Music Banter

Music Banter (https://www.musicbanter.com/)
-   Punk (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/)
-   -   Skrewdriver (https://www.musicbanter.com/punk/54855-skrewdriver.html)

Buzzov*en 04-05-2011 02:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1030501)
Not posting here to re-hash an argument. Screwdrivers first album is a really fantastic PUNK album. I actually like a few songs off of their other albums, Most notably When the snow fell. While they delved into white power lyrics after the first album, that doesn't take away from the fact they could really write some intense and poignant lyrics. I wouldn't say they are memorable to many but they often take a hit for their beliefs and thats a bit of a shame as they had some talent.

The problem is they use their talents to spread hate. It is not like a band spreading hate about governemtn or capitalism. Their first album I agree was a great album, but their ignorance took over and they began to spew bull****.

hip hop bunny hop 04-07-2011 08:56 PM



Oh gee, listen to this "hateful" anthem; god forbid some British musicians make a song about wanting to remain the majority in their own country. Quality harmonies in this sing-a-long anthem.

Howard the Duck 04-07-2011 08:58 PM

^^are you a BNP member?

FRED HALE SR. 04-08-2011 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hip hop bunny hop (Post 1032914)


Oh gee, listen to this "hateful" anthem; god forbid some British musicians make a song about wanting to remain the majority in their own country. Quality harmonies in this sing-a-long anthem.

Guys have been singing about this stuff for ages. **** the middle east is a good example. Billy Milano never takes any stick for that song and its highly offensive to a vast majority of people.

Howard the Duck 04-08-2011 10:40 AM

it doesn't really offend me much - everybody has the right to air their opinion, whether it's a right one or a wrong one

FRED HALE SR. 04-08-2011 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1033224)
it doesn't really offend me much - everybody has the right to air their opinion, whether it's a right one or a wrong one

I agree with this assessment. It reminds me of earlier times when people wanted to banish Wagner after the fall of germany. Its art in any form and people should be able to listen to what they want. I only own the first screwdriver album and i own a few SOD albums and thats my god given right.

Howard the Duck 04-08-2011 11:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1033228)
I agree with this assessment. It reminds me of earlier times when people wanted to banish Wagner after the fall of germany. Its art in any form and people should be able to listen to what they want. I only own the first screwdriver album and i own a few SOD albums and thats my god given right.

as I've posted earlier, I quite like their cover of Road to Valhalla

FRED HALE SR. 04-08-2011 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Il Duce (Post 1033244)
as I've posted earlier, I quite like their cover of Road to Valhalla

That is an outstanding song. When The Snow Fell, i find quite well done also.

hip hop bunny hop 04-08-2011 01:03 PM

Quote:

^^are you a BNP member?
No, I'm American. I am fond of Europe's New Right, however, and I do support paleoconservative candidates when I can.

Buzzov*en 04-08-2011 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1033218)
Guys have been singing about this stuff for ages. **** the middle east is a good example. Billy Milano never takes any stick for that song and its highly offensive to a vast majority of people.

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1033228)
I agree with this assessment. It reminds me of earlier times when people wanted to banish Wagner after the fall of germany. Its art in any form and people should be able to listen to what they want. I only own the first screwdriver album and i own a few SOD albums and thats my god given right.

SOD's lyrics were written by Scott Ian as a joke through a character Sgt. D haha. Skrewdriver actually means what they are singing about because they are racist *******s.

FRED HALE SR. 04-08-2011 02:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buzzov*en (Post 1033346)
SOD's lyrics were written by Scott Ian as a joke through a character Sgt. D haha. Skrewdriver actually means what they are singing about because they are racist *******s.


I understand the concept of his lyric writing that doesn't make it any less offensive being written in third person. I don't know one muslim who would not be aghast after hearing that song. That was my point, what is offensive to one person may not be to another, regardless of the reasoning behind the lyrics.

And I don't think there is a difference in the lyrics honestly, they are preaching about hate of another race regardless of whether they find it humorous.

Buzzov*en 04-08-2011 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1033356)
I understand the concept of his lyric writing that doesn't make it any less offensive being written in third person. I don't know one muslim who would not be aghast after hearing that song. That was my point, what is offensive to one person may not be to another, regardless of the reasoning behind the lyrics.

And I don't think there is a difference in the lyrics honestly, they are preaching about hate of another race regardless of whether they find it humorous.

