Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Mb Awards Voting!!! (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/16692-mb-awards-voting.html)

Real_Eyez_C_Real_Lies 06-11-2006 02:31 AM

so for the people who joined MB on May 15th, they can't vote...right?

littleknowitall 06-11-2006 07:08 AM

wait, did i vote for nothing then? or have i qualified for being here long enough...??

swim 06-11-2006 07:13 AM

^you've been here since december, yes, you can vote.

littleknowitall 06-11-2006 07:15 AM

haha, i can vote! woohoo!

although, now i have no excuse for not getting a nomination apart from the fact that i'm a droning sad ass. :(

jr. 06-11-2006 12:10 PM

I nominate Moley as Most Droning Sad Ass

littleknowitall 06-11-2006 12:11 PM

I'd take it if it wasn't too late...

jr. 06-11-2006 12:12 PM

You'd win it, too.


EDIT* Man, I just owned the heck out of you, I think.

adidasss 06-11-2006 05:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by right-track
I doubt you or Urban will win that category. Whoever nominated either of you as being closed minded... it's beyond me.
Both you and Urban are 2 of the most open minded members here, in different ways of course.
And I voted you most open minded. :)

i call bullshit...i nominated both and for good reason....music wise....

right-track 06-11-2006 05:11 PM

Your saying Urban and jr. are both closed minded when it comes to music?
How?

Urbans tastes are varied and as for jr. it's obvious to me he picks up on new stuff all the time, it's one of the reasons he visits these boards (same as me).
Like anyone else they both have the right to choose whether or not they like what they hear...

littleknowitall 06-11-2006 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
You'd win it, too.


EDIT* Man, I just owned the heck out of you, I think.

you did :D and there's me thinking you were a 'seeker of peace!'

adidasss 06-11-2006 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by right-track
Your saying Urban and jr. are both closed minded when it comes to music?
How?

Urbans tastes are varied and as for jr. it's obvious to me he picks up on new stuff all the time, it's one of the reasons he visits these boards (same as me).
Like anyone else they both have the right to choose whether or not they like what they hear...

i haven't noticed a great interest in new music in either of them...especially jr.

it's not an insult nor should i be considered an asshole by either of those two for nominating them, that's just how i see things...maybe jr. is more than willing to experiment in real life...but i haven't noticed him posting about a single band that's not from the 70's or before...

Barnard17 06-11-2006 05:21 PM

I voted for me whenever I could. Largely because I'm damn sexy.

right-track 06-11-2006 05:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
i haven't noticed a great interest in new music in either of them...especially jr.

it's not an insult nor should i be considered an asshole by either of those two for nominating them, that's just how i see things...maybe jr. is more than willing to experiment in real life...but i haven't noticed him posting about a single band that's not from the 70's or before...

I can't speak for your personal dealings with either of them, but only for my own.
Both of them have shown an interest in Northern Soul (possibly the most obscure genre on these boards), so my experience of these two members is coloured by that somewhat.

Even so, I've seen no evidence to suggest either of them are closed minded, musically or otherwise.
I can think of many other members, more deserving of that title...myself included...

adidasss 06-11-2006 05:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by right-track
I can't speak for your personal dealings with either of them, but only for my own.
Both of them have shown an interest in Northern Soul (possibly the most obscure genre on these boards), so my experience of these two members is coloured by that somewhat.

Even so, I've seen no evidence to suggest either of them are closed minded, musically or otherwise.
I can think of many other members, more deserving of that title...myself included...

nope, the fact that you listen to most of my suggestions makes you very open minded...( and northern soul ain't exactly new music )

right-track 06-11-2006 05:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
( and northern soul ain't exactly new music )

It is if you've never heard it before, which most people haven't.
It was overlooked back then and it's overlooked now.

jr. 06-11-2006 05:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
i haven't noticed a great interest in new music in either of them...especially jr.

it's not an insult nor should i be considered an asshole by either of those two for nominating them, that's just how i see things...maybe jr. is more than willing to experiment in real life...but i haven't noticed him posting about a single band that's not from the 70's or before...


