![]() |
Quote:
|
Oh gee, listen to this "hateful" anthem; god forbid some British musicians make a song about wanting to remain the majority in their own country. Quality harmonies in this sing-a-long anthem. |
^^are you a BNP member?
|
Quote:
|
it doesn't really offend me much - everybody has the right to air their opinion, whether it's a right one or a wrong one
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
Quote:
I understand the concept of his lyric writing that doesn't make it any less offensive being written in third person. I don't know one muslim who would not be aghast after hearing that song. That was my point, what is offensive to one person may not be to another, regardless of the reasoning behind the lyrics. And I don't think there is a difference in the lyrics honestly, they are preaching about hate of another race regardless of whether they find it humorous. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Skrewdriver is nothing like SOD IMO. SOD had a FEW (if that maybe even one. Speak English or die) songs that were meant as jokes while Skrewdriver's catolog (besides their first album) was pure hate for anyone but whites. |
BuzzOvens argument is: the biography of any particular artist trumps the substance of said artist's work, and that intent trumps content.
Oscar Wilde said biography is the lowest form of criticism. I, and most anyone else who has suffered the ordeals of freshmen art school courses, would agree. |
Quote:
My criticism of this band has to do with what they sing about or is that too hard for someone like yourself to grasp? Well nvm you are a racist as well so you are obviously blind to what they are about since you agree with them. |
Quote:
Quote:
These statements are contradictory. |
Quote:
|
I've not heard SOD but from what I've read from Buzz it sounds like those lyrics were ironic or satirical. Meant to actually promote the opposite of what Skrewdriver promotes.
But again, don't know the band. Just saying. |
Quote:
|
You're missing the point.
The point is: Buzz is saying he dislikes Skrewdriver for their hateful lyrics, which the band genuinelly believes. SODs lyrics are hateful as well, but because he percieves them as having some sort of troll motive, it's ok. So, what differentiates the two bands, according to Buzz, is biographical content, not lyrical content. Such a viewpoint, however, creates problems - such as, what if a musician holds racist views, but the music isn't racist? How do you deal with historical music that is racist? There is a place for biography when judging art. However, when biography trumps content, criticism both becomes relativistic and less informative. |
Quote:
Surely you see the basic difference between lyrical content and an artist's biography. Maybe JS Bach was personally enormously racist. That would make sense historically. Does it affect the listener's reaction to his music? No, not a bit. But what if his music included racist words? Would it change the living public's perception of him? Of course it would. Anti-racists would boycott him and vilify him unless it was an obvious joke. Even I would to some extent and I love Bach (shit, I even like Skrewdriver musically). Biography certainly has it's place in the historiography of music. And the public's PERCEPTION of the music (which I know you are not stupid enough to give much credence) matters, but only slightly. You can only judge a piece of music / art by what you're given from the artist. It's obvious that SOD gave us a joke while Skrewdriver expressed a distinct, serious political philosophy. Both of these facts are informative. Unless you're a young child, I expect you to recognize this. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Yeah those are really funny lyrics, i wouldn't be offended if i was Middle Eastern. Yeah it isn't as hateful as Screwdriver because they are kidding its just a big joke. :) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
You seem incredibly offended by the lyrics. They've done their job apparently. |
Quote:
|
What?
|
Quote:
We know what really happened. And i truly am not offended by either bands lyrics. I was drawing a comparison just to further explore how hypocritical it is to bash Skrewdriver for their lyrical content while not doing the same for bands with similar lyrical content. |
Yeah, I put Mexican at first But I didn't think i actually posted it. He is Asian, it was my mistake, I was thinking of the wrong one. Doesn't really matter though? The lyrics seem equally as offensive to both.
And stop trying to trump the discussion by saying things like "thanks for playing." That's coming off as really condescending. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
First, thanks to everyone who contributed a constructive reply.
Secondly, some minorities do listen to and appreciate Skrewdrivers overtly racist material; the S. Korean band Samchung covered a song from this era of Skrewdriver. Quote:
Quote:
Why? Because the intent of Skrewdriver did not change; but their method of presenting themselves (primarily) lyrically did. So to draw a line in the sand, and proclaim this Skrewdriver ok & this Skrewdriver bad because of "racially offensive lyrical content", and then proclaim S.O.D. acceptable because of the difference of intent.... that's inconsistent. Now, I'm all for some measured inconsistency, but when people blithely present themselves as morally superior because they don't listen to album X or band Y and then present an ill conceived argument as to why.... it's annoys me, quite a lot. Quote:
I'd like to discuss this later, as I don't think a thread on Skrewdriver is an appropriate venue, and (more importantly) I've yet to clearly make sense of it to myself. But there is a weird phenomenon wherein persons such as Buzz find it acceptable to listen to Burzum but not Skrewdriver... and I don't get it. |
Can someone change this stupid thread title.
I really like being a part of a forum where a National Front supporting band is considered to have a 'bold vision' |
**** skrewdriver; hate is not cool; hate sucks, hip hop bunny hop and all other nazis and white supremists, I hate you, and hope you die.
I hate racism. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:42 AM. |
© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.