Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Hardcore & Emo (https://www.musicbanter.com/hardcore-emo/)
-   -   New TBS CD (https://www.musicbanter.com/hardcore-emo/1789-new-tbs-cd.html)

Thrice 07-27-2004 04:16 PM

New TBS CD
 
I got it early this morning, and it is pretty good. I think there first one was better. Let me know what you all think of it.

David Frost 07-27-2004 05:37 PM

as in their first release, do you mean the cd they had before this one, or do you mean the first release they had. there is a big difference

Thrice 07-27-2004 06:16 PM

Enlighten me, because as far as i know, they only have two cd's. I was referring to Tell all your friends. Is there a CD before they split up?

David Frost 07-27-2004 06:28 PM

i know there is music that was released from them before the cd tell all your friends. im not a huge fan so i didnt pay much attention to it but i think the bassist sang on it and there were 3-5 songs. it was a demo release. i was suprised it was them because it wasnt that bad

Thrice 07-27-2004 07:16 PM

ya they switched a few members around, it was probably before the setup they have now. i think i have heard of it. thanks for the info.

Who_Cares 07-28-2004 03:13 AM

I got it a couple days ago and I like it a lot, but im gonna have to agree with everyone and say that Tell All Your Friends was a better cd...

Who_Cares 07-28-2004 03:51 AM

Favorite song on the cd would be # 9, it might not be their best on the cd, but i think its the catchiest


ps. does anyone else hate Modest Mouse with a passion? music video is on and made me think of how much i despise them...

IamAlejo 07-28-2004 12:18 PM

How many of their songs have you heard? (modest mouse that is)

David Frost 07-28-2004 12:34 PM

thats a good question, the new modest mouse isnt anything much to look at. however, they have been around for quite some time and making great music before this video

Who_Cares 07-28-2004 03:13 PM

Ive only heard that one song on mtv and ****, but if the rest of their stuff is like that i think they are really bad, but i prolly shouldnt say anything until i hear th rest of them

David Frost 07-28-2004 03:25 PM

download

dramamine


best song ever

Thrice 07-28-2004 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Who_Cares
I got it a couple days ago and I like it a lot, but im gonna have to agree with everyone and say that Tell All Your Friends was a better cd...

How'd you get it a couple of days ago?

emocapella 07-28-2004 08:43 PM

lol obviously he doesnt have it nd is just trying to fit in. no but i really was disappointed with Where You Want to Be. I knew John Nolan had left but had no idea wut a big difference it was going to make. in Tell All Your Friends, they were the one band that set themselves apart from the rest by featuring a hardcore sound without becoming a screamo band. They were different than most bands and thats wut i liked about them. a large part of this was Nolan's voice b/c it was raspy nd throaty nd added that hardcore sound to it. O'Connell, the guy that replaced Nolan, has tried to fill his shoes and has not come even close. i do think Lazarra has developed as a singer, but now, without Nolan, they just sound like every other emo band out there, which isnt sooo terrible, but it is dissappointing.

deliriumtrigger 07-28-2004 09:58 PM

i wasnt sure if i was gonna like it due to the fact that they lost two members. however teh new cd is really amazing. still not quite as good as the first though. but it comes closer than i ever thought it would. teh new bassist in my opinion is better than the old one. however, Nolan just cant be replaced. so it falls just a little bit short of tell all your friends.

Who_Cares 07-29-2004 01:24 AM

I got the CD b4 it was widespread released or w/e because the CD Connection in my town said that they got it straight from the label , i didnt really ask questions , just was happy to take it + why would i be lying about getting the CD, im not that hung up on attention, but if you get your jollies by callin people liers and starting things, then by all means keep it up, do what makes you happy :ar_15s:

Sweet_Irony 07-29-2004 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by emocapella
lol obviously he doesnt have it nd is just trying to fit in. no but i really was disappointed with Where You Want to Be. I knew John Nolan had left but had no idea wut a big difference it was going to make. in Tell All Your Friends, they were the one band that set themselves apart from the rest by featuring a hardcore sound without becoming a screamo band. They were different than most bands and thats wut i liked about them. a large part of this was Nolan's voice b/c it was raspy nd throaty nd added that hardcore sound to it. O'Connell, the guy that replaced Nolan, has tried to fill his shoes and has not come even close. i do think Lazarra has developed as a singer, but now, without Nolan, they just sound like every other emo band out there, which isnt sooo terrible, but it is dissappointing.

