![]() |
Quote:
But for your last bullet, I think more time would have been needed for them to be signed to Sub Pop if Mudhoney didn't make much success. |
I think Pixies were more influential in their sound. However, you cannot deny Nirvana's influence either, they were a huge catalyst in the rise of alternative to the mainstream.
I think Pixies cavorted more with boundaries, which i'm a sucker for, so i'd have to relucantly say them. |
I mean, I say Pixies even though I like both of their music because I love the noise aspects of their music and the anxiety and unease that runs blatantly through their songs. I actually think I would say in a sense, The Pixies songs were much "poppier" - they were generally more upbeat on the surface... just listen to Debaser, that's more of a pop song than most of what I can think of from Nirvana (though I guess it depends what you think of as pop music, because the term encompasses such a huge array of sounds). The best part? I'll get to hear them play it tonight :D
|
I actually think the majority of Nirvana's output is really good pop music, pop music that is simply played out with a lot of distortion and angst. Generally they adhered to a simple Verse-chorus structure, utilised hooks effectively and created memorable yet basic melodies. It was presented in the 'alternative' format, sure, but at the base of it all was a very sophisticated pop sensibility. Pixies for me just had a bit more divergence away from convention, which for me makes the music that bit more interesting.
And all i have to end with is YOU LUCKY BAST*RD. |
Quote:
|
well pixies dont have that "hard edge" to them but they have better and "understandable songs" than nirvana
|
Quote:
Are you really talking about The Pixies here? Have you heard Black Francis Scream or sing en Espanol? That alone nullifies both of those statements. |
yeah i know they play hard but do they play hard every song? nirvana plays 99.8% of all their songs raw. i didnt mean that pixies never play rough songs but they dont play like that all the time such as "here comes your man"
|
Nirvana had some really poppy songs thrown into the mix too. I think Kim Deal's voice kinda' sweetened up a lot of The Pixies songs.
|
lol ok then, i feel the same way, thats why i put nirvana songs were 99.8% raw because they have some pretty mellow songs as well. looks like we struck an agreement?
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:57 AM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.