Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   The Lounge (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/)
-   -   Other Conservatives? (https://www.musicbanter.com/lounge/25983-other-conservatives.html)

Inuzuka Skysword 11-13-2007 08:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardboard adolescent (Post 414173)
You seem to be implying that we have some sort of "social equality" in America which is....


























................









.........



















wait for it....























...........




















bullshit!

We don't have to have social equality to the fullest extent. All you need is a good work ethic and as bit of talent at what you do and you can hit the big time. I can be a professional basketball player if I practice for a couple of hours everyday and focus on it. That alone pays a lot of money.

Barnard17 11-13-2007 08:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414171)
Socialism does not give equality. It only stresses for it.

You're just full of those helpful little tidbits aren't you.

Socialism gives equality. Until equality is achieved, neither is socialism. It's not that hard to understand.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414171)
And why is he working in this job? Well because he thought that school was not worth it so he decided to not apply himself. If he did apply himself and not worry about love so much, maybe he would have succeeded. It is partially his fault he ended up that way.

I thought I'd established that without him working in his job you'd be running to the toilet to throw up for a week after every time you ate at a restaurant. Coming from a well-to-do middle-class background may have warped your view on jobs that are good or not, but the bottom end ones are usually the most necessary ones when you get down to it. Being a builder may not be as glamorous and well paid as being a lawyer but who does a greater service to society?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414171)
And why is forced charity right? That is pretty much what it is.

And why is greed, selfishness and hoarding right?

I really hope you're not Christian. That would be the cherry of irony.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414177)
We don't have to have social equality to the fullest extent. All you need is a good work ethic and as bit of talent at what you do and you can hit the big time. I can be a professional basketball player if I practice for a couple of hours everyday and focus on it. That alone pays a lot of money.

Somebody should give you a shovel so you can carry on digging your grave of naivety.

TheBig3 11-13-2007 11:41 PM

First let me say that I've read up until, I don't know page 4 or 5 and I've come to the position that you should all get a library card.

Quote:

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks (Post 414104)
You guys don't understand the basic tenants of capitalism. Competition for buisness = better product, lower prices.
Complete privatization of health care. If you need it, you pay for it (or you pay for insurance which helps). And free clinics can operate too, by philanthropy.

If you privatize, competetion will spring up. Better doctors who compete for patients by having competetive pricing. Everyone wins.

We don't understand the "basic tenants of capitalism?" I'd be more inclined to believe you but I said that exact phrase in this thread a couple pages earlier. I don't think you understand the basic principles of capitalism. There are reasons governments exist and regardless of what your L. Ron Hubbard overlords have told you, its not a power grab.

Standardized pricing takes place everywhere. Try and buy an ipod. Its going to be the same price everywhere. And there will not be some renegade company selling it for less because Apple won't sell you it. Even if they did, you'd be crushed by the bigger stores with more locations and the ability to process more consumers. And in your free market unregulated world, there'd be no federal government or anti-monopoly laws in place to stop them.

Businesses do not run, nor care about societies and governments, which operate in many cases as a giant consumer advocate anyway, have to keep the will of the public in mind. Capitalism is a dynamic system that corresponds well to democracy, its voting with your wallet. But if you don't like the laws you can always change the law makers.

As for your comment on philanthropy, what are you ****ing 12? Or is your head just up your ass. That was the dumbest ****ing thing I've ever read. Most capitalists want unregulated everything so your philanthropic doctors wouldn't need licenses and if you're going to allow doctors to practice in your country without any sort of oversight, then I pray you get sick first and we'll see how strong your resolve is then you poverty stricken naive invalid.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlJr (Post 414130)
Universal Healthcare is unconstitutional. The sole authority on whether or not a system can be implemented in the United States is the constitution, and universal Healthcare places a incredible amount of power in the hands of the Government. Healthcare is a service industry. Competetion increases the quality of the service, and, if not dominated by a few regional powerhouses, keeps costs managable. Universal healthcare is a huge step towards socialism, an economic and political system that the Founding Fathers did not intend and certainly would not approve of.

The founding fathers would also not approve of large corporations telling you what you can and cannot get treated for. But I suppose HMO's doing exactly what government would in a socialist nation is completely different right? Does anyone around here think?

Seriously, whats more detrimental to a society? A government dictating or a business dictating. And before you bring up idiot underdog theories again, why hasn't any HMO in existence currently offered up affordable coverage for any type of problem you'd come across?

I suppose giving them more power would fix that though, right?

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardboard adolescent (Post 414169)
The founding fathers were racist pricks and the Constitution is as outdated as the Bible.

I hate Ron Paul.

