Seminal Post Hardcore Albums: The Best
 

After talking about seminal post hardcore albums I realized there's a lot and they kick ass. I'm putting a poll up on here to see which are the best received by MB. I imagine it being a tight battle.

(the other one just like, didn't even take me to the poll screen)

Neither did this one it seems.

lulz

Yeah I guess if you take more than 5 minutes it just ****s your ass

I'll try again on a computer and maybe I'll win eventually

I shoulda had my options planned ahead if time

Was gonna put

Slint - Spiderland
Refused - The Shape of Punk to Come
Squirrel Bait - Skag Heaven
Unwound - Leaves Turn Inside You
Nomeansno - Wrong
Husked Du - Zen Arcade
Minutemen - Double Nickels on the Dime
Glassjaw - Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Silence
Rodan - Rusty
Rites of Spring - End on End
Moss Icon - Lybernum Wits End Liberation Fly

**** dude, idk if i could choose but it's between the top 3.

I guess ask a mod to make the poll. I think they can add one onto thread in post-production.

Yeah do that, mod **** bitches

Respond to my verbal anger

I suppose you could add an 'other' option too

I could do it but I'm lazy right now.

It's award season. Time to schmooze if you want that Best Mod trophy.

Did I win last year? I honestly forget. I may have. It's okay. We all know what's good.

Yeah. Grindy.

Swap Everything You Wanted to Know for Worship and Tribute?

Grindy won? Good. Good mod.

Since this is a question I'll answer, nah.

Swap these hands

Coalesce - Functioning on Impatience
Deadguy - Fixation on a Coworker
The Dillinger Escape Plan - Calculating Infinity
Botch - We Are the Romans

We picked my least favorite Dillinger album unfortunately.

lol wrong thread

That's what I get for having multiple tabs open. Lol. I'm leaving it.

I also had Indian Summer - Science 1994 on that list

no Fugazi? Drive Like Jehu?

Yank Crime was also included.

Fugazi is very clearly a seminal post hardcore band but I dunno what album would be here. I mean, Repeater, In on the Kill Taker, Red Medicine, and the Argument are all very highly regarded

Come to think of it I dont even what my personal favorite would be

answer: The Arguement

I'll have to consult with some other people, someone might say another one is my favorite

Should add atdi and jawbox too

The Argument could very well bent fav Fugazi actually. It's either that or In On the Kill Taker.

Jawbox came to mind when making the list but I totally forgot ATDI. Relationship of Command would be the one to add right? That's always been my least fav tbh

This, and Relationship Of Command by At the Drive-In. I mean seriously, what kinda Post-hardcore thread is this where no one mentions ROC. C'mon now

I do PCP

What about

The Fall of Troy - s/t
Birds in Row - You, Me, and the Violence

100%

it's like mondo is so hipster that we can't even hipster with him because his hipster is more hipster than our hipster

everything I've mentioned in here is so outrageously not underground

Mondo knows all the music. Question him not, for he be the wiser. I liked ROC, a little over produced at times but it was their most intense record IMO. Its been so long since ice listened to atdi that I can't really comment on their other albums.

i wasn't questioning mondo, he knows his ****. it's just in most cases i've never heard of the ****.

I forgot a lot of albums

your avi still makes me hard

Vaya is ATDI's best release followed by In/Casino/Out and tied with Relationship of Command. There are only like 5 or 6 good songs on Acrobatic Tenement but those 5 or 6 songs rock.

That is all.

Oh that's right, I couldn't remember the name. Acrobatic Tenement is my favorite

Ass

Husker Du "Zen Arcade"
Hot Water Music "Fuel for the Hate game" & "Caution"
Rites of Spring "End on End"
Embrace "s/t"
Big Black "Songs about Fxcking"
Dag Nasty "Can I Say"
Fugazi "Repeater"
Rollins Band "Weight" & "The End of Silence"
At the Drive-In "Relationship of Command"
Thrice "The Artist in the Ambulance"
Shabutie (Coheed & Cambria) "Penelope"

I have some homework to do, thanks all. I’m post hardcore curious. Hardcore curious too tbh