Question, Don do you have any opinion on emo outside of this one "scholar journal"? Cause all i've seen is you generating your entire opinion on a genre from one article. Which is kind of weak...
Here are some links you should try and disapprove and fix ya' know cause they're wrong and I just wanna see how they're totally wrong.
http://fourfa.com
http://www.musicbanter.com/showthread.php?t=7002
http://www.musicbanter.com/showthread.php?t=13388
Shouldn't be hard since this scholar journal is so well done for you to disprove these aye?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
When did I ever say "The Used are an emo band?" This is not what I'm arguing here. Everyone's saying that The Used aren't emo at all. I'm saying what you just said, they drew influences and consequently emo shows in some of their tracks.
|
Hey, it would be kind of cool if you could actually list how it shows and in which tracks. Ya know like *insert song here* you can obviously here inlfluneces from *insert band here* in the screaming/guitaring/drumming etc.. Instead of just going "Oh well they do cause I say so and I don't need to bring up any facts to back this up." Back up your post with facts and maybe people will start to take you more seriously.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
It doesn't matter if emo first stood for electric mother onion, the only thing that matters is what historically happened with the style.
|
See now this post made me LOL. *compares taking back sunday to heroin* *compares saetia to heroin*. Well its pretty obvious which band has emo roots there. Taking Back Sunday of course. :rolleyes:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
I've already explained to you why your hideous logic is wrong. I said that initially emo was short for emotional, that's where the word ****ing came from.
|
Can you proves this? Emo could just as easiley mean emotive, emote, emollient and probaly more words I can't think of.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
Emo is a branch alternative/indie rock and some is very closely related to punk-pop with the use of whiny vocals, though it's a bit more intricate.
|
See now this post is completely inaccurate, you dismiss nearly every band that laid the foundations of emo regardless of which you consider emo. (See electric oceans post). You basically dismiss the entire screamo genre off. I fail to see how this "punk-pop" is closely related to emo. Then again with your logic, anberlin is emo and they sound the same as simple plan. Acutally have you heard untitled by simple plan? That song is emo according to your standards, even though it has 0 punk elements or hardcore elements. Also could you define indie-rock? I was pretty sure indie-rock was just rock group on an indepedent label which isn't a genre because it doesn't like the bands through actual sound. I've never known what "alternative rock is" i've always been told its alternative to mainstream rock, but I havn't bothered to ask around and look so I am not exactly going to stand by that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
The lyrics of emo are mostly deeply personal, usually poetry or intimate confessionals.
|
I'm going to quote some of these "emo" lyrics.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Taking Back Sunday "Timberwolves At New Jersey
Get up, get up
Come on, come on, lets go
There’s just a few things
I think that you should know
Those words at best
were worse than teenage poetry
Fragment ideas
and too many pronouns
Stop it, come on
You’re not making sense now
You can't make them want you
They're all just laughing
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Anberlin "Day Late Friend"
so let me get this straight
all these years and you were no where to be found
and now you want me for your own
but you're a day late and my love, she's still renowned
we are who we were when
could've been lovers but at least you're still my day late friend
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Atmosphere "52 Pick Up"
Come here little rabbit, I'm going to give you a treat, take a seat
I'd like to tell you a little story, about a boy; he couldn't make ends meet
Not only that but he couldn't make sense out of the daily walk
Or the way we talk
Or how much though can be put into the price of advertising
I was watching him when he stepped forward to speak
Under the impression that he was just another local freak
Never would have guessed that he was capable of taking out a cluster of droids!
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dashboard Confessional "Swiss Army Romance"
We're not twenty-one,
but the sooner we are,
the sooner the fun will begin,
so get out your fake eyelashes,
and fake i.d's,
& real disasters ensue,
it's cool to take these chances.
