Alkaline Trio : Emo or Not?
 

Well, what does everyone think? I'm curious to see what people think... all my friends have different opinions about alkaline..... so have at it kids! :afro:

what do you mean by emo?

YOU STOLE MY USERNAME...bastard....

ha ha i thought you were the same person!

I think there relativly emo. But not because its popular. Its just the sound they've always had and people built walls around them.

haha im sorry jesus ill go change it

[I]what do you mean by emo?[I]

what do you mean by that?? emo = emotional and emo music comes from emotional punk

and i belive alkaline is emo.

I think he was referring to what the other guy thinks is emo. A lot of people have different views on what emo is...like some people even say good charlotte are emo.................

anyway, It really depends on what you consider as emo. I'd say that they do have quite emotional lyrics but that doesn't necessarily make them emo. Soooo many people go on about emo being emotional punk, fair do's but a lot of music includes some emotion : anger, love etc I think emo is a personal oppinion.

Yup...That's it. I'm done

I guess you could call them emo....they seem mor...goth rock tho.... theyre one of my favorite bands....

no

haha its ok i guess...i consider them emo, but i like a couple songs by them. Armageddon(sp?) is my favorite.

I'd have to say I think ALK3 is emo...emo meets goth rock, n e way.but they have thier own thing, and i think they r cool, no matter what the music nazis' say.

Alkaline Trio =not even close to emo

When I think of emo bands, I think of bands that tend to sing about the mellow emotions...saddness, despair, and hopelessness. Also, most emo bands seem to dress and act a certain way(The Trio doesn't follow this trend). Alkaline Trio might sing about pretty emotional stuff, but there subject matter covers almost every emotion known to man. They have been classified as punk and alternative, not emo. Another thing to take into account is their "dark" lyrics. Most emo bands don't use lyrics like that. I would say if they were anything they would be more associated with goth than emo. So to answer your question simply...no they are not emo lol. To be quite honest actually, Alk3 is pretty undefinable if you look at how unique each one of their albums really is.

Sadness, despair and hopelessness are 'mellow' emotions?

I stopped reading there.
As for the rest of the question, I wouldn't have thought they were emo. Wouldn't have thought they were that good either, but obviously they have their fans who have heard a lot more of their stuff than I have (Odd tracks on compilations is about it, and I tend to skip those once I've heard them TBH) so I bow to their superior knowledge....

I can think of a few words that define them, but none of them are positive.

Well, suck can sometimes be a positive, but in this case, it's the negative form.

Sad pop-punk.

Alkaline Trio? Emo?


Hahahahahaha