Music Banter - Elliott Smith

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)

- Indie & Alternative (https://www.musicbanter.com/indie-alternative/)

- - Elliott Smith (https://www.musicbanter.com/indie-alternative/18502-elliott-smith.html)

I'm yet to listen to that album for the albums thing, but Laith loves this guy. So I ussually like alot of his taste so lets just wait and see

Quote:

Originally Posted by Crowquill

I could care less about Kurt Cobain, the fact is it was declared inconclusive. Lighten up seriously.

You're full of contradictions, you say all either/or is a good album. Then say all his albums suck. (as pointed out by moonlit). You also say, after he left Kill Rock Stars his music sucked, yet he didn't just release either/or on kill rock stars he also released self titled. Another contradiction. And I wasn't aware either/or was his back catalogue, brand new news to me.

EDIT: Nice, edit your post after I post mine in hopes to make me look dumb. Genius move and I didn't include Roman Candle because it was released on Cavity Search.

Firstly, my edit wasn't after yours, and if it was it was by a split second seeing as I never saw your post before my edit. Secondly, check your facts, for your sake, before you say dumb things. Either/or was on Kill Rock Stars, in fact it was his final album on that label.

His death was ruled a suicide, so if you an a couple other conspirators wanna say it was 'inconclusive' then go for it. I'll stick to believing the people who examined evidence, and who are trained to make those kind of desicions.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bungalowbill357

No it wasnt, do your research it was declared inconclusive as of 06.

And I never said either/or wasn't released on kill rock stars. "he didn't just release either/or on kill rock stars he also released self titled."

Learn to read n00b.

I am aware of what albums he released on Kill Rock Stars, and of them, Either/or is the only one worth buying.
He sucks, you can go listen to your singer songwriter sh*t and suck Bright Eyes and Elliott Smith's balls all you want. Doesn't change the fact that 90% of their output is garbage.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bungalowbill357

lol, temper temper mr facts. You should go to teh doctor for last word syndrome fo real.

Quote:

You should go to teh doctor for last word syndrome fo real.

Talk about contradiction.

It's natural for scene kids to d*ck ride their favorite musicians and not give it up.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bungalowbill357

Talk about contradiction.

It's natural for scene kids to d*ck ride their favorite musicians and not give it up.

I'd like to point out to you Alex that you love love loved Bright Eyes for the longest time. I don't know if you do now but now you're saying he's bad. quit being a contradictory elitist

I do like Bright Eyes, once again, about 2 albums.

And seeing as this is no longer an elliott smith disucussion in anyway, the arguement is over.

Back to his music,

hxxp://www.sendspace.com/file/bg7l8a - XO

hxxp://www.sendspace.com/file/zm1t93 - From A Basement On The Hill

hxxp://www.sendspace.com/file/6jvsoa - either/or

If I find anymore links i'll post them.

I have no idea why Ethan seems to think that Alex steals his opinions from me or whatever, since other than both liking Screamo and a few popular Indie bands, our tastes are pretty different. Anyway, I like Either/Or (bit overrated, though), and haven't really bothered listening to the rest of his albums. I don't really care if Alex thinks they're garbage or if Ethan thinks they're the best thing ever, because I'm just not interested in listening to Elliott Smith anymore than I do now.

Happy?

Oh, and Rufus Wainwright > Jesus > Elliott Smith > Bright Eyes.