And you're not a bright bulb either. The constitution is outdated?? Go **** yourself. The constitution is amendable, and if changes need be made, they can. Who cares what the founding fathers practiced? Shouldn't you be holding a sign that says "rethink thanksgiving?"

Newsflash: Everyone that has ever lived was a ****ty person. This is why government works. We agree on things so that we move towards a collective balance even if we're racist ourselves. Its ugly, but if there were real problems the country would have folded by now. We're making progress and just because we were not born a utopia doesn't mean we're inherently bad.

And what exactly is wrong with Ron Paul, and where did that come from? Because he cites the constitution? Shouldn't he? Its the ****ing law.

TheBig3 11-13-2007 11:47 PM

Sorry I missed one.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal (Post 414137)
You do realize your Government, along with any other constitutional Government, just changes the constitution to suit it's needs right? I can't really fathom why people spend so much time yammering on about why you should or shouldn't do something with the argument "It's (un)constitutional!" because when it boils down to it a constitution is worth less than the paper it's written on.

Well most times when things are "unconstitutional" its because they are the laws that no state would have changed.

I'm not sure what you'd know of our system here but you need (and its been awhile since i've checked) something to the effect of 3/4'sof the union agreeing upon a change before it can be ratified. Its generally solid.

DearJenny 11-13-2007 11:53 PM

For my, my alignment depends on the topic. I'm very wishy-washy when it comes to politics.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-14-2007 01:35 AM

I wish I lived in this middle class utopia that some people here seem to want.
Just think a whole society of people in middle management jobs where nobody has any financial problems during their entire lives at all ,ever.

I fear there are a few people in for a nasty shock once they get into the real world.

Whatever next ? Poor people wanting to be able to go to a doctors? ... damn communists.

N*S*G 11-14-2007 03:43 AM

I got a (-10, -10) on a political analysis diagnostic.

That is a hard left, hard libertarian... the antipode of a hard right, hard statist. I am opposite of Stalin (pretty much a (10, 10)), and more left than Ghandi (he was close to a (-4, -4)).

So am I a conservative? No.

Quote:

I wish I lived in this middle class utopia that some people here seem to want.
Just think a whole society of people in middle management jobs where nobody has any financial problems during their entire lives at all ,ever.

I fear there are a few people in for a nasty shock once they get into the real world.

Whatever next ? Poor people wanting to be able to go to a doctors? ... damn communists.
http://www.layoutlounge.com/Images/B...-high-five.jpg

Joshee 11-14-2007 03:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal (Post 414179)
And why is greed, selfishness and hoarding right?

I really hope you're not Christian. That would be the cherry of irony.

Dude,
Thats gold.
Ha ha ha.

N*S*G 11-14-2007 03:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joshee (Post 414294)
Dude,
Thats gold.
Ha ha ha.

As forced as that joke was, I will have to disagree.

Liberals want provided economy, free social.
Conservatives want provided social, free economy.

It depends on how you look at it. Do you want either your wallet or your balls in a vice grip?

DontRunMeOver 11-14-2007 04:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger (Post 414274)
I wish I lived in this middle class utopia that some people here seem to want.
Just think a whole society of people in middle management jobs where nobody has any financial problems during their entire lives at all ,ever.

(I'm going to use the word 'medic' all the way through after it was pointed out in great length to me the other day that most people who went to medical school aren't actually 'doctors')

If that were the state of society then medics would just up their prices and half of the people still wouldn't be able to afford to go to the medics. Either that or everybody would have enough extra cash to pay but the waiting lists would be huge.

I think that most of the medic-related problems you see in the NHS result from not enough medical school places being created, so that there aren't enough medics in the first place. If everything went private there still wouldn't be enough qualified medics around to deal with everybody adequately and there certainly wouldn't be enough to create a competitive capitalist environment. In fact, the system would probably be a lot less competitive because the customer wouldn't have the alternative of free state-funded treatment to barter with.

We've seen with the railway system here that privatisation can be a complete balls up, resulting in something which amounts to legal monopolisation and as a result much worse services at a much higher cost. The idea of universal privatisation of medical treatment leading to improved services doesn't always work when:

1) Medics have, due to 'old school ties', access to a more organised network of other practising medics and are generally in a position to take part in a kind of informal price-fixing (quite simply, if no medics lower their prices then everybody can continue to charge high prices for the services).
2) In most places there are a lack of medics compared to the demand, so medics don't need to cut their prices to get customers.

And the problems are probably worse in small towns/villages where they might be only one or two medics available. In that situation privatisation could easily lead to medics charging through the roof, knowing that their customers have no other alternative.