One is meant to actually spread hate while the other is written through a character. What is there not to understand? One is meant to spread hate while the other is not and is simply written as a joke and to piss people off.

FRED HALE SR. 04-08-2011 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buzzov*en (Post 1033375)
One is meant to actually spread hate while the other is written through a character. What is there not to understand? One is meant to spread hate while the other is not and is simply written as a joke and to piss people off.

They both spread hate is my point. Regardless of whether they find it funny, muslims don't find it funny. The only real point i'm trying to make here is there is plenty of hate spread throughout music that goes unnoticed while bands like Skrewdriver get blackballed for the exact same thing. In no way do i condone the aryan nations beliefs but there are plenty of other people doing what they are doing and labeling it something else entirely. Are we through yet, jesus man stop already. :band:

Buzzov*en 04-08-2011 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1033382)
They both spread hate is my point. Regardless of whether they find it funny, muslims don't find it funny. The only real point i'm trying to make here is there is plenty of hate spread throughout music that goes unnoticed while bands like Skrewdriver get blackballed for the exact same thing. In no way do i condone the aryan nations beliefs but there are plenty of other people doing what they are doing and labeling it something else entirely. Are we through yet, jesus man stop already. :band:

Nah I'm not. I see a difference. If someone gets offended by a joke that is meant nothing more than a joke than they need thicker skin. If they get offended by actual racism that is meant to spread hate and hurt that is understandable.

Skrewdriver is nothing like SOD IMO. SOD had a FEW (if that maybe even one. Speak English or die) songs that were meant as jokes while Skrewdriver's catolog (besides their first album) was pure hate for anyone but whites.

hip hop bunny hop 04-08-2011 06:36 PM

BuzzOvens argument is: the biography of any particular artist trumps the substance of said artist's work, and that intent trumps content.

Oscar Wilde said biography is the lowest form of criticism. I, and most anyone else who has suffered the ordeals of freshmen art school courses, would agree.

Buzzov*en 04-08-2011 07:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hip hop bunny hop (Post 1033488)
BuzzOvens argument is: the biography of any particular artist trumps the substance of said artist's work, and that intent trumps content.

Oscar Wilde said biography is the lowest form of criticism. I, and most anyone else who has suffered the ordeals of freshmen art school courses, would agree.

:rofl:

My criticism of this band has to do with what they sing about or is that too hard for someone like yourself to grasp? Well nvm you are a racist as well so you are obviously blind to what they are about since you agree with them.

hip hop bunny hop 04-11-2011 12:41 AM

Quote:

One is meant to spread hate while the other is not and is simply written as a joke and to piss people off.
...and then you said;

Quote:

My criticism of this band has to do with what they sing about
'

These statements are contradictory.

Buzzov*en 04-11-2011 12:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hip hop bunny hop (Post 1034765)
...and then you said;

'

These statements are contradictory.

No they are not. They only are to racist individuals who do not see the difference and try to equate the two when clearly there is a difference. One is about spreading hate because of their beliefs while the other is written through a character as a joke to piss people off. That is not contradcitory to my judging of a racist piece of **** band who actually believe their own white power ****.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-11-2011 01:46 AM

I've not heard SOD but from what I've read from Buzz it sounds like those lyrics were ironic or satirical. Meant to actually promote the opposite of what Skrewdriver promotes.

But again, don't know the band. Just saying.

Engine 04-11-2011 02:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1034795)
I've not heard SOD but from what I've read from Buzz it sounds like those lyrics were ironic or satirical. Meant to actually promote the opposite of what Skrewdriver promotes.

But again, don't know the band. Just saying.

While definitely a joke (unlike Skrewdriver), I think the only thing that SOD was promoting was to fuck around and mock everything and everybody. They weren't a particularly anti-racist band, they just wanted to joke in the most shocking manner they could muster. I do like SOD, btw. Speak English or Die is a really good album.

hip hop bunny hop 04-11-2011 11:14 PM

You're missing the point.

The point is: Buzz is saying he dislikes Skrewdriver for their hateful lyrics, which the band genuinelly believes. SODs lyrics are hateful as well, but because he percieves them as having some sort of troll motive, it's ok. So, what differentiates the two bands, according to Buzz, is biographical content, not lyrical content.

Such a viewpoint, however, creates problems - such as, what if a musician holds racist views, but the music isn't racist? How do you deal with historical music that is racist?

There is a place for biography when judging art. However, when biography trumps content, criticism both becomes relativistic and less informative.