Well, I certainly don't take any offense. I listen to a lot of newer music. The last three cds I bought were Yellowcard, Hawthorne Heights and Panic at the Disco. Granted, they were for my daughter, for getting straight A's and perfect attendance throughout 6th grade. I will be hearing all these bands, though, on a regular basis. I enjoy Greenday, Bowling for Soup, Fallout Boys, Good Charlotte, some Arctic Monkeys, and some others whose names escape me right now. I couldn't tell you the names of all the songs, but I can pretty much distinguish one band from another.

Now some people may dump on those bands, but they're what my daughter listens to, so it's what I'm exposed to. She's 11, and fortunately for her, she hasn't become jaded and dislikes bands because they don't fit into a certain 'genre' or they're 'trying to be this or that'. She just enjoys the music for what it is, with no preconcieved notions about what it's 'supposed to be'. Just like her dad.

And as far as posting only about stuff from the 70's, I am of the notion that a person should only make objective posts, on subjects they are knowledgable about. I grew up in that time, so I know a lot about those bands and that era. It's not the only music I listen to, nor is it the only music I know about. It is, however, the one genre I feel I know well enough to post something that someone else might get something from. This is a music site, why not go with your strong suite. I'd rather do that than go from thread to thread, making posts about bands I'm not familiar with and make myself look foolish, while detracting from an otherwise good music duscussion in the process.

right-track 06-11-2006 05:55 PM

Marijan...I think you owe this man ^ an apology. :laughing:

tdoc210 06-11-2006 05:58 PM

^mmmm exactley why i voted you for smartest poster

adidasss 06-11-2006 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Well, I certainly don't take any offense. I listen to a lot of newer music. The last three cds I bought were Yellowcard, Hawthorne Heights and Panic at the Disco. Granted, they were for my daughter, for getting straight A's and perfect attendance throughout 6th grade. I will be hearing all these bands, though, on a regular basis. I enjoy Greenday, Bowling for Soup, Fallout Boys, Good Charlotte, some Arctic Monkeys, and some others whose names escape me right now. I couldn't tell you the names of all the songs, but I can pretty much distinguish one band from another.

Now some people may dump on those bands, but they're what my daughter listens to, so it's what I'm exposed to. She's 11, and fortunately for her, she hasn't become jaded and dislikes bands because they don't fit into a certain 'genre' or they're 'trying to be this or that'. She just enjoys the music for what it is, with no preconcieved notions about what it's 'supposed to be'. Just like her dad.

And as far as posting only about stuff from the 70's, I am of the notion that a person should only make objective posts, on subjects they are knowledgable about. I grew up in that time, so I know a lot about those bands and that era. It's not the only music I listen to, nor is it the only music I know about. It is, however, the one genre I feel I know well enough to post something that someone else might get something from. This is a music site, why not go with your strong suite. I'd rather do that than go from thread to thread, making posts about bands I'm not familiar with and make myself look foolish, while detracting from an otherwise good music duscussion in the process.

first of all there is no such thing as being objective with regards to music, you can only voice your opinion, which is subjective by default.
second, i would be much happier if you went into those threads about newer bands, read what others have said about the bands music and possibly download something or go to the myspace page, then come back and clog up the conversation by saying "i hate it" .at least that way i would know that you're open to new music. but you said it yourself, the new music you listen to is predominantly music your daughter listens to ( so you're essentially forced to listen to it ). why not use this forum to DISCOVER new music and maybe even make your daughter happy by suggesting a few bands? you may be 40-ish, but there's no reason for you to be oblivious to what's going on in music right now...

jr. 06-11-2006 06:08 PM

Who said I didn't go into the threads? I read them. I just don't have anything of value to add, so I keep my mouth shut. I'm not educated enough to make an informed opinion, but I am far from oblivious. Besides, what is there to add to "They suck", "No, YOU suck for tinking they suck"?