In the US there might be a huge surplus of trained medics, but in the UK that is not the case and I think the big problem is not universal healthcare but the number of people who are being funded to do ****ty mickey-mouse degrees instead of pushing more people towards medical school. More medics = greater supply compared to demand and with or without universal privatisation that will bring the cost of the service down (within the NHS such an action should lead to individual medics being paid less thus you get more medics for your tax-pound).

adidasss 11-14-2007 04:17 AM

Teenagers discussing politics=comedy gold.:yeah:

...

OT: Brought up a conservative, went gay. =(

N*S*G 11-14-2007 04:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 414300)
Teenagers discussing politics

http://www.borderline-plattform.de/a...ages/angst.jpg

DontRunMeOver 11-14-2007 05:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 414300)
Teenagers discussing politics=comedy gold.:yeah:

...

OT: Brought up a conservative, went gay. =(

I've been loving Inuzuka Skysword's posts, where he'll say something contentious but pretty valid and then back it up with the worst possible examples. e.g.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword
All you need is a good work ethic and as bit of talent at what you do and you can hit the big time.

Simplistic, but still a valid opinion.

And followed by
Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword
I can be a professional basketball player if I practice for a couple of hours everyday and focus on it.

Which, unless you are talking about yourself specifically and you are already your town basketball hero this is not true at all. Love the logic though.

Or this chestnut of a counter argument
Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger
I'm sure everybody would like to go private but sadly in the real world not everybody can afford it. I'm sure some of the elderly people & relatives I know who have needed operations on the NHS would be happy to know you'd abolish the whole thing just because of a few junkies and because they don't happen to have a lot of money you'd rather they died , but then they'd probably point out to you that they'd paid for it their entire lives themselves.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword
Well I would hope they would want their offspring to live happy lives without a government controlled by a tyrant.

Tangential thinking is all well and good (and hilarious in this case) but it isn't meant to be applied so much to political debate. Unless you're a crazy.

DontRunMeOver 11-14-2007 05:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by adidasss (Post 414300)
OT: Brought up a conservative, went gay. =(

That just means you went full time gay. Most conservatives here are part-time gay, meaning that they're only gay on saturday nights on poorly-lit grassland with young phillipino lads.

TheBig3 11-14-2007 09:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 414320)
Tangential thinking is all well and good (and hilarious in this case) but it isn't meant to be applied so much to political debate. Unless you're a crazy.

Actually, you'd be surprised how that argument stands up over here. Recently, when the democrats said they needed to raise taxes because government spending was too high, the republicans said something like "well you should do more to curb government spending." This was roughly a year after the republicans had controlled all three branches for six years.

And the tyrant attitude is almost omnipresent on the right. They said because Clinton was trying to socialize medicine she was trying to tell you what doctors to go to, and what you can do with your health. He said "shes trying to rule your life." Its sad to watch at the power junkies claw for their fix.

If the republicans don't openly support Paul, their screwed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver (Post 414321)
That just means you went full time gay. Most conservatives here are part-time gay, meaning that they're only gay on saturday nights on poorly-lit grassland with young phillipino lads.

can you blame them? what better time is there to be *** than on saturday night with a young Filipino?

riseagainstrocks 11-14-2007 12:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
We don't understand the "basic tenants of capitalism?" I'd be more inclined to believe you but I said that exact phrase in this thread a couple pages earlier. I don't think you understand the basic principles of capitalism. There are reasons governments exist and regardless of what your L. Ron Hubbard overlords have told you, its not a power grab.

Ok, I'm not sure where you're coming from at all with this. How would you be more inclined to believe me if you hadn't said the same thing early. I was merely skimming this thread until I saw the Universal Health Care comment and then started to read intently. I probably shouldn't gone back through the thread but I didn't.

And who is saying governments are a power grab? I understand there are valid reasons for them, I just don't believe that the regulation of services (not goods) should be one of them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
Standardized pricing takes place everywhere. Try and buy an ipod. Its going to be the same price everywhere. And there will not be some renegade company selling it for less because Apple won't sell you it. Even if they did, you'd be crushed by the bigger stores with more locations and the ability to process more consumers. And in your free market unregulated world, there'd be no federal government or anti-monopoly laws in place to stop them.

Of course there won't be a renegade company. Apple OWNS iPod, so no one but them can sell it as their own product. Naturally, Apple sets the prices. However with competing products (such as the major video game consoles) prices and service have both improved immensely due to competition. Sony believe the PS3 was worth $600 and the market did not agree, hence the PS3's abysmal first year. Microsoft decided to capture more of the market they would need to deal with hardware problems and so to make the product more desirable, they added the retroactive warrantly on all 360's.

These are examples of companies adjusting to the needs and wants of the market. The market decideds how much something is worth, NOT the company. Going back to UHC, different hospitals all want to make money by selling a similar service (medicine, operations, check-ups, etc.). The moment one hospital realizes it can draw patients by lowering their prices for these things, the consumer begins to win. The market doesn't provide for people paying 10,000 for an operation. And buisnesses will adjust.