Engine 04-12-2011 02:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hip hop bunny hop (Post 1035350)
You're missing the point.

The point is: Buzz is saying he dislikes Skrewdriver for their hateful lyrics, which the band genuinelly believes. SODs lyrics are hateful as well, but because he percieves them as having some sort of troll motive, it's ok. So, what differentiates the two bands, according to Buzz, is biographical content, not lyrical content.

Such a viewpoint, however, creates problems - such as, what if a musician holds racist views, but the music isn't racist? How do you deal with historical music that is racist?

There is a place for biography when judging art. However, when biography trumps content, criticism both becomes relativistic and less informative.

I like your depth of analysis but surely it's not logical to compare and relate biography to content so much that the core meaning of any song lyrics are defined by content. Actually, I expect you to understand this better than most, hip hop bunny.

Surely you see the basic difference between lyrical content and an artist's biography.
Maybe JS Bach was personally enormously racist. That would make sense historically. Does it affect the listener's reaction to his music? No, not a bit.
But what if his music included racist words? Would it change the living public's perception of him? Of course it would. Anti-racists would boycott him and vilify him unless it was an obvious joke.
Even I would to some extent and I love Bach (shit, I even like Skrewdriver musically).

Biography certainly has it's place in the historiography of music. And the public's PERCEPTION of the music (which I know you are not stupid enough to give much credence) matters, but only slightly.

You can only judge a piece of music / art by what you're given from the artist. It's obvious that SOD gave us a joke while Skrewdriver expressed a distinct, serious political philosophy. Both of these facts are informative. Unless you're a young child, I expect you to recognize this.

Janszoon 04-12-2011 07:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hip hop bunny hop (Post 1035350)
You're missing the point.

The point is: Buzz is saying he dislikes Skrewdriver for their hateful lyrics, which the band genuinelly believes. SODs lyrics are hateful as well, but because he percieves them as having some sort of troll motive, it's ok. So, what differentiates the two bands, according to Buzz, is biographical content, not lyrical content.

Such a viewpoint, however, creates problems - such as, what if a musician holds racist views, but the music isn't racist? How do you deal with historical music that is racist?

There is a place for biography when judging art. However, when biography trumps content, criticism both becomes relativistic and less informative.

You started a thread about "Skrewdriver's Bold Vision". Artistic vision is directly related to the intent of the artist, and thus intent is a logical thing to talk about when discussing vision. Skrewdriver's intent is different from M.O.D.'s and so it is entirely reasonable to treat the two bands differently when discussing their "bold vision".

Buzzov*en 04-12-2011 12:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Janszoon (Post 1035511)
You started a thread about "Skrewdriver's Bold Vision". Artistic vision is directly related to the intent of the artist, and thus intent is a logical thing to talk about when discussing vision. Skrewdriver's intent is different from M.O.D.'s and so it is entirely reasonable to treat the two bands differently when discussing their "bold vision".

Thank you Janszoon. That hit it directly on the head.

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Buzzov*en (Post 1035582)
Thank you Janszoon. That hit it directly on the head.

http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&sourc...T79LWg&cad=rja

Yeah those are really funny lyrics, i wouldn't be offended if i was Middle Eastern. Yeah it isn't as hateful as Screwdriver because they are kidding its just a big joke. :)

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1035587)
http://www.google.com/url?sa=t&sourc...T79LWg&cad=rja

Yeah those are really funny lyrics, i wouldn't be offended if i was Middle Eastern. Yeah it isn't as hateful as Screwdriver because they are kidding its just a big joke. :)

yeah

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1035595)
yeah

Yeah you should definitely play it for all your middle eastern/asian/east indian friends they will love it. They are such funny guys with such a great sense of humor.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1035605)
Yeah you should definitely play it for all your middle eastern/asian/east indian friends they will love it. They are such funny guys with such a great sense of humor.

yeah

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 02:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1034795)
I've not heard SOD but from what I've read from Buzz it sounds like those lyrics were ironic or satirical. Meant to actually promote the opposite of what Skrewdriver promotes.

But again, don't know the band. Just saying.

:band: Insightful you've never heard them how did i know.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 06:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1035619)
:band: Insightful you've never heard them how did i know.

Stormtroopers of Death are a pretty well known band. One of my good friends listens to them. He's Asian.

You seem incredibly offended by the lyrics. They've done their job apparently.

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1035771)
Stormtroopers of Death are a pretty well known band. One of my good friends listens to them. He's asain.

