![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Socialism gives equality. Until equality is achieved, neither is socialism. It's not that hard to understand. Quote:
Quote:
I really hope you're not Christian. That would be the cherry of irony. Quote:
|
First let me say that I've read up until, I don't know page 4 or 5 and I've come to the position that you should all get a library card.
Quote:
Standardized pricing takes place everywhere. Try and buy an ipod. Its going to be the same price everywhere. And there will not be some renegade company selling it for less because Apple won't sell you it. Even if they did, you'd be crushed by the bigger stores with more locations and the ability to process more consumers. And in your free market unregulated world, there'd be no federal government or anti-monopoly laws in place to stop them. Businesses do not run, nor care about societies and governments, which operate in many cases as a giant consumer advocate anyway, have to keep the will of the public in mind. Capitalism is a dynamic system that corresponds well to democracy, its voting with your wallet. But if you don't like the laws you can always change the law makers. As for your comment on philanthropy, what are you ****ing 12? Or is your head just up your ass. That was the dumbest ****ing thing I've ever read. Most capitalists want unregulated everything so your philanthropic doctors wouldn't need licenses and if you're going to allow doctors to practice in your country without any sort of oversight, then I pray you get sick first and we'll see how strong your resolve is then you poverty stricken naive invalid. Quote:
Seriously, whats more detrimental to a society? A government dictating or a business dictating. And before you bring up idiot underdog theories again, why hasn't any HMO in existence currently offered up affordable coverage for any type of problem you'd come across? I suppose giving them more power would fix that though, right? Quote:
Newsflash: Everyone that has ever lived was a ****ty person. This is why government works. We agree on things so that we move towards a collective balance even if we're racist ourselves. Its ugly, but if there were real problems the country would have folded by now. We're making progress and just because we were not born a utopia doesn't mean we're inherently bad. And what exactly is wrong with Ron Paul, and where did that come from? Because he cites the constitution? Shouldn't he? Its the ****ing law. |
Sorry I missed one.
Quote:
I'm not sure what you'd know of our system here but you need (and its been awhile since i've checked) something to the effect of 3/4'sof the union agreeing upon a change before it can be ratified. Its generally solid. |
For my, my alignment depends on the topic. I'm very wishy-washy when it comes to politics.
|
I wish I lived in this middle class utopia that some people here seem to want.
Just think a whole society of people in middle management jobs where nobody has any financial problems during their entire lives at all ,ever. I fear there are a few people in for a nasty shock once they get into the real world. Whatever next ? Poor people wanting to be able to go to a doctors? ... damn communists. |
I got a (-10, -10) on a political analysis diagnostic.
That is a hard left, hard libertarian... the antipode of a hard right, hard statist. I am opposite of Stalin (pretty much a (10, 10)), and more left than Ghandi (he was close to a (-4, -4)). So am I a conservative? No. Quote:
|
Quote:
Thats gold. Ha ha ha. |
Quote:
Liberals want provided economy, free social. Conservatives want provided social, free economy. It depends on how you look at it. Do you want either your wallet or your balls in a vice grip? |
Quote:
If that were the state of society then medics would just up their prices and half of the people still wouldn't be able to afford to go to the medics. Either that or everybody would have enough extra cash to pay but the waiting lists would be huge. I think that most of the medic-related problems you see in the NHS result from not enough medical school places being created, so that there aren't enough medics in the first place. If everything went private there still wouldn't be enough qualified medics around to deal with everybody adequately and there certainly wouldn't be enough to create a competitive capitalist environment. In fact, the system would probably be a lot less competitive because the customer wouldn't have the alternative of free state-funded treatment to barter with. We've seen with the railway system here that privatisation can be a complete balls up, resulting in something which amounts to legal monopolisation and as a result much worse services at a much higher cost. The idea of universal privatisation of medical treatment leading to improved services doesn't always work when: 1) Medics have, due to 'old school ties', access to a more organised network of other practising medics and are generally in a position to take part in a kind of informal price-fixing (quite simply, if no medics lower their prices then everybody can continue to charge high prices for the services). 2) In most places there are a lack of medics compared to the demand, so medics don't need to cut their prices to get customers. And the problems are probably worse in small towns/villages where they might be only one or two medics available. In that situation privatisation could easily lead to medics charging through the roof, knowing that their customers have no other alternative. In the US there might be a huge surplus of trained medics, but in the UK that is not the case and I think the big problem is not universal healthcare but the number of people who are being funded to do ****ty mickey-mouse degrees instead of pushing more people towards medical school. More medics = greater supply compared to demand and with or without universal privatisation that will bring the cost of the service down (within the NHS such an action should lead to individual medics being paid less thus you get more medics for your tax-pound). |
Teenagers discussing politics=comedy gold.:yeah:
... OT: Brought up a conservative, went gay. =( |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
And followed by Quote:
Or this chestnut of a counter argument Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
And the tyrant attitude is almost omnipresent on the right. They said because Clinton was trying to socialize medicine she was trying to tell you what doctors to go to, and what you can do with your health. He said "shes trying to rule your life." Its sad to watch at the power junkies claw for their fix. If the republicans don't openly support Paul, their screwed. Quote:
|
Quote:
And who is saying governments are a power grab? I understand there are valid reasons for them, I just don't believe that the regulation of services (not goods) should be one of them. Quote:
These are examples of companies adjusting to the needs and wants of the market. The market decideds how much something is worth, NOT the company. Going back to UHC, different hospitals all want to make money by selling a similar service (medicine, operations, check-ups, etc.). The moment one hospital realizes it can draw patients by lowering their prices for these things, the consumer begins to win. The market doesn't provide for people paying 10,000 for an operation. And buisnesses will adjust. I'd also like to respond to your point on monopolies springing up. This is a place for the government to step in. I never said that they shouldn't. Similar to the dissolution of giants like Bell (the telephone company) and Standard Oil were great steps in insuring the continuation of the free market system. I'm all for anti-trust acts. I'm not for government regulation of an industry. Huge difference. Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
If we go to a UHC system where does the money to pay for the poor going to the doctor come from? ME! As heartless as it sounds, I want my money to be spent on ME or on things that I want to spend it on. I went to school, I studied, I worked, I made money. I'll be damned if my compensation goes to anyone else (minus the obligitory taxes I pay for roads, schools, etc.) Quote:
1. You're assuming that doctors have a devious plan to price gouge at the first oppurtunity. Lawyer's have a job with near the same prestige, and roughly in the same demand. Largely unregulated system, but it still works because entry level practicioners charge reasonable fee's so they can a) get cases as an unknown and b) make a name for themselves. Doctors would be much the same way. A sought after commodity. 2. No one lives in a vaccum. Travel is too easy these days to let that be an excuse. again, this system actually taps into greed. Doctors who want money, will be willing to do a little bit more work. If not, they won't make money. |
Quote:
Nurses are some of the lowest paid public sector workers out there , hell some nurses who work in London can't afford to even live there . Would you like them to all up & leave to become accountants or lawyers too? And their wages wouldn't get better under the private sector either , they'd just go & hire cheap labour from Asia / eastern Europe / Philippines because they have their shareholders to think of. Of course it's perfectly OK for you to have your 'me me me' opinion. Let's hope you'll never be in the situation where you have to appreciate the long hours & low wages that these people have to deal with to make your life better. |
Quote:
Quote:
Besides, you have to cynical of a view of the health profession. I doubt anyone is out to get you (or Benjamin) Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
What it comes down to is different morality. I'm selfish and look out for my own interest. I have enough of my own problems without worrying about others. I don't want to government telling me how to deal with my own ****, nor do I want to contribute to a slush fund where others can use it for their own mishaps. |
Quote:
Merit systems > tradition. ANYONE can move up the ladder if they show drive and aptitude. Again, I think this is merely a fundamental point we disagree on. I see and respect your position, but to me the idea of UHC is repugnant as well as immoral. |
Quote:
b) The very fact that the constitution has 27 amendments implies to me that it's outdated... I mean if you look at the French they've had a ****load of Constitutions, their current one is only fifty years old and they've already amended it 18 times. Either the French have ADD or we're just really stubborn. Both are probably true. c) The fact that we're all ****ty people is the reason why any sort of socio political economic system will never work perfectly. We'd probably still need one if we were all perfect (whatever the hell that means). That argument had nothing to do with my vague points, however. d) I dislike Ron Paul because he is the "CHAMPION OF THE CONSTITUTION," which seems ridiculous because it implies you'll disagree with someone else's views or policies simply on the basis of what it says in the constitution. As you yourself pointed out, the whole point is that we can change it so that it fits with social currents, not stick to it regardless of what happens. e) I am a bright bulb. Thank you. |
Quote:
... >_> :rofl: |
Quote:
And there I think is the big split between liberals and conservatives. Liberals would love to see the government running their healthcare system. Liberals (like neocons) WANT big government. This country was established to rid its people of tyranny. Allowing the government to control and manipulate the country ceaselessly will only serve to kill this country. Liberals and Neoconservatives could care less about the constitution. Big government, increased spending, global government. It's ridiculous. |
Quote:
|
Are you going for a Nazi salute there? How about contributing something worthwhile to the thread, like...I dunno...an opinion?
|
Quote:
Look up for my other post. |
Some things are better run by the government than they are privately.
Take Royal Mail for example , since that was privatised thousands of small post offices have closed , many in remote rural areas , prices have gone up , the number of postal deliveries has been reduced , there are more post strikes than ever and bosses award themselves huge pay increases despite not hitting targets. That has nothing to do with me being liberal or conservative , thats just me seeing an industry going down the toilet since it was privatised and being run for profit rather than for service. And have taxes gone down since it didn't have to subsidise Royal Mail , nope not in the slightest. And I wouldn't like to see the NHS go down the same road. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Much like package delivery services in america (DHL, UPS, FedEx, U.S. Postal Service, etc.). All compete for consumers. Prices stay low. Monopolies won't form because each company stands to make more money.
It's a wonderful system really. CarlJr is explaining it well. |
thank god for anti-trust laws.
|
Quote:
In my experience of working in the service industry competitive prices for consumers usually means cut corners. And that is one thing I don't want to gamble my health for. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
A government free society would survive for 10 years max. Anarcho communism works if you're looking for a temporary government.
|
Quote:
BTW. I am into more of a Collective Anarchy. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
don't freak out inuzuka, i'm not knocking you. i just see that mentality so much here in america, and it kills me. |
Quote:
What I meant was that we have enough freedom for me to not kill myself. |
None of us are free because we're all interconnected. The actions of one affect us all, we can't choose our situation nor our fate. More freedom for one person means less freedom for another.
|
the empirical statements around here are hilarious.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:14 PM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.