I'd also like to respond to your point on monopolies springing up. This is a place for the government to step in. I never said that they shouldn't. Similar to the dissolution of giants like Bell (the telephone company) and Standard Oil were great steps in insuring the continuation of the free market system. I'm all for anti-trust acts. I'm not for government regulation of an industry. Huge difference.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
Businesses do not run, nor care about societies and governments, which operate in many cases as a giant consumer advocate anyway, have to keep the will of the public in mind. Capitalism is a dynamic system that corresponds well to democracy, its voting with your wallet. But if you don't like the laws you can always change the law makers.

I really don't follow this paragraph.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
As for your comment on philanthropy, what are you ****ing 12? Or is your head just up your ass. That was the dumbest ****ing thing I've ever read. Most capitalists want unregulated everything so your philanthropic doctors wouldn't need licenses and if you're going to allow doctors to practice in your country without any sort of oversight, then I pray you get sick first and we'll see how strong your resolve is then you poverty stricken naive invalid.

How will they not need licenses? As far as I'm concerned, I'm not saying change much about the current system. If anything I'm simply saying we should have more control over what doctor's we see and that we become much more financially responsible over our own treatement.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger
I wish I lived in this middle class utopia that some people here seem to want.
Just think a whole society of people in middle management jobs where nobody has any financial problems during their entire lives at all ,ever.

I fear there are a few people in for a nasty shock once they get into the real world.

Whatever next ? Poor people wanting to be able to go to a doctors? ... damn communists.

You're right. I grew up in an upper middle class family. I attend a prestigious public university. I've never had a need in my life (although plenty of wants). But that does not mean I can't express my opinion on this topic.

If we go to a UHC system where does the money to pay for the poor going to the doctor come from? ME! As heartless as it sounds, I want my money to be spent on ME or on things that I want to spend it on. I went to school, I studied, I worked, I made money. I'll be damned if my compensation goes to anyone else (minus the obligitory taxes I pay for roads, schools, etc.)

Quote:

Originally Posted by DontRunMeOver
1) Medics have, due to 'old school ties', access to a more organised network of other practising medics and are generally in a position to take part in a kind of informal price-fixing (quite simply, if no medics lower their prices then everybody can continue to charge high prices for the services).
2) In most places there are a lack of medics compared to the demand, so medics don't need to cut their prices to get customers.

I'd like to zero in on this part of your post, because a lot of it is talking about location specific issues.
1. You're assuming that doctors have a devious plan to price gouge at the first oppurtunity. Lawyer's have a job with near the same prestige, and roughly in the same demand. Largely unregulated system, but it still works because entry level practicioners charge reasonable fee's so they can a) get cases as an unknown and b) make a name for themselves. Doctors would be much the same way. A sought after commodity.
2. No one lives in a vaccum. Travel is too easy these days to let that be an excuse.


again, this system actually taps into greed. Doctors who want money, will be willing to do a little bit more work. If not, they won't make money.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-14-2007 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks (Post 414349)
You're right. I grew up in an upper middle class family. I attend a prestigious public university. I've never had a need in my life (although plenty of wants). But that does not mean I can't express my opinion on this topic.

If we go to a UHC system where does the money to pay for the poor going to the doctor come from? ME! As heartless as it sounds, I want my money to be spent on ME or on things that I want to spend it on. I went to school, I studied, I worked, I made money. I'll be damned if my compensation goes to anyone else (minus the obligitory taxes I pay for roads, schools, etc.)

That wasn't a dig at your own background , just pointing out that if you were to go sick where everybody 'bettered themselves' who would clean your hospitals? who would cook your meals for you? Ambulance Staff , Hospital porters , forget it.
Nurses are some of the lowest paid public sector workers out there , hell some nurses who work in London can't afford to even live there . Would you like them to all up & leave to become accountants or lawyers too?
And their wages wouldn't get better under the private sector either , they'd just go & hire cheap labour from Asia / eastern Europe / Philippines because they have their shareholders to think of.
Of course it's perfectly OK for you to have your 'me me me' opinion. Let's hope you'll never be in the situation where you have to appreciate the long hours & low wages that these people have to deal with to make your life better.

riseagainstrocks 11-14-2007 01:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal
Meet Benjamin. Benjamin is a cleaner. Specifically he cleans restaurant kitchens. It's not a particularly enjoyable job, and it doesn't require many qualifications. As a result it's not very highly paid. Under a pure capitalism this will remain the same as, through lack of protection for the workers rights there's inadequate support should a body wish to unionise and, for example, exercise strike action. Because Benjamins job so lacks a necessity for qualification, and because there will always be people who need money, there will always be a Benjamin. At the same time, there will always be a need for a Benjamin, without him providing such a service you go to a restaurant, eat the food and pick up God only knows what bug and fall ill. Bless him, Benjamin fell in love and married. Now he also has a kid to support! As a result of common social divide, his wife is in a similarly low paid job. Maybe she's working two to help them scrape by, which tends to be what happens.