It's cool to fake romances
& grow up fast.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by My Chemical Romance "Bury Me In Black"
Just give us war, worn lipstick by the door if I inflame
These eyes have had too much to drink again tonight
Black skies, we'll douse ourselves in high explosive light
Just give us war, I've been calling you all week
for my shotgun
|
I could go on, but I am not going to. To be honest those lyrics don't fit the bill all that well. They seem kind of lame and not very poetic. Now poetic would be well example saetia.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Saetia "Postlapsaria"
I am the horizon.
I have dreamed of tracing rings around this world.
My arms are stretched to forever.
My fingers shake with the fear of control.
The fear I know you all know so well.
We all lay claim to our destinies.
Yet we all rise and fall with the current.
|
Thats is poetic and very emotional, I think it fits your definition way better, but I think thats stupid. Judging an entire genre on lyrics, why not have sexo? Or politicalo? Cause their is definetly enough lyrics on both going around, why can't they have their own genre? Infact, screw metal, classical etc.. Lets start grouping all the bands by lyrics instead. Because music isn't about sound, its about lyrics right?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
Who here has heard their latest album 'In Love and Death'?” The class shake their heads in unison.
|
This post is completely ignorant and fictional. I own the album, and you didn't even bother checking as to whether or not anyone else did. I have each used album. They're pop-punk with screaming, some tracks have slight hardcore elements but hardly enough to be considered emotionally driven hardcore.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Crowquill
"well hell since no one knows what emo is i'll just slap the title onto them sounds more attractive then pop-rock" and then it went from their into the current wave of mediocre pop groups that MTV and other such companies have labelled "emo". Similar to what they've labelled punk, good charlotte and simple plan?
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
That's what more or less happened and is exactly what I mean by evolved.
|
Here you also consider false labelling evolving.
Quote:
Wow, so I know nothing about emo when all you've done is agree with what I just said. There is no ****ing difference between saying emo is short for emotional and saying it's short for emotional hardcore.
|
See this makes me laugh, because you basically say hardcore isn't anything by saying theres no difference between saying emo is short for emotional and emo is short for emotionaly hardcore. Theres a huge difference.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Don
Moreover, it should be noted that Rites of Spring don't just play emo, they also play post-hardcore, alternative pop/rock and indie rock. And this is the same for most emo bands (or any band for that matter), they do not stick to just one style
|
Now i've heard rites of spring's first album. As stated before I don't really think indie-rock is a proper genre. Its about as accurate of a definition as this supposed "emotional music" its too vast to be considered a genre. I mean indie rock could mean Crass, Red Light Sting, and Mae. These bands have nothing in common, but are all on independent record labels and play some form of rock music therefore, indie rock. You need to elobrate on this post. Also you said, rites of spring we're the first emo band, but they only had a few emo tracks. Wouldn't that mean they just put out the first emo songs, and weren't technically the first emo band, but in the post you also said they were. That contradicts itself, and also judging by your definition rites of spring wasn't the first one to do emo, Barry Manilow came before him and by your standards he was emo and their is probaly there was probaly alot more people before him playing emo. Just going by your standards. You're whole arguement is sketchy and poorly done as best. The bands are hardly linked. The emo education thread history seems way more likely to be valid then this "professionally written music article". But hey, if you wanna make it in the music industry you're on the right path. Keep going with whatever sells and believe everything you see on MTV. :thumb:
Oh I am also kind of stupid, seeing as you said that you've argued it before you can just copy and paste. Not too hard for a genius like you. Because all you really did was basically say "no you're wrong". Can you actually argue this statement this time? Assuming you can do that without your precious article, i'd like to see you stand on your own two feet in this arguement instead of just saying READ THE SCHOLAR JOURNAL.
The post I was refering to
Another thing, I think scholar journals are great for math, scienece etc... But they're kind of weak for music, art etc...Thats just my stance though. You're whole arguement once again has been lame, you've hardly been able to stand on you're own two feet and shock-shock people who know what they're talking about have been able to!
P.S. Don't be afraid to admit you're wrong on some points (or all) I doubt anyone will dog you constantly for it and treat you like crap. I'd personally think more of you for admitting to what you we're wrong then continuing to fight a lost battle.