bands below, which seems to you (have you heard of any or all in their 80s incarnations) like they have dated most or least? *U2 *The Icicle Works *REM *The Smiths *Guns N Roses *Echo and the Bunnymen *New Order Please exclude any music by these bands post 1990. |
i agree with you in this case, that icicle song was 80's as f*ck.
From those artist i would say the least dated for me would be U2 and The Smiths and the most dated would be REM and Guns n roses. To me the smiths could still pass off as a new indie band, a song like "Please let me get what i want" would be a hit in any era and U2 for better or worse always comes up with a radio hit once in awhile and stays relevant. REM and GNR to me though are pure 90's. every REM song ive heard still sounds like it belongs in a 90's college radio station and GNR always reminds of the hair metal of the late 80's early 90's. |
U2 stinks now-a-days if you ask me. Bullet the Blue Sky was a great song though.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Care to elaborate on that? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Indie rock still lives on, and the Smiths could very well fit into the whole Interpol wave. As for U2, I haven't really heard anything from them since the Beautiful Day album, I thought they should have continued to push their more experimental 90's sound. |
Quote:
glad to see im not the only one who sees it like that. |
U2 still feels reletivley current, but that doesn't mean that they don't suck.
|
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:05 AM. |
© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.