How is any of this mine, or societies fault? You're creating a sob story to garner sympathy for this man, when it seems to me, living in America the vast majority of this could be avoided. We offer FREE education until you're 19 (21 in some states). Do good in school, you can get into college (many colleges compare you to the rest of your school, meaning urban and inner city kids DO have a shot). Sure, you won't get into Dartmouth, but a good state school will accept you. Oh, and if you can't support a kid, don't ****ing have one.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal
Bejamin falls ill. He has cancer. Oh noes! Now we see three options:

1. He doesn't have health insurance. He goes to the hospital, pays a gazundle of money for the meeting with the doctor and all the tests that they do (and you know in the US under a mostly privatised system they do a lot of essentially unnecessary tests to "rule out alternatives" that cost a lot of money. Need an MRI? Have five!) has to stay off work and finds his pay lowered for sick leave and then can't pay for his treatment. He dies, sucks for Molly and Jimmy. Maybe they go on benefit, single mother family sort of thing. Jimmy probably gets bullied for getting free school meals, though maybe that's too close to socialism, but it's Ok because RiseAgainst didn't have to wait in line for his treatment, whatever that may be.

lol, since when have I said that I should go in front of him. Dude, I want to own my own record studio. I'm not gonna have tons of money either. I am however going to make sure to set aside cash so if the **** does hit the fan, I'll be ok. And why go to a doctor who will do uneeded test. If you have cancer, then do some research on it. Make the doctor explain himself.

Besides, you have to cynical of a view of the health profession. I doubt anyone is out to get you (or Benjamin)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal
2. He has health insurance, his already low wage is munched a sizable amount. He goes to hospital, goes through the same process and the health insurance pays for all that and his treatment. His premiums SKYROCKET, a lack of money causes his marriage to break up (because money issues are amongst the most commonly cited cause for divorce), little Jimmy has a troubled upbringing; grows up to and with bickering and arguing as the norm for a relationship (internal working model, developmental psychology) and probably divorces in his future relationship. He was probably a right little tyke! (read also: bully) because the trials of the break up meant that parenting went to hell in a handbasket. Benjamin continues to scrape a living, but with less of his wage to play with because of raised insurance premiums a bald head and clinical depression caused by chemo therapy and a divorce, but it's ok because RisaAgainst didn't have to wait in line for his treatment, whatever that may be. It'd probably be much similar if he didn't have health insurance and decided to pay for the treatment, he'd just have to mortgage the house in the process.

So now, it's my fault he has depression and got divorced. You're not even making a simple arguement anymore. You're reading into this so much it's hilarious. My response from the first point stands.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal
3. He doesn't have health insurance and won't go to see the doctor, you think a guy in a low wage job trying to support a wife and kid has that sort of money to spend?! You gotta be kidding! He dies, they don't know it was cancer until post mortem, Molly and Jimmy are boned. RiseAgainst didn't have to wait.

Sounds a lot like his problem and not mine.

Quote:

The assertion that a system such as the medical one will have prices internally regulated is naive. Even if things aren't to become goliathic monopolies, the tendency is for the CEOs of the companies to meet up and say "you know we can still keep our prices high and get a tidy keeping for ourselves", or the Doctors on the ground level will throw in tests to rule out alternatives (protect themselves from lawsuits and get a tidy sum in their pockets) which boosts the price. The patient either pays or dies. Which is why hospital fees and health insurance can be kept so high. You pay or you die.
Why is it naive? It works in most all other industries. You're buying into this vast conspiracy theory. Even if that was the case, doctors are engaged in private practice all the time. Setting your own prices + close contact with the community = high quality care by someone you know at an affordable rate. Granted, for major surgery, you'd have to go to a hospital, but agian, CEO's don't have some clandestine organization waiting to screw over the general populace.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal
Under the British Health System Benjamin would have paid health insurance from his wages as a part of the tax, which really is a pittance for what you get especially considering that drinkers and smokers "sin tax" heavily subsidises the system, and that the high wage earners pay more tax in the gradient system. When he fell ill he would've gone to the doctor without worry, been sent off for tests which he wouldn't have had to wait an incredible length for and get it all paid for by the Government. If waiting lists are massive, there's a chance that the Government will pay for him to go private anyway. And of course he has that option from the start if he has that sort of money to fritter away because private healthcare legally coexists (something which I disagree with, which is another matter).

