My rating was very good and I still agree with it. I like Watershed.

But after seeing Opeth live and some more listens... Blackwater Park, Damnation, Still Life, Ghost Reveries are so much better ;) Watershed would have fifth place for me.

Opeth never disapointed me :D

Not thier best album, but with a band like Opeth, they are not known to put out bad albums. Personal favorite The Lotus Eater. Overall, very good album.

I absolutely lost my faith in Opeth when this came out. They have steadily gone worse after Still Life. Can't blame them since I consider Still Life to be a masterpiece and it's still one of my favorite albums, but Watershed is a huge dissapointment for me. I don't find it to be that well put together and it feels like a mixtape of bad Opeth songs. There are some good ones in there but as an album it seriously isn't that good.