I just wanted to point out that O'Connell is the drummer, and has been there all along, Fred Mascherino replaced John Nolan. I agree though, I was dissappointed with the new CD too. I liked it and all, it's catchy as hell, but it's just not the same Taking Back Sunday I orginally loved. The lyrics aren't as deep, which I guess, in large part, has to do with John & Shaun leaving the band. It's a good CD, but it's not their best work.

They still rock live though. I just saw them at Warped on the 21st and they were amazing. I met Eddie Reyes and Mark O'Connell and they were two of the nicest people I've ever met.

One more thing: I don't like them being on MTV. It saddens me. Maybe I'm selfish, but I like feeling like I had the band to myself (even though I really don't because so many people know them anyway) and not having to worry about people always being like, "lYkE oMg!!!! tHoSe GuYs In ThAt OnE bAnD, lYkE tAkInG bAcK sOmEtHiNg R lYkE tOtAlLy HoTt!!! lYkE, oMg!!!" (It took me forever to type like that, and it's really annoying)
Blah. I don't care. I'm a selfish bitch.

Thrice 07-30-2004 05:41 PM

I'm going to warped tomorrow, but I talked to my friend who went today, and he said they didnt feel like playing or something. If thats the case tomorrow I will be really pissed considering they are one of the most looked forward to bands on the tour...

Sweet_Irony 08-03-2004 01:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thrice
I'm going to warped tomorrow, but I talked to my friend who went today, and he said they didnt feel like playing or something. If thats the case tomorrow I will be really pissed considering they are one of the most looked forward to bands on the tour...



That would piss me off. They just didn't play because they didn't feel like it?

Somebody needs a reality check.

I sound so cliche, but it's true. That kind of thing really makes me mad.
I have so many mixed emotions about them now.


I think I'll go listen to my Brand New CDs. :)

riseagainstrocks 08-03-2004 10:46 AM

This cd is much harder and therefore automatically better lol. I like it more than their previous work...

Thrice 08-03-2004 09:30 PM

I like some of it better, but it lacks the emotion of the old stuff.

allysguitar 08-04-2004 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by deliriumtrigger
i wasnt sure if i was gonna like it due to the fact that they lost two members. however teh new cd is really amazing. still not quite as good as the first though. but it comes closer than i ever thought it would. teh new bassist in my opinion is better than the old one. however, Nolan just cant be replaced. so it falls just a little bit short of tell all your friends.

I agree, Lazzara needs Nolan to counteract his seemingly cavalier demeanour.....oh yeah, Nolan faultlessly compliments Lazzara's voice.

allysguitar 08-04-2004 08:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sweet_Irony
I just wanted to point out that O'Connell is the drummer, and has been there all along, Fred Mascherino replaced John Nolan. I agree though, I was dissappointed with the new CD too. I liked it and all, it's catchy as hell, but it's just not the same Taking Back Sunday I orginally loved. The lyrics aren't as deep, which I guess, in large part, has to do with John & Shaun leaving the band. It's a good CD, but it's not their best work.

They still rock live though. I just saw them at Warped on the 21st and they were amazing. I met Eddie Reyes and Mark O'Connell and they were two of the nicest people I've ever met.

One more thing: I don't like them being on MTV. It saddens me. Maybe I'm selfish, but I like feeling like I had the band to myself (even though I really don't because so many people know them anyway) and not having to worry about people always being like, "lYkE oMg!!!! tHoSe GuYs In ThAt OnE bAnD, lYkE tAkInG bAcK sOmEtHiNg R lYkE tOtAlLy HoTt!!! lYkE, oMg!!!" (It took me forever to type like that, and it's really annoying)
Blah. I don't care. I'm a selfish bitch.


