Moon made me teary.

There's a few I can't remember but off the top of my head some movies that made me cry hardest (not just a little welling up of tears, full on cascading down my cheeks) are the Elephant Man, Dancer in the Dark, and American History X.

I'm skeptical as to if there's anything that can top Dancer.

Same. I think you'll like San Junipero though.

dancer >>>

i think the only thing that ****ed me up as long term as that was the doc dear zachary but it's not everyone's cup of tea
actually marwencol got me pretty hard too

Lucha Underground

there's also Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

the ending of this almost made me cry. It's not a sad movie (well I guess that part kinda is) I'm just a bitch. That said I love this movie a lot, wasn't really expecting to.

is Titanic good

It has boobies.

Shame about the rest of the movie.

Worse than a sinking ship.