Why should my money go to someone else? That's where we disagree fundamentaly and I don't think that will change.

What it comes down to is different morality. I'm selfish and look out for my own interest. I have enough of my own problems without worrying about others. I don't want to government telling me how to deal with my own ****, nor do I want to contribute to a slush fund where others can use it for their own mishaps.

riseagainstrocks 11-14-2007 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger (Post 414351)
That wasn't a dig at your own background , just pointing out that if you were to go sick where everybody 'bettered themselves' who would clean your hospitals? who would cook your meals for you? Ambulance Staff , Hospital porters , forget it.
Nurses are some of the lowest paid public sector workers out there , hell some nurses who work in London can't afford to even live there . Would you like them to all up & leave to become accountants or lawyers too?
And their wages wouldn't get better under the private sector either , they'd just go & hire cheap labour from Asia / eastern Europe / Philippines because they have their shareholders to think of.
Of course it's perfectly OK for you to have your 'me me me' opinion. Let's hope you'll never be in the situation where you have to appreciate the long hours & low wages that these people have to deal with to make your life better.

There will always be the poor. I know that. I also know that there is enough wealth in the world for everyone to be well off. Yes, it's true. According to economist Bjorn Lumborg, in 20 years the lower class in Asia will be as well off (on the whole, not all of them) as America's middle class. As a globe we are getting wealthier, thanks in large part to implentation of competition throughout the globe.

Merit systems > tradition. ANYONE can move up the ladder if they show drive and aptitude. Again, I think this is merely a fundamental point we disagree on. I see and respect your position, but to me the idea of UHC is repugnant as well as immoral.

cardboard adolescent 11-14-2007 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog (Post 414238)
And you're not a bright bulb either. The constitution is outdated?? Go **** yourself. The constitution is amendable, and if changes need be made, they can. Who cares what the founding fathers practiced? Shouldn't you be holding a sign that says "rethink thanksgiving?"

Newsflash: Everyone that has ever lived was a ****ty person. This is why government works. We agree on things so that we move towards a collective balance even if we're racist ourselves. Its ugly, but if there were real problems the country would have folded by now. We're making progress and just because we were not born a utopia doesn't mean we're inherently bad.

And what exactly is wrong with Ron Paul, and where did that come from? Because he cites the constitution? Shouldn't he? Its the ****ing law.

a) Thanksgiving is bull****.
b) The very fact that the constitution has 27 amendments implies to me that it's outdated... I mean if you look at the French they've had a ****load of Constitutions, their current one is only fifty years old and they've already amended it 18 times. Either the French have ADD or we're just really stubborn. Both are probably true.
c) The fact that we're all ****ty people is the reason why any sort of socio political economic system will never work perfectly. We'd probably still need one if we were all perfect (whatever the hell that means). That argument had nothing to do with my vague points, however.
d) I dislike Ron Paul because he is the "CHAMPION OF THE CONSTITUTION," which seems ridiculous because it implies you'll disagree with someone else's views or policies simply on the basis of what it says in the constitution. As you yourself pointed out, the whole point is that we can change it so that it fits with social currents, not stick to it regardless of what happens.
e) I am a bright bulb.

Thank you.

N*S*G 11-14-2007 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cardboard adolescent (Post 414365)
a) Thanksgiving is bull****.
b) The very fact that the constitution has 27 amendments implies to me that it's outdated... I mean if you look at the French they've had a ****load of Constitutions, their current one is only fifty years old and they've already amended it 18 times. Either the French have ADD or we're just really stubborn. Both are probably true.
c) The fact that we're all ****ty people is the reason why any sort of socio political economic system will never work perfectly. We'd probably still need one if we were all perfect (whatever the hell that means). That argument had nothing to do with my vague points, however.
d) I dislike Ron Paul because he is the "CHAMPION OF THE CONSTITUTION," which seems ridiculous because it implies you'll disagree with someone else's views or policies simply on the basis of what it says in the constitution. As you yourself pointed out, the whole point is that we can change it so that it fits with social currents, not stick to it regardless of what happens.
e) I am a bright bulb.

Thank you.

:clap: :clap:

... >_>

:rofl:

CarlJr 11-14-2007 04:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheBig3KilledMyRainDog
The founding fathers would also not approve of large corporations telling you what you can and cannot get treated for. But I suppose HMO's doing exactly what government would in a socialist nation is completely different right? Does anyone around here think?

Seriously, whats more detrimental to a society? A government dictating or a business dictating. And before you bring up idiot underdog theories again, why hasn't any HMO in existence currently offered up affordable coverage for any type of problem you'd come across?

I suppose giving them more power would fix that though, right?