allysguitar 08-04-2004 08:09 PM

yes, I hate MTV and I also hate knowing that they too now have music videos....just like EVERYBODY else

felix 08-05-2004 01:39 AM

I've had the CD for a while now (I downloaded it back in early July) but I did manage to get to the mall and buy it today. I really liked it when I first listened to it. But as I listened to it more I found myself not so thrilled by it. I have to say I liked Tell All Your Friends much more. I didn't want to believe that Nolan leaving would make such a huge difference, but his absence becomes appearant quickly. The songs don't have the same emotion and the lyrics on the new disk aren't the same. The highlights on the disk would have to be Bonus Mosh Pit Part 2, Slowdance On The Inside(more like the old stuff) and Little Devotional(very catchy). And I don't think getting play on MTV is such bad thing either. If they can become rich and famous doing what they love, all the best to them. Theres no need to be bitter because Average Joe enjoys whichever singles MTV decides to air of your once "little-known" band.

P.S. For anyone who hasn't checked out John's new band Straylight Run I suggest you do. You can download what they've tracked so far at www.straylightrun.com

Thrice 08-05-2004 04:26 PM

They are ok...I'd say the mars volta of TBS

allysguitar 08-07-2004 07:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by felix
I've had the CD for a while now (I downloaded it back in early July) but I did manage to get to the mall and buy it today. I really liked it when I first listened to it. But as I listened to it more I found myself not so thrilled by it. I have to say I liked Tell All Your Friends much more. I didn't want to believe that Nolan leaving would make such a huge difference, but his absence becomes appearant quickly. The songs don't have the same emotion and the lyrics on the new disk aren't the same. The highlights on the disk would have to be Bonus Mosh Pit Part 2, Slowdance On The Inside(more like the old stuff) and Little Devotional(very catchy). And I don't think getting play on MTV is such bad thing either. If they can become rich and famous doing what they love, all the best to them. Theres no need to be bitter because Average Joe enjoys whichever singles MTV decides to air of your once "little-known" band.

P.S. For anyone who hasn't checked out John's new band Straylight Run I suggest you do. You can download what they've tracked so far at www.straylightrun.com

Any individual who gets paid to do something that he or she loves to do is quite blessed. TBS's acceptance of MTV's offer isn't bad at all, some people would think you'd have to be out of your mind to turn down that kind of cash. It's the image MTV "artists" portray that has diminished whatever minuscule amount of respect i ever had for MTV to a sad inexsistence. That is why it's almost a dissapointment to see an original, talented, presumably unmaterialistic artist sign an agreeement with MTV enabling many viewers to subconciously place them next to brittany spears and the untalented likeness in a otherwise unheard of comparison. Music videos have also succeeded in creating a flawless image of "artists" thus forming a new surreal account for viewers. What are live shows for anyway? Ultimately it is great to see TBS succeed in ways some musicians could only dream of, I'm sure TBS has given hope to similar aspiring musicians.

mikka 08-12-2004 12:20 AM

i am totally in love with Taking back sundays new cd i sorta like alittle better than the last one.

mikka 08-12-2004 12:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thrice
I got it early this morning, and it is pretty good. I think there first one was better. Let me know what you all think of it.

yeah it's pretty great i really like number 2 and 3 on the new cd

XxHOTDAMNxX 08-12-2004 02:21 PM

okay i'm just gonna say i love tbs no matter what, even though 2 of them left.. they're still awesome.. i do like the new cd.. maybe not as much as tell all your friends, but i am completely in love w/ the song "new american classic" and u can't just stop loving them they're really great. practically my fav. band so... if u loved them before.. just stick w/them..

MyFavouriteAccident 12-13-2005 07:21 AM

the new one is ok, but nothing compares to their first, timberwolves at new jersey and cute with the e, those are the songs that make me love tbs

A_Perfect_Sonnet 12-13-2005 12:21 PM

Don't bump 4 month old threads on crappy cds.

ArtistInTheAmbulance 12-13-2005 12:29 PM

^Yes. I think I hate the latest CD. I used to think "meh, its okay, good for every once in a while if there's nothing else to listen to" but I just get pissed off when Im listening to it now. Like "why isn't this song over yet" kinda thing.

Not too promising really.

EDGE 01-15-2006 01:50 PM

um.
I won't lie.
I like this band.
:(


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:53 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.