And I have downloaded lots of things I've seen suggested here. Emo, Northern Soul, Primal Scream, etc.

adidasss 06-11-2006 06:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Who said I didn't go into the threads? I read them. I just don't have anything of value to add, so I keep my mouth shut. I'm not educated enough to make an informed opinion, but I am far from oblivious. Besides, what is there to add to "They suck", "No, YOU suck for tinking they suck"?

And I have downloaded lots of things I've seen suggested here. Emo, Northern Soul, Primal Scream, etc.

we're not talking about genre discussions, but rather discussions about perticular bands. any input is valuable in such threads, even if it's a one sentence response. by not responding you have not given me any reason to believe you've actually bothered to check out what we have been suggestin....hence the nomination....
northern soul is geezer music so you don't get any points for downloading that...what about downloading some of the stuff that people have been uploading in the sharing thread? beirut and the hidden cameras would be my suggestions....maybe the shins link is still working...

right-track 06-11-2006 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
we're not talking about genre discussions, but rather discussions about perticular bands. any input is valuable in such threads, even if it's a one sentence response. by not responding you have not given me any reason to believe you've actually bothered to check out what we have been suggestin....hence the nomination....
northern soul is geezer music so you don't get any points for downloading that...

I do believe you are ageist!!! ;)

Geezer music? Surely music is music?
Or are you too concerned about your image Marijan?

How open minded of you. :D

jr. 06-11-2006 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
northern soul is geezer music so you don't get any points for downloading that......


Closed minded, indeed.


Pardon me. I didn't realize I had had to make my presence known in each thread I visit. LOL.

Close lipped is closer to accurate than close minded.

Anyway, I choose not to jump into the middle of discussions about bands I don't know a whole lot about. If that makes me close minded, you're certainly entitled to your opinion.

As far as being forced to listen to my daughter's music, I run the show around here, and if I didn't want to hear it, I wouldn't hear it. My daughter is free to listen to whatever she chooses. Same as my Mom let me explore, she's free to do the same.

right-track 06-11-2006 06:27 PM

Well! *looks at watch* Urban will be on soon no doubt.
Love to stick around to witness another mauling Marijan...but work in the morning...gotta go. :)

jr. 06-11-2006 07:12 PM

I just went and took a look at my cds, and I own music spanning 60 years, all the way up to today. I own bluegrass, rock, country, folk, new wave, big band, techno pop, classic rock, disco, prog, metal, blues and everything in between. Some I own a lot of, some I own a little. The point is, I listen to a wide variety of music.

Does the fact that I am not in close contact with today's music make me close minded? Or is it the fact that there are bands out there that I don't care for? I don't like rap. and I don't own any. But that isn't because I have never given it a chance. I worked with a guy for seven years, who listened to rap all the time. I liked Biggie, but the rest, I didn't care for. Because it wasn't appealing to my musical ear, does that make me close minded? Your 'old geezer music' comment was far more close minded than anything I have ever said about any music on these boards.

Let me ask you this adidasss....what time span does your music collection cover? How many genres? Is it only close minded if you're not into today's music? Does it only work one way? Does it work for people who don't listen to geezer music? Is that close minded, not listening to music because it's 'old'?

Because if not, then there is a double standard as to what 'close minded' means.

*EDIT* I also forget to mention, besides the cds I bought for my daughter, I have bought for myself in the last few months, Bruce Springsteen's new cd, which consist of folk, country, a touch of bluegrass and even some ragtime. I've also bought the new Dixie Chicks cd (bland compared to their other three), and James Blunt, not to mention Dean Martin's greatest hits.

Also, I own 4 cds by R. Carlos Nakai. A Native American flutist. It's very enriching, spiritually. I own a lot of music like that. Exploratory stuff. Can you make the same claim?