I don't understand your " whats more detrimental to a society? A government dictating or a business dictating?" point. When it comes to the economy, it is far better that a business dictate. Liberals rely on the government to baby them from birth, that is not what the Government is for. If you need constant care from your government, then move to a socialist country. In a capitalistic society, the government should not interfere with the free market (except to regulate quality, and to avoid monopolies). Since Healthcare is a service industry, it only follows that capitalism should not allow for government regulation. Capitalism works. Prices benefit the consumer. The problem in the United States is that, instead of the government controlling business, you have lobbyists in Congress controlling the government. Keeping them seperate is the key, and that is the current problem with the healthcare system, not the fact that the government isn't running it.

And there I think is the big split between liberals and conservatives. Liberals would love to see the government running their healthcare system. Liberals (like neocons) WANT big government. This country was established to rid its people of tyranny. Allowing the government to control and manipulate the country ceaselessly will only serve to kill this country. Liberals and Neoconservatives could care less about the constitution. Big government, increased spending, global government. It's ridiculous.

N*S*G 11-14-2007 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlJr (Post 414411)
I don't understand your " whats more detrimental to a society? A government dictating or a business dictating?" point. When it comes to the economy, it is far better that a business dictate. Liberals rely on the government to baby them from birth, that is not what the Government is for. If you need constant care from your government, then move to a socialist country. In a capitalistic society, the government should not interfere with the free market (except to regulate quality, and to avoid monopolies). Since Healthcare is a service industry, it only follows that capitalism should not allow for government regulation. Capitalism works. Prices benefit the consumer. The problem in the United States is that, instead of the government controlling business, you have lobbyists in Congress controlling the government. Keeping them seperate is the key, and that is the current problem with the healthcare system, not the fact that the government isn't running it.

And there I think is the big split between liberals and conservatives. Liberals would love to see the government running their healthcare system. Liberals (like neocons) WANT big government. This country was established to rid its people of tyranny. Allowing the government to control and manipulate the country ceaselessly will only serve to kill this country. Liberals and Neoconservatives could care less about the constitution. Big government, increased spending, global government. It's ridiculous.

http://www.hecklerspray.com/wp-conte...ger%20nazi.jpg

CarlJr 11-14-2007 04:06 PM

Are you going for a Nazi salute there? How about contributing something worthwhile to the thread, like...I dunno...an opinion?

N*S*G 11-14-2007 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlJr (Post 414416)
Are you going for a Nazi salute there? How about contributing something worthwhile to the thread, like...I dunno...an opinion?

Oh, you got me there.

Look up for my other post.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-14-2007 04:16 PM

Some things are better run by the government than they are privately.

Take Royal Mail for example , since that was privatised thousands of small post offices have closed , many in remote rural areas , prices have gone up , the number of postal deliveries has been reduced , there are more post strikes than ever and bosses award themselves huge pay increases despite not hitting targets.

That has nothing to do with me being liberal or conservative , thats just me seeing an industry going down the toilet since it was privatised and being run for profit rather than for service.

And have taxes gone down since it didn't have to subsidise Royal Mail , nope not in the slightest.

And I wouldn't like to see the NHS go down the same road.

N*S*G 11-14-2007 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger (Post 414431)
Some things are better run by the government than they are privately.

Take Royal Mail for example , since that was privatised thousands of small post offices have closed , many in remote rural areas , prices have gone up , the number of postal deliveries has been reduced , there are more post strikes than ever and bosses award themselves huge pay increases despite not hitting targets.

That has nothing to do with me being liberal or conservative , thats just me seeing an industry going down the toilet since it was privatised and being run for profit rather than for service.

And I wouldn't like to see the NHS go down the same road.

How about we elect people to run privatized firms?

CarlJr 11-14-2007 05:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Urban Hatemonger (Post 414431)
Some things are better run by the government than they are privately.

Take Royal Mail for example , since that was privatised thousands of small post offices have closed , many in remote rural areas , prices have gone up , the number of postal deliveries has been reduced , there are more post strikes than ever and bosses award themselves huge pay increases despite not hitting targets.

That has nothing to do with me being liberal or conservative , thats just me seeing an industry going down the toilet since it was privatised and being run for profit rather than for service.

And have taxes gone down since it didn't have to subsidise Royal Mail , nope not in the slightest.

And I wouldn't like to see the NHS go down the same road.

Well, the government should reuglate monopolies. Multiple different mail services would lower the price and increase the quality of the service. If you've got one company that runs all mail, they can charge however much they want and provide whatever quality of service they want. When you have different companies vying for your money, you get the good deal.

riseagainstrocks 11-14-2007 05:11 PM

Much like package delivery services in america (DHL, UPS, FedEx, U.S. Postal Service, etc.). All compete for consumers. Prices stay low. Monopolies won't form because each company stands to make more money.