These aren't the Droids you're looking for.

Strange when i quote this it says hes asian. Is your imaginary friend asian or mexican from mexico? Seriously quote it yourself. LOL

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 06:18 PM

What?

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 06:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1035777)
What?

Look at my quote. above yours. I quoted your post about your mexican friend from mexico and voila the quote turned to asian, just curious. Is he an asian from mexico by way of egypt? :wavey: thanks for playing.

We know what really happened. And i truly am not offended by either bands lyrics. I was drawing a comparison just to further explore how hypocritical it is to bash Skrewdriver for their lyrical content while not doing the same for bands with similar lyrical content.

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 06:34 PM

Yeah, I put Mexican at first But I didn't think i actually posted it. He is Asian, it was my mistake, I was thinking of the wrong one. Doesn't really matter though? The lyrics seem equally as offensive to both.

And stop trying to trump the discussion by saying things like "thanks for playing." That's coming off as really condescending.

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1035793)
Yeah, I put Mexican at first But I didn't think i actually posted it. He is Asian, it was my mistake, I was thinking of the wrong one. Doesn't really matter though? The lyrics seem equally as offensive to both.

And stop trying to trump the discussion by saying things like "thanks for playing." That's coming off as really condescending.

Yeah

someonecompletelyrandom 04-12-2011 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FRED HALE SR. (Post 1035795)
Yeah

Touché

FRED HALE SR. 04-12-2011 06:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Conan (Post 1035798)
Touché

Just yanking your chain a bit Mr Slater. I understand why people find skrewdriver unappealing and hateful, it was just my intention to understand how lyrical content can be so different just because of ideology behind it. Nothing more just that, and i had to get a touche outta ya. Ok i'm done i am closing the book on skrewdriver and can now say this thread will never be graced by me ever again. :shycouch:

hip hop bunny hop 04-12-2011 09:46 PM

First, thanks to everyone who contributed a constructive reply.

Secondly, some minorities do listen to and appreciate Skrewdrivers overtly racist material; the S. Korean band Samchung covered a song from this era of Skrewdriver.

Quote:

surely it's not logical to compare and relate biography to content so much that the core meaning of any song lyrics are defined by content.
When judging art, I tend to favor content over biography when critiquing, but not to the complete exclusion of biography. Granted, this shouldn't always be the case, but I firmly stand behind O. Wilde's statement that biography is the lowest form of criticism, particularly in regards to contempory art.

Quote:

You can only judge a piece of music / art by what you're given from the artist. It's obvious that SOD gave us a joke while Skrewdriver expressed a distinct, serious political philosophy. Both of these facts are informative.
Agreed, the intent of these artists (SOD & Skrewdriver) is different, and that intent is important; but when people rail against post-1st album Skrewdriver because of the lyrical content, state their admiration for SOD and then proclaim the 1st album & prior Skrewdriver material acceptable, there appears to be a lack of continuity.

Why? Because the intent of Skrewdriver did not change; but their method of presenting themselves (primarily) lyrically did. So to draw a line in the sand, and proclaim this Skrewdriver ok & this Skrewdriver bad because of "racially offensive lyrical content", and then proclaim S.O.D. acceptable because of the difference of intent.... that's inconsistent.

Now, I'm all for some measured inconsistency, but when people blithely present themselves as morally superior because they don't listen to album X or band Y and then present an ill conceived argument as to why.... it's annoys me, quite a lot.

Quote:

And the public's PERCEPTION of the music (which I know you are not stupid enough to give much credence) matters, but only slightly.
This is a difficult statement. I agree that in most cases popular public opinion has little resonance in the culture of underground music; however, there is group think in the underground, and certain popular cultural ideals remain cherished holy cows in the underground.

I'd like to discuss this later, as I don't think a thread on Skrewdriver is an appropriate venue, and (more importantly) I've yet to clearly make sense of it to myself. But there is a weird phenomenon wherein persons such as Buzz find it acceptable to listen to Burzum but not Skrewdriver... and I don't get it.

Urban Hat€monger ? 04-13-2011 11:47 AM

Can someone change this stupid thread title.

I really like being a part of a forum where a National Front supporting band is considered to have a 'bold vision'

Revolutionarypunk 07-04-2011 10:40 AM

**** skrewdriver; hate is not cool; hate sucks, hip hop bunny hop and all other nazis and white supremists, I hate you, and hope you die.

I hate racism.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:42 AM.


© 2003-2025 Advameg, Inc.