![]() |
I'd have to vote I prefer the Pixies. Definately a more diverse group in terms of their sound, IMHO. Also, I think the Pixies were more influential. They certainly influenced Nirvana. I remember reading that Nirvana almost left Smells Like Teen Spirit off of Nevermind because they were affraid it sounded too much like The Pixies! Anyway, both great bands!
|
Yep. Seattle movement, or even "Seattle Sound" i suppose.
Genres do get confusing, but then you add sub-genres into the equasion as it becomes even more so confusing. Grunge can have many influences going to it... punk/hardcore punk, metal, sludge.. even elements of Noise Rock, Drone and other styles as well... Each band is different, and have different influences. Get into a band like say even U-Men, who were early grunge, and had elements of garage rock like The Sonics, post-punk like The Birthday Party, and even some psychobilly like as The Cramps.. It is not an easy scene to say it belongs to one genre or any another. Though I am sure quite a few in that scene will tell you Hardcore Punk was a big part of it, Nirvana covered songs by Fang, Wipers and others... Mudhoney covered songs by Dicks, Angry Samoans, Fang, Adolescents, Void, Black Flag, The Crucif*cks... Melvins covered Flipper and others.... Punk seemed to be a lot more of an influence. However, the above is person opinion, I have no citation to back up that it was more punk based than anything. |
While we are speaking of Grunge.. I made a thread that never got a single response... but anybody interested in the scene should take a listen to them, and give their thoughts.
http://www.musicbanter.com/punk/56254-slow.html Slow is one band credited with being the first to play what would become Grunge... yeah, though associated with Seattle, it was a little band from Vancouver, BC, Canada who would go onto influence the scene, and bands like Green River in paticular. |
So I just traded Oasis' Morning Glory and Be Here Now to my brother for Pixies Doolittle. Good trade or no?
|
never heard of the pixies so i still gonna go with Nirvana
|
start here then:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Pixies hands down.
i like Nirvana too though just not as much as i like Pixies |
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:06 AM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.