Quote:
Screamo>Emo>Punk(Anarcho)>Hardcore |
EMO is not PUNK at all-I can see a small connection but it's barely blinking!
|
Quote:
EDIT: LISTEN TO Mid 90s Emo/Screamo band Anomie: www.myspace.com/standardproperty versus Modern Hardcore Punk band Sinking Ships: www.myspace.com/sinkingships Holy crap, that was like totally different in every way ever. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Okay PUNK is an attitude, a way of life. A social situation. Middle class young men bemoaning their love lives (or lack of) does not constitute punk. Railing against the system, unhappiness at your lack of economic status and having political leanings are just some of the elements of punk. Jamming in a garage and releasing a rough demo shorn of a studio polish could be considered PUNK. Releasing albums on their own Independent labels is considered PUNK, not glossy studio numbers. I would much rather put early electro/hip hop along with punk not EMO. For the record I'm 35 I dare say some will now trot out the old classics like old fart etc and I do like some EMO but it is not punk. |
I'm sorry but emo does all those things. House shows, self releases, cdrs, photo-copied inserts, 100 press releases, public practices, sleeping at strangers house, **** ass recordings, cassettes passed, labels run out of basements. All that junk. Emo's got it.
|
Maybe it's a cultural thing, everyone I know would not class EMO as punk over here, and maybe a lot of British punk bands are not known in America and EMO is the new punk-don't quote me-put a previous poster had an opinion of me without knowing **** all about me-I'm beginning to think that this is not a great forum-I was having arguments about genres of music @ 16-discuss our likes and dislikes but there seems to be a lot of petty minded opnions on here (not your self swim).
|
@Mushie.
Ampere, a screamo band from Massachusetts. www.myspace.com/amperepunx Daniel Striped Tiger, a screamo band from Massachusetts. www.myspace.com/danielstripedtiger Antioch Arrow, an emo band from California, they broke up 95/96. www.myspace.com/antiocharrow Swing Kids, an emo/hardcore punk band from California, they broke up quite a while ago. www.myspace.com/officialswingkids Minor Threat, a hardcore punk band from D.C., they are also deceased. www.myspace.com/minorthreattribute http://www.musicbanter.com/hardcore-...on-thread.html |
I'd be the first to tell you that the UK has a pretty shoddy emo scene and that I don't think you know what emo is.
It's off shoot of hardcore which was an off shoot of punk. I notice how you only described punk by ethics I think emo is the most musically ethical-elitest genre out right now. If you sell an emo record for 15 dollars you're an arsehole. If you do a show with age limits you're an arsehole. If you charge more than 10 bucks for a show you're an arsehole. If you produce polished grovel you're a god damn arsehole ch-check out June Paik www.myspace.com/junepaik |
Being from Britain he probably has no clue (even at the time) about 80s hardcore in DC.
It's a shame, really. |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:32 PM. |
© 2003-2024 Advameg, Inc.