I'm not hear to argue, or cause trouble. It simply disturbed me to be considered close minded when I know I am probably the owner of a wider variety of music than most people here.

Urban Hat€monger ? 06-11-2006 08:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
i haven't noticed a great interest in new music in either of them...

Really?

Well I seem to remember you telling me to name some stuff I liked post 2000. I named something like 27 albums *just* from the year 2000 and offered to carry on for the following years.

You never anwered.

And just because I don`t like *some* bands doesn`t make me closed minded. Wouldn`t close minded be not listening to them at all?

bungalow 06-11-2006 09:44 PM

:( I'm open minded.

hiu 06-11-2006 10:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
i haven't noticed a great interest in new music in either of them...especially jr.

it's not an insult nor should i be considered an asshole by either of those two for nominating them, that's just how i see things...maybe jr. is more than willing to experiment in real life...but i haven't noticed him posting about a single band that's not from the 70's or before...

If anything you are the one with a strong close mindedness towards music, not Jr or Urban. I mean really going around fighting about people not listening to newer bands, saying your music is superior to everyone elses et cetera is not open mindedness, it's pretentious dribble.

MURDER JUNKIE 06-11-2006 10:58 PM

I'm not open minded :p:

TheBig3 06-12-2006 12:54 AM

/\ but you're open-minded about being so

adidasss 06-12-2006 03:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by right-track
I do believe you are ageist!!! ;)

Geezer music? Surely music is music?
Or are you too concerned about your image Marijan?

How open minded of you. :D

i only meant to imply that geezers are more susceptible to this kind of music...:D
Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Closed minded, indeed.


Pardon me. I didn't realize I had had to make my presence known in each thread I visit. LOL.

Close lipped is closer to accurate than close minded.

Anyway, I choose not to jump into the middle of discussions about bands I don't know a whole lot about. If that makes me close minded, you're certainly entitled to your opinion.

As far as being forced to listen to my daughter's music, I run the show around here, and if I didn't want to hear it, I wouldn't hear it. My daughter is free to listen to whatever she chooses. Same as my Mom let me explore, she's free to do the same.

suit yourself, i didn't mean to say that you absolutely HAD to make your presence known in every thread you vist, but certainly in every thread about a band you actually bothered to check out. but i would say those are few and far between....until you prove me otherwise....( and no, you don't have to prove anything to me, but i also reserve the right to call you closed minded till further notice :-/ )
Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Does the fact that I am not in close contact with today's music make me close minded?

yes, yes it does...you know why? because you're on a music forum that deals in great extent with new music and yet you stick to music you already know...you're either closed minded, lazy or you don't have the time to explore ( and you can't convice me of the last option because if you have the time to write these extensive posts, you certainly have the time to download an album or two )
Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Your 'old geezer music' comment was far more close minded than anything I have ever said about any music on these boards.

don't get your knickers in a twist, David here has made me check it out and i was happy to oblige him, it just so happens that northern soul didn't do anything for me, my geezer music comment was only a joke, anyone is free to explore it...
Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
Let me ask you this adidasss....what time span does your music collection cover? How many genres? Is it only close minded if you're not into today's music? Does it only work one way? Does it work for people who don't listen to geezer music? Is that close minded, not listening to music because it's 'old'?

Because if not, then there is a double standard as to what 'close minded' means.

*EDIT* I also forget to mention, besides the cds I bought for my daughter, I have bought for myself in the last few months, Bruce Springsteen's new cd, which consist of folk, country, a touch of bluegrass and even some ragtime. I've also bought the new Dixie Chicks cd (bland compared to their other three), and James Blunt, not to mention Dean Martin's greatest hits.

Also, I own 4 cds by R. Carlos Nakai. A Native American flutist. It's very enriching, spiritually. I own a lot of music like that. Exploratory stuff. Can you make the same claim?

I'm not hear to argue, or cause trouble. It simply disturbed me to be considered close minded when I know I am probably the owner of a wider variety of music than most people here.

lemme try to answer some of your questions:
my music collection spands some 50 years, i got a bit of elvis and the rolling stones, aretha franklin, nina simone, the supremes and so on....genres? pretty much everything except for norwegian black metal :D
no, it doesn't work only one way, anyone who isn't prepared to at least give a certain type of music a go is closed minded...and if i had more time and money my music collection would be double the size it is now...but alas...
Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger
Really?

Well I seem to remember you telling me to name some stuff I liked post 2000. I named something like 27 albums *just* from the year 2000 and offered to carry on for the following years.

You never anwered.

And just because I don`t like *some* bands doesn`t make me closed minded. Wouldn`t close minded be not listening to them at all?

true, that's why i voted for jr., not you...

Cheese 06-12-2006 03:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss

suit yourself, i didn't mean to say that you absolutely HAD to make your presence known in every thread you vist, but certainly in every thread about a band you actually bothered to check out. but i would say those are few and far between....until you prove me otherwise....( and no, you don't have to prove anything to me, but i also reserve the right to call you closed minded till further notice :-/ )

Well if that's the case, label me with the same tag.:rolleyes:

adidasss 06-12-2006 03:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cheeseman
Well if that's the case, label me with the same tag.:rolleyes:

you're absolutely right, i can't believe i forgot about you...

jr. 06-12-2006 03:57 AM

adidasss, you are certainly entitled to your opinion of me. It doesn't get my 'knickers in a twist' at all. It would take a lot more than something as trivial as someone else's perception of me to get my fur up.

And, I've no problem with you whatsoever. Your one vote for jr. as 'Most Close Minded' poster certainly isn't going to shift my calm.

But wait...you nominated two people....but can only vote for one. What now?

I can see by a lot of the comments in this thread that there are a lot of people who think you are close minded. How does that make you feel?

Cheese 06-12-2006 04:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
you're absolutely right, i can't believe i forgot about you...

Your Momma:finger:

I'm always right...............................Except for the times I haven't been.

adidasss 06-12-2006 04:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
adidasss, you are certainly entitled to your opinion of me. It doesn't get my 'knickers in a twist' at all. It would take a lot more than something as trivial as someone else's perception of me to get my fur up.

And, I've no problem with you whatsoever. Your one vote for jr. as 'Most Close Minded' poster certainly isn't going to shift my calm.

But wait...you nominated two people....but can only vote for one. What now?

I can see by a lot of the comments in this thread that there are a lot of people who think you are close minded. How does that make you feel?

did they? well anyone who i talk to ( and yes, David knows better than to call me closed minded ) through msn knows i'm up for anything really...even emo...:D ( excuse me for not giving a rats ass for what hiu thinks )
edit: and i do believe i've managed to get your fur up, judging by your responses...;)

Cheese 06-12-2006 04:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss
excuse me for not giving a rats ass for what hiu thinks

No need for excuses. I don't think many care for what he thinks.

jr. 06-12-2006 04:11 AM

No, not at all. My responses were calm, level headed and well thought out. Same as any post I make about music. I goof around in here, same as anyone, but no one will ever see anger from me. It's not how I live.

Well, I am off to work, good citizens of MB.

adidasss 06-12-2006 04:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
No, not at all. My responses were calm, level headed and well thought out. Same as any post I make about music. I goof around in here, same as anyone, but no one will ever see anger from me. It's not how I live.

Well, I am off to work, good citizens of MB.

well no, not anger...but something....slight agitation possibly? you're only human jr....don't worry about it...( plus,i have that effect on people ;))

Cheese 06-12-2006 04:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jr.
No, not at all. My responses were calm, level headed and well thought out. Same as any post I make about music. I goof around in here, same as anyone, but no one will ever see anger from me. It's not how I live.

Well, I am off to work, good citizens of MB.

Good for you. I wish I could live like that, but alas I've always had a c*ntish streak.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:46 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.