Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Pan's Labyrinth (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/22931-pans-labyrinth.html)

rosiegurl 05-21-2007 08:08 PM

Pan's Labyrinth
 
I personally think this movie was amazing...anyone else have an opinion on it?
just wondering!

<brit:wavey:

Sparky 05-21-2007 08:11 PM

well, i have mixed feelings.

I liked it, but i thought the violence was unnecessary, as was the language. They took what could have been a great kids movie, threw in some torture scenes and bam, slapped an r-rating on it.

not enough focus on the magic, i honestly didnt care too much for gneral's story line. I wanted to see some magic shiz! >:[

Frances 05-21-2007 09:05 PM

I wanna see it!

rosiegurl 05-21-2007 09:19 PM

But it wasnt meant for kids! It was an Aduts Fairy Tail. If it was jsut another G Sleeping beauty fairy tail thanm it would have been boaring! the violene made it interesting!

adidasss 05-22-2007 03:22 AM

One of the best films I've seen recently.

DearJenny 05-22-2007 07:32 AM

I saw it in theaters a while back right after the Oscar hype. Easily a new favorite. I argued with my fiance about the magic being real or not. I still think it was all her imagination. Nothing proves it to be actually there.

Kevorkian Logic 05-22-2007 07:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matious (Post 368280)
well, i have mixed feelings.

I liked it, but i thought the violence was unnecessary, as was the language. They took what could have been a great kids movie, threw in some torture scenes and bam, slapped an r-rating on it.

not enough focus on the magic, i honestly didnt care too much for gneral's story line. I wanted to see some magic shiz! >:[

You sound like my brother.

If you want magic and a weak plot watch Harry Potter.

adidasss 05-22-2007 09:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CityLightsLikeRain (Post 368428)
I saw it in theaters a while back right after the Oscar hype. Easily a new favorite. I argued with my fiance about the magic being real or not. I still think it was all her imagination. Nothing proves it to be actually there.

I argued the same thing with my sister. I was inclined to think that it was all her imagination, pure escapism, she was more romantic about it and was convinced it was all real. It could basically go either way, although the last scene sort of goes in her (your fiancee's) favor.

DearJenny 05-22-2007 02:38 PM

Dude....adidass....I'm a chick. How did you miss that?

adidasss 05-22-2007 02:45 PM

Oh...well, you could've been a lezzy?;) Sorry...:(

right-track 05-22-2007 02:53 PM

hahaha ^ what a n00b. :laughing:

jackhammer 05-22-2007 02:57 PM

The film works on two levels-

The fantastical world a child retreats into from life.
The franco regime in spain circa 1940.

The whole point of the film was too juxtapose these two worlds. The violence is neccessary in order for the child's journey to have real purpose (i.e her mothers health)

An amazing film and was so pleased to see it in the cinema

adidasss 05-22-2007 03:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 368492)
The film works on two levels-

The fantastical world a child retreats into from life.
The franco regime in spain circa 1940.

The whole point of the film was too juxtapose these two worlds. T

Well put, although I wouldn't say the girl's journey had a specific purpose apart from the need to feel special and escape the brutal reality.

PopIsDead 05-22-2007 05:12 PM

I really liked that movie. I saw that movie in the theatres on opening night in my city. That weekend I also saw Children Of Men, which I liked a lot as well.

A few weeks later one of my friends burned me a copy of a screening copy of Pan's Labyrinth which he stole, so that was cool.

Sparky 05-22-2007 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevorkian Logic (Post 368429)
You sound like my brother.

If you want magic and a weak plot watch Harry Potter.

....

weak plot?

what was the plot?

chick goes to mansion, and uh, looks down in a cave and finds mr.tree guy?

goes collects keys to boxes filled with knives that are useless?

im saying, do you really think you opinion would have changed if that torture scene wasn't in there?

they could have made a great childrens movie for kids, not for adults.
They barely covered anything mystical at all, the movie took it self so seriously with all this civil war bull****. If i want to see a war movie, ill see a ****ing war movie.

it seems as if they're where two different screenwriters with two different goals for the movie.

acting was superb though:thumb:

edit: did you just make fun of harry potter >.<!

jackhammer 05-23-2007 02:50 PM

That is a terrible review Matious-civil war bull****? Del toro the director grew up in Spain living in the aftermath of the franco regime, and maybe this is his way of dealing with difficulties in his childhood or Spanish culture in general.

This was never intended as a childrens movie, it's an Imaginary world a child might inhabit growing up in these circumstances.

The violence in the film was what was going on in this time and to just gloss over it would be considered dishonest by DEL TORO.

By all means you don't have to like the film, but your review lacked intelligence.

Sparky 05-23-2007 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 368944)
That is a terrible review Matious-civil war bull****? Del toro the director grew up in Spain living in the aftermath of the franco regime, and maybe this is his way of dealing with difficulties in his childhood or Spanish culture in general.

This was never intended as a childrens movie, it's an Imaginary world a child might inhabit growing up in these circumstances.

The violence in the film was what was going on in this time and to just gloss over it would be considered dishonest by DEL TORO.

By all means you don't have to like the film, but your review lacked intelligence.

correct, i wasn't reffering to the civil war as being anything bad, i simply thought the film got to preachy with messages instead of focusing on all the fun parts.

I came into the film expecting a adventourous kids fairy tale, and you certainly have to admit thats what it seems like judgin by the trailers and art for the movie. So i was dissapointed at what little mystical events happened.

But the more i think about it, i do have to give it credit for mixing two completely different worlds so well. and intertwining them like was done.

lol, didnt del toro also direct "Hellboy" before this?

hellboy>pans labrynth easily;)

jackhammer 05-23-2007 04:40 PM

Thankyou for the reply MATIOUS-hope I did'nt offend you!