It's a wonderful system really. CarlJr is explaining it well.

anticipation 11-14-2007 05:36 PM

thank god for anti-trust laws.

Urban Hat€monger ? 11-14-2007 05:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by riseagainstrocks (Post 414455)
Much like package delivery services in america (DHL, UPS, FedEx, U.S. Postal Service, etc.). All compete for consumers. Prices stay low. Monopolies won't form because each company stands to make more money.

It's a wonderful system really. CarlJr is explaining it well.

When it works it is yes. I'm not anti-privatisation in some cases it works in some cases it doesn't. All i'm saying is I don't want shareholders profits to be a factor should I ever need medical attention.
In my experience of working in the service industry competitive prices for consumers usually means cut corners. And that is one thing I don't want to gamble my health for.

Inuzuka Skysword 11-14-2007 08:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fal (Post 414179)
You're just full of those helpful little tidbits aren't you.

Socialism gives equality. Until equality is achieved, neither is socialism. It's not that hard to understand.

Then socialism can't work under a government.

Quote:

I thought I'd established that without him working in his job you'd be running to the toilet to throw up for a week after every time you ate at a restaurant. Coming from a well-to-do middle-class background may have warped your view on jobs that are good or not, but the bottom end ones are usually the most necessary ones when you get down to it. Being a builder may not be as glamorous and well paid as being a lawyer but who does a greater service to society?
Not really. If he wasn't working his job because he chose to pursue his studies, then somebody else would have his job and they would get paid more because of the demand.

Quote:

And why is greed, selfishness and hoarding right?

I really hope you're not Christian. That would be the cherry of irony.
I never said charity was wrong. I said forced charity is wrong. This is because you have a government forcing you to pay for a cause you may not agree with. I mean look at it this way. Every citizen is supporting the Iraq war financially whether they agree with it or not. Is it right?

Quote:

Somebody should give you a shovel so you can carry on digging your grave of naivety.
Don't make me explain stories about a poor people have risen to the big top. I hear many of them. In fact my friends dad was a poor Mexican immigrant and because he managed his studies, he has been able to be the president of his company in the SA region. He is pretty rich now too. I wish everyone would put effort into what they do.

Quote:

I've been loving Inuzuka Skysword's posts, where he'll say something contentious but pretty valid and then back it up with the worst possible examples. e.g.
I can admit to that. That is why I can't teach people anything. I tried to tutor someone once and it didn't work out well.

Quote:

Which, unless you are talking about yourself specifically and you are already your town basketball hero this is not true at all. Love the logic though.
Look at Sebastian Telfair. I don't even he practiced the routine I mentioned, but he practiced a lot and made it out of the ghetto.

Quote:

A government dictating or a business dictating.
The government has more power than the business so I would therefore go with the business. Governments aren't needed. Without a government people would have more money because we wouldn't have to pay people to make dumb decisions on how we should live.

CarlJr 11-14-2007 10:09 PM

A government free society would survive for 10 years max. Anarcho communism works if you're looking for a temporary government.

Inuzuka Skysword 11-15-2007 03:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CarlJr (Post 414533)
A government free society would survive for 10 years max. Anarcho communism works if you're looking for a temporary government.

Well, I would beg to differ. The only way a government free society would die in ten years is either from themselves or from invaders. Since you have countries who are willing to defend against things like imperialism, I don't think it is that big of an issue. I would rather die then live with a government that made me act like a robot.


BTW. I am into more of a Collective Anarchy.

anticipation 11-15-2007 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414707)
I would rather die then live with a government that made me act like a robot.

shouldn't you be dead by now then?

Inuzuka Skysword 11-15-2007 03:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gentleman Johnny (Post 414711)
shouldn't you be dead by now then?

No, I get enough freedom here in the US. Plus I don't believe in suicide.

anticipation 11-15-2007 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Inuzuka Skysword (Post 414715)
No, I get enough freedom here in the US.

i <3 american mindset.



don't freak out inuzuka, i'm not knocking you.
i just see that mentality so much here in america,
and it kills me.

Inuzuka Skysword 11-15-2007 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gentleman Johnny (Post 414716)
i <3 american mindset.



don't freak out inuzuka, i'm not knocking you.
i just see that mentality so much here in america,
and it kills me.

I understand where you are coming from because I don't think I phrased it right for you to understand.

What I meant was that we have enough freedom for me to not kill myself.

cardboard adolescent 11-15-2007 03:47 PM

None of us are free because we're all interconnected. The actions of one affect us all, we can't choose our situation nor our fate. More freedom for one person means less freedom for another.

TheBig3 11-15-2007 04:44 PM

the empirical statements around here are hilarious.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:14 PM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.