I admit that the Juxtaposition could freak you out a bit and yes Del Toro did direct HELLBOY-but has also done other Spanish films. He balances personal projects with Hollywood type crowd pleasers.

Give PANS another viewing and watch it from a completely different perspective-it's an amazing film.

Kevorkian Logic 05-23-2007 06:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matious (Post 368539)
....

weak plot?

what was the plot?

chick goes to mansion, and uh, looks down in a cave and finds mr.tree guy?

goes collects keys to boxes filled with knives that are useless?

im saying, do you really think you opinion would have changed if that torture scene wasn't in there?

they could have made a great childrens movie for kids, not for adults.
They barely covered anything mystical at all, the movie took it self so seriously with all this civil war bull****. If i want to see a war movie, ill see a ****ing war movie.

it seems as if they're where two different screenwriters with two different goals for the movie.

acting was superb though:thumb:

edit: did you just make fun of harry potter >.<!

Yes I made fun of Harry Potter, even thought I dedicated weeks to those books when I was little, when I grew a half a brain I realized its worthless and her writing style is bland and ****ty, therefore I have little interest and respect for it now.

I could have honestly never read a more inane review. You obviously were just too young to understand or appreciate the movie. Somethings just aren't meant for the younger minded (I apologize for sounding condescending), but its just like music. It's easier to learn to listen to Elliot Smith sing soothingly and appreciate the gentle melodies, than is to listen to Captain Beefheart and appreciate it for obvious reasons.

Not everything should be a watered down fairy tale where Cinderella finds her Prince Charming, it would be a pretty boring movie.

How about for a movie there's a kid with a scar and a magic wand who falls in love with another kid with a magic wand? That's happy ending.

Leave Pan's Labyrinth alone, it was never meant to be a children's tale, and if you think it was mean to you TOTALLY missed the point of the movie. It's meant to work and multiple levels that combine to form something beautiful and unique that is constantly changing, like Captain Beefheart.

If you take out all the levels you would be left with an extremely shallow movie that would have just been labeled another Narnia.

And, in case you didn't know Pan's Labyrinth was written by Del Toro ALONE, and he was influenced by many ADULT books, not children's books.
Watch the movie in 5 years or after you've done drugs, I promise you will be ashamed of yourself for thinking it should be a children's movie. I was felt so nausated and tired watching that movie because I was coming out of my drunken haze, and I still found it remarkable in so many levels.

And I agree about the acting.

Sparky 05-23-2007 07:03 PM

i already sayd i was sorry D=

The Dave 05-23-2007 07:07 PM

Eh, I'm not going to bother debating over a movie, seems even too trivial for my time.

I liked the movie, the plot was good, but I didn't get the ending. Did she actually go to that "heaven" or was it just a dream?

Kevorkian Logic 05-23-2007 07:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matious (Post 369046)
i already sayd i was sorry D=

didn't see.
sorry.
I felt immediate need to reply without reading anything else, i'm rash like that.

Sparky 05-23-2007 07:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Dave (Post 369048)
Eh, I'm not going to bother debating over a movie, seems even too trivial for my time.

I liked the movie, the plot was good, but I didn't get the ending. Did she actually go to that "heaven" or was it just a dream?

it wasnt heaven:crazy:
she died, and then went back to where she invisioned along side her once-happy family:thumb:

what i didnt get was the whole "dont trust whatever mr.tree guy was called" i thought they're would be some plot twist turning out he was bad..

The Dave 05-23-2007 07:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matious (Post 369057)
it wasnt heaven:crazy:
she died, and then went back to where she invisioned along side who once-happy family:thumb:

what i didnt get was the whole "dont trust whatever mr.tree guy was called" i thought they're would be some plot twist turning out he was bad..

I puit heaven is quotation marks meaning something that would be like a heaven, jeez, get with the metaphors :).

K, but that makes sense. I imagine the whole don't trust the faun goes with her not trsuting him to give him her baby brother, which lead to her happy ending, so yeah.

jackhammer 05-23-2007 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Dave (Post 369048)
Eh, I'm not going to bother debating over a movie, seems even too trivial for my time.

I liked the movie, the plot was good, but I didn't get the ending. Did she actually go to that "heaven" or was it just a dream?


Debating about Movies? trivial? WTF?

It's an art form that's as legitamate as music-an inane retort if I have ever heard one.

The Dave 05-23-2007 08:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jackhammer (Post 369086)
Debating about Movies? trivial? WTF?

It's an art form that's as legitamate as music-an inane retort if I have ever heard one.

I just don't see the point behind debating over whether or not a movie was good, seems to trifling plus it's all opinion. Same thing goes for music. If anyone bothers to write over a paragraph as to why a band or movie is good, then I won't read it, because it's ultimately up to taste.

adidasss 05-24-2007 02:56 AM

You don't see a point in discussion, the exchange of ideas and thoughts is trifling?:usehead: How on earth did you manage to gather over a thousand posts on a music board? WTF are you doing on on-line forums in general?

The Dave 05-26-2007 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 369145)
You don't see a point in discussion, the exchange of ideas and thoughts is trifling?:usehead: How on earth did you manage to gather over a thousand posts on a music board? WTF are you doing on on-line forums in general?

There's a difference between discussing and debating and I don't mind to debate, but to debate as to whether or not a movie is good just seems to trifling for me to waste my time on. It's a movie, you watch, you enjoy, you tell a joke about it at a company pic-nic, and you then move on.

adidasss 05-26-2007 02:38 PM

So why are you in this thread?

The Dave 05-27-2007 05:56 PM

To state that I enjoyed the movie, which I